Love Live x Reader [Closed Request]

[ My heart can't choose one ] Maki x Reader x Eli

{ AN : This story takes part in Season 1 }

First Person's Pov

I was sitting on the piano chair, watching as Maki plays gracefully. I couldn't help but admire the way her red hair swayed and her lids that were closed while she swayed along with the melody.

I usually come here just to watch this girl even though it's always so awkward between us. Despite that, I still wouldn't mind because of how attracted I am to the melody and how she looked while playing.

“So, how was it?” Maki asked while looking at me in the eyes.

My body slightly shudders and both of my cheeks slightly become pinkish. “It was good...” I replied while scratching the side of my cheek.

“That's good..Well, I mean I know it should be naturally good” Maki muttered, looking away as she twirl a strand of her hair with her finger.

I know Maki meant no harm with her words and I rather find her behavior endearing. Not many people may agree with me, because they can't get used to it. But I also used to be one of them, that I couldn't bear someone being so outright harsh and make insensitive remarks.

But, I learned from meeting Maki that some people are different and that they have their own depth and reason to be who they are. I am the same, after all.

“I really enjoy listening to your play, Nishikino-san” I told her while smiling.

With her finger still twirling the strand of her hair, she looks back at me before averting my gaze once again. “T-Thanks.” she replied while blushing.

As I stood up and decided to leave the girl be, I was soon stopped when Maki's hand grabbed onto my wrist.

“Hey..I just want to say that I appreciate your presence here..” Maki muttered, her eyes darting around the music room. “And I think of you as a friend so...y-you can call me, Maki.” she added while blushing furiously

My eyes slightly widened before I also started feeling flustered. ‘Did she just..’ I thought to myself before looking away. ‘I can't believe she's telling me to call her by her first name..’

I cleared my throat while looking away as well, unable to look at the red-haired girl.

“Alright, Maki-san..”

At that very moment, neither of us caught a glimpse of the steam that was coming out of each of our heads.

___________________________________

While returning back to the Student Council, I saw Eli working alone on her desk. Smiling softly to myself, I walked towards her and put down the piles of paper on top of the table.

“May I help you, Eli-san?” I asked while looking at her in the eyes. I've always admired the President Student Council, and I know it may sound strange to like two girls at once. But I am also conflicted about it, and yet I could never tell which one would I even date if I even had the chance.

Eli looks up at me with a soft smile before shaking her head. “No, you should be heading home now..” she replied while fixing the piles of paper in her hands. “I can handle this myself so don't worry” she added reassuringly.

I couldn't help the sigh that escaped my lips. I should be used to it by now, knowing that Eli wouldn't accept a hand if it's not Nozomi. I felt a heavyweight feeling in my heart as I thought about the President's relationship with the Vice President.

But it's not like I have the right to be jealous and this is just me being a little too greedy. As I stood there while staring at Eli, my eyes couldn't look away from how beautiful she looked while working on the documents.

Then suddenly, our eyes met and that just made my heart skipped a beat. It was unfair to only have one heart but what more is that it beats for two people.

“Did you need something, Y/N?” Eli asked out of concern while arching a brow.

I shake my head with a smile while blushing from embarassment. “No, I'm sorry for staring.. I just couldn't help but admire you for a moment” I said unconsciously before widening my eyes.

“I-I'm sorry! I meant..” I immediately wave my hands in front of me defensively

Eli only looks at me with a smile before letting out a chuckle. “I'm quite fluttered.” she replied, standing up while walking across the table towards me.

“I—”

Before she could continue, I woke up with a start while breathing heavily. My face flushing red as I wipe the sweat off of my forehead.

“What a strange dream..” I muttered before looking beside me to see both of Maki and Eli in each of my sides.

Oh yeah right, that dream was the past. I can't believe it, that I'm dating both of the girls I had love since then.

“Mhm..Y/N...lay down..” Eli murmured while pulling me back down on the bed, wrapping her arms around my neck. Meanwhile, Maki wrap her arms around my waist as I chuckle nervously.

I guess my problems back then was really small compared to having two girlfriends now. I stifled a laugh before snuggling with both of them.

________________________________

A/N : Imagine writing this while you're sleepy.. Yeah I just did.

Requested by tsunderish_Act