Slenderman
Slenderman had no idea why he spared you. You were just a human. But ever since then, he hadn't stopped thinking about you. He decided to go to your house, to pay you a visit.
You were having dinner with your parents, and some very important business partners. There was a loud crash in your bedroom, spooking all of you and causing your parents to glare at you.
"(Y/N), please go see what that was." Your mother spoke through clenched teeth.
You rushed upstairs, and when you arrived you saw the exact last being you'd expected to see. Slenderman. Sitting on your bed with his hands on his knees.
"What are you doing here?" You asked, "My parents are having an important business dinner and you're causing things to fall!" There wasn't a trace of fear in your body, rather annoyance.
"Oh my goodness! I am so sorry." He spoke, "Goodbye, child."
"Next time let me come to you, if I want to see you again." You rolled your eyes, watching his teleport away leaving you with your ears ringing slightly.
Once you got back downstairs, you told them you left your window open and it made your lamp fall over. And they totally believed it.
Jeff the Killer
As you expected- the creepy guy showed up again the next day. At the same time. But he didn't seem to have his knife out this time. Instead, he seemed amused with himself.
"I decided to not kill you." He spoke proudly, "Mostly because you're the only person I've ever seen naked. But also because you seem...interesting."
"So you aren't going to kill me because you saw me naked? Wow, thank you, stranger. You're so polite." You roll your eyes.
"My name is Jeff the Killer, but I'm Jeff, to some." Jeff said, "We're friends now."
"Jeff the Killer? Wow, that's generic," You rolled your eyes, "I'm (Y/N). Proud to meet you fully clothed this time."
"That can always change," He had this tone of voice, you knew he'd probably wink if he were able.
"Oh, you're one of those? How annoying." You shoved him lightly, "Glad we get to be friends."
BEN Drowned
Detention time. And much to your dismay, when you opened the doors, that sat the annoying kid from the other day. Perfect.
"Hey! I knew I'd find you here!" He smiled. He was still wearing the Link cosplay, god how cringey could this kid be?
"You again? Bug off." You hiss, pulling out your sketchbook and beginning to work on the sketch for your next painting.
"Are you drawing? What're you drawing!?" He asked, does this kid ever shut up?
"I'm drawing your mom," You replied in an annoyed tone, "Please go away."
"Nope! You're stuck with me!" He smiled, "The name is BEN Drowned, call me BEN."
Even his name was cringey, jeez, would this kid ever quit? "(Y/N). You're going to get me in trouble."
"I know." BEN replied, "You seem like a nice person to be stuck in detention with."
"I'll seem even nicer if you'd stop talking to me and let me focus," How was he not taking the hint? "Why're you even here?"
"Because you're here. I figured I might as well stick around you since I got you in trouble in the first place." He gave you a little grin, one that almost made him cute.
"Oh, I see.." You mutter, so now he's stalking you.
"Ms. (L/N), who're you talking to?!" The teacher snapped.
You looked over, and saw BEN gone, but he had drawn a little doodle on the corner of your paper.
Eyeless Jack
A few days after, you saw him again, but this time it was you who snuck up on him. "Boo!" You shouted in his ear, causing him to let out a very unmanly shriek. He was standing outside near the end of your street with his back towards you.
"What the fuck! That was rude!" He sounded defensive. Mad that he got scared by someone shorter than him.
"Don't tell me about rude, you originally planned on killing me." You rolled your eyes, "You take the cake for rude. I'm (Y/N), by the way. Glad to meet you."
"I guess, that is true..." Jack paused, "I'm Eyeless Jack, call me EJ, if you wish."
You stuck out your hand for him to shake, and he shook your hand, "Weak."
"What?" He asked, "I'm not weak!"
"No, but your handshake is. Work on your hand shakes." You began walking back to your house, not caring to give EJ another moment of your time. Hopefully this would be the last time you see him. But part of you wished otherwise.
Dark Link
After defeating the game, you were sitting back when suddenly, your system turned on and Dark Link popped out of the TV.
"Oh not you again." You groan slightly as he sits next to you on your couch.
"It's me again!" He rolls his eyes, "Be glad it isn't Link, he's annoying."
"You're annoying," You reply with a laugh, "But anyways, what brings you here?"
"You." Dark told you, "You're more interesting than the other girls I've run into."
"Interesting? Your brief interaction with me was you wanting to kill me." You were confused, "And that sounds like a really lame way of telling me you just wanted to visit because you miss me." You teased.
"Based off your stats in the game, plus I was watching a little while you were playing." Dark ignored the second half, the half when you called out his stupid pick up line thing.
"That's creepy," You shiver, "Make yourself at home, I guess."
"Great, because I already planned on it." Dark Link smiled at you, "Now pick something to watch, I'm ready to binge."
You ended up watching (TV show) until 2am with some video game enemy.
Lost Silver
You heard the quiet footsteps of someone walking into your bedroom. "Who is it?" You ask, not lifting your head from your pillow." It was nap time after a long day of work/school, and you seriously needed it.
"Luh-Lost Silver," The person responded.
"Didn't I tell you not to come back?" You asked, now sitting up, "What're you doing here?"
Silver nodded, "Yuh-You did, buh-but um, I wanted to uh, say huh-hi, muh-maybe try again?"
"How'd you get in?" You asked, and watched as he pointed to the small Gameboy sitting on your desk. "My Gameboy? Really?" This seemed honestly all a little fake, just someone trying to recover after being caught breaking into your house.
"Ye-Yeah." Lost Silver replied, "Th-That's how I travel."
"And where do you live? Is that in the Gameboy, too?" You decided to play into the whole story he had set up here.
"Nuh-No, but it's huh-hard to explain." He shook his head, "I'll explain it to you suh-sometime if you'd luh-let me."
"Okay, fine. But for now, I must nap." You decided you'd let him try to explain it to you. What's the worst that could happen?
Ticci Toby
You went back to the pond, almost wanting Toby to be there, but he wasn't. Disappointed, you sat at the beach end of the pond and stared at the fish, it was filled with catfish and and bluegills. All of the fish swam away when someone disturbed the silent water.
"Hi, (Y/N)." Toby's voice sounded, he was quiet like he didn't want to disturb the peace around him.
"Hi, Toby," You reply, "I have a question."
"What is it?" He asked, twitching when he turned his head to look at you.
"How long had you been...watching me?" You looked him right in the eye, hoping this would let him know he could be honest with you.
"Only a few weeks." Toby answered, then darted his eyes away, "Not long."
"Didn't that get boring? Just watching?" You asked, you wanted more information from him.
"You already asked one question today. Ask too many and that leaves no room for surprise." Toby said, placing the blade of his hatchet into the water, washing away the new, and old blood.
"Oh so now you're playing the mysterious bad boy?" You laughed, "Okay, Toby. I have to go now. I'll see you around."