"Arch nemesis by day --- Arched on his bed by night." They say you shouldn't be sleeping with the enemy. Dallas "Day" Haywood did and did he do it with Eastview University's lacrosse star, Knight Evans. Stemming from a clueless and senseless Grindr hook-up with Knight---they say it's just "curiosity" and "one night only", yet the athlete isn't quite willing to let go of the geeky, yet unique boy who seems to know the right buttons to push. The thing is, Knight hates Day with a passion in fear of a ruined future if Day ever speaks out against him, and Day hates Knight because he just doesn't know what to do with this feeling inside of him and he wants a closure. Can they ever find a way to sort these things out? And for the sake of Day's sanity, can Knight just stop acting like a romantic boyfriend at night when he's calling Day a stupid bitch in the morning?