Green cinnamon roll
You were at the mall, looking for a present to give Deku. It was your first anniversary present, so it had to be special. Then you saw it, an adorable broccoli plushie. It reminded you to your Deku. You had to buy it!
Deku liked the present a whole lot and to thank you he kissed your cheek. Since then it's his keychain.
Explosion king
You were surfing the net, trying to find a present for your beloved boyfriend, when you found this. A bomb that could talk and say fuck? You couldn't think of anything better, so you bought it.
Katsuki loved it. He always has it with him and loves it when it yells fuck. And to thank you he yelled it to you, if you know what I mean. 😉
Icyhot
You were in a comic store and saw those two cute plushies sold together. They reminded you to Shoto. Well, you had to buy him an anniversary present, so why not?
Shoto loved them so much he sleeps with one of them every night you're apart, while you sleep with the other one, so they keep you together. AWWWWWWWWWW!
Manly man
You wanted to give Kiri a manly present, but it had to be cute too. So the first thing you thought about was a shark, but it had to be cute, so when you found this shark plushie you immediately bought it.
Kiri really loved it and since that day it's on his desk, next to his important belongings, which include a photo of you and an action figure of Crimson Riot. That's love babe.
Pikachu
He's your Denkichu, of course you had to choose a Pikachu plushie! You just had to choose the perfect one. And when you found this, well, you didn't need to search any longer.
Denki absolutely loved it! He keeps it on his bed since then so it's a witness of, well, whatever happens when you two are in there, alone, symbolizing your love. 😏
Raven-kun
Well, what could you possibly give to Tokoyami? He's a dark emo bird, but you like cute things, so you wanted to combine your interests in one. When you found that cute raven plushie you thought it was the cutest thing ever seen, even though it was a dark raven.
Tokoyami liked it a lot, but of course he didn't clearly admit it. He just said it was a nice present, but he secretly keeps it under the covers of his bed and hugs it every night. He loves it.
Sonic
Of course you had to buy a Sonic plushie. There were a lot to choose within, but this was the cutest ever. But there was something missing, so you bought a pair of small glasses and put them on it.
Iida loved it. He put it on his desk, so he could have it near everytime he would study, and remember how much he loves his girlfriend.
Psycho boy
Monoma is your little Kirby coz he's totally cute and he can steal other's Quirk. But he's still a cute little psycho that own your heart, so this plushie was perfect as a present.
When Monoma saw it he started to laugh like a psycho, saying that the plushie was nearly as cute as him. He's so psycho! Anyway, he always keeps it with him since then, saying it's his lucky charm.
Hot villain
You hate to buy presents, but since it was important for Dabi and you to celebrate your frist anniversary as a couple, so you decides to buy him a cute present your style.
Dabi loved it. He found it cute and quite creepy. Lovely. To thank you he, how can I say, showed the plushie a 18+ show. 😏
Purple cat
Shinsou is a purple cat, so it was obvious that you'd give him one. The difficult part was to choose which purple cat was the best. Eventually you chose this, coz it was cute.
Shinsou was enthusiastic. He always hugs it at night when he can't fall asleep, so he can remember his loving girlfriend and how lucky he is to have you.
Shy elf
Tamaki is so cute and shy, you thought he deserved a cute present for your first anniversary. It was difficult to choose because you wanted something that represented him, and this cute octopus plushie was the answer to all your questions.
Tamaki loved it but he is too shy to admit it, so he just kissed your cheek before blushing like crazy. He always keeps the plushie inside one of the pockets of his hero costumes. He considers it his lucky charm.
Hand man
Tomura always hated the fact that Stein gained all the glory and had his merchandise while he didn't. So you decided to create this plushie yourself.
Tomura litterally loved it! He was so careful while holding it, he didn't want to ruin it. He always keeps it with him since then. Geez, everytime he looks at it he falls in love with you all over again. I'd say best present ever.