Ten years after the murder of sixteen year old, Kayla Winston new evidence is found to reopen the case in an attempt to finally name her killer. Alicia Adams has done everything to forget the past, including neglecting to tell her husband, Scott, about her friends murder. As the friends come together to help with the investigation after not seeing other in ten years her feelings for Jeremy resurface. Tensions rise within the group as Kayla's boyfriend, Eric begins receiving threats from the killer revealing secrets they had worked hard to forget. Alicia learns the past cannot always stay in the past and that history always repeats itself.