Puppy Love/Johnny Cade Fanfic

By AnotherOutsiderGirl

29.8K 514 285

"Just tell him I love him alright? I haven't said it to him enough and he needs to hear it again. I just wish... More

Introduction
Part 1
Part 2
Part 3
Part 4
Part 5
Part 6
Part 7
Part 8
Part 9
Part 10
Part 11
Part 13
Part 14
Part 15
Part 16
Part 17
Part 18
Part 19
Part 20
Part 21
Part 22
Part 23
Part 24
Part 25

Part 12

947 18 8
By AnotherOutsiderGirl

I felt my heart in my throat and all eyes went to me as soon as his name slipped out. My breath hitched and I looked down at the ground. Jay? No, I'm going to think about him. He's not worth my time anymore. I cleared my throat and all the boys instantly looked away. "Are you ok?" Johnny whispered to me. "Yeah, why wouldn't I be?" I said with a smile and he gave me a half smile. I took his hand and squeezed it a little. "I'm ok Johnny, don't worry about me." He gave me a full smile this time and I gladly smiled back. "I don't know Tim. This whole thing might make things better or worse. Can we really take a chance?" Two-Bit said. "We have the people to fight them," Dallas argued. "I know that Dallas, I'm just saying do you think we'll have a chance to beat them?"

Tim shook his head and pointed at him. "You really think we can't beat those pricks?" Tim raised his eyebrows and pointed at me which made me tense up. "If we don't do anything about it, something could happen to her." I tried not to seem scared but I think my face turned ghost white. "Don't bring her into this Tim. She has nothing to do with this whole thing," Two-Bit boomed. I almost said something but Ponyboy grabbed my shoulder which stopped me. "Technically she does. After that whole mess with Jay he's getting violent. Look at Curly! Who knows what could happen to her?" I felt Johnny squeeze my hand and I gave him a worried look. "Don't worry," he whispered and I wish I could've believed him. "I'm not going to let anything happen to her," Two-Bit said. "So what are you going to do about it?" Tim snapped back and I could see the frustration on both their faces.

"You want to protect her? Then do this rumble with us and let's get these Socs off our turf." There was silence in the room and I saw the look on Two-Bits face. "Two-Bit-," I started but he raised his hand to stop me. I bit back my words and he sighed in frustration. I was scared of what he was going to say. I never wanted this rumble and I trust that he'll make the right decision. I'll be fine without this rumble. Two-Bit rubbed his jaw and then looked up at Tim. "When is this rumble?" I closed my eyes and put my head down. "That's the Two-Bit I know!" Tim said walking up to him and patting his shoulder. I let go of Johnny's hand and he knew I was upset. "Beth, hold on a minute," he said. "I'm fine," I muttered standing up. "Bethany, now hold on a minute," Two-Bit said. "No, you guys were right. I have absolutely nothing to do with this because you guys aren't going to listen to me anyway." I headed to the door. "Bethany Renae Mathews, don't you dare walk out that door!" I sighed and put on my shoes quickly.

"Excuse me, have a good night." I said heading out the door. "Bethany Mathews!" Two-Bit said behind me but I kept walking. I started heading down the street towards home trying to fight back the tears in my eyes. He wasn't thinking straight. He didn't think that if something happened me and mom would be left alone. I don't want anything to happen to him. I get scared when he leaves the house, how am I supposed to handle a huge fight? I'm already losing my mind over it. I sighed and I heard footsteps following behind me. I ignored it and kept walking until a voice called out. "Bethany, it's me," they said. I stopped and blinked away a few tears in my eyes. I turned around and saw Johnny standing a few feet away from me. "Johnny, I'm sorry but I don't want to talk about it," I said.

He shook his head and I made a confused face.  "It's not that Bethany. I just wanted to make sure you got home ok." The second he finished my eyes softened and I frowned. "I'm sorry Johnny. I didn't mean to snap at you," I said. "You didn't snap at me Beth and you don't need to apologize. I know you're upset right now and I just want to make sure you get home alright." I smiled and I stretched out my hand and he gladly took it. We headed towards my house hand in hand. "You shouldn't have left the meeting. I would've been fine on my own," I said. "They didn't need me anyway. They already made their decision," Johnny said. Yeah, clearly they have. "Are you going to fight in the rumble?" I said looking at him and we met eyes. "I don't know yet. Usually I go if Ponyboy goes because we team up." He suddenly stopped in his tracks and I stopped with him. "What's wrong Johnny?"

He gulped and I got scared about what he was going to say. "Are you upset that I'm fighting in the rumble?" I was surprised by what he said. "No Johnny, of course I'm not angry," I said. "I'm just worried about this rumble. I don't want you or anyone else getting hurt." Johnny nodded and looked behind us as if someone was there. "We'll be ok Beth and I understand what you mean. This rumble scares me too," he said. "Then why are you doing it Johnny?" He met my eyes and when he did I smiled. "Because we stick together during times like this." He smiled and I felt butterflies fluttering in my stomach. Then I realized he was leaning in and I was too. Suddenly a car horn blasted and scared the both of us. Ruining the moment.

Suddenly a bottle landed next to us and broke. I yelped and I heard screaming from the car. "Clean it up you dirty greaser!" The car started to speed off and I saw Johnny pick up the top of the broken bottle and throw it. It missed the car and shattered on the ground. I heard the Socs laughing in the car and I saw Johnny looking upset. I looked at the broken bottle and gulped. I looked down the street and I saw the gang heading towards us. "Are you guys okay?" Dallas yelled and the both of us nodded. Two-Bit ran up to me and hugged me tightly. He held my face in his hands and looked at me. "Are you ok?" He asked me. "They threw a bottle at us. It nearly hit us," I stuttered. Two-Bit hugged me again and I saw Johnny talking to the guys. He was much more calm than I was. "I'm not going to let them hurt you Beth," Two-Bit said. "Never."

Three days later...
I plopped down on the couch as soon as I got home and Two-Bit chuckled when I did. "Long day huh?" He asked as I sighed and nodded. "I swear history will be the death of me!" He laughed and went into the kitchen and grabbed a beer from the fridge. "Here this'll help," he said opening it up and I instantly shot up. "Keith Mathews! I can't believe you'd think I'm going to drink that," I snapped but he only smiled. "I meant for me. This will help me get through your rant," he said. I smacked his arm and he did the same to me. "Are you going out tonight?" I asked him as I headed to the kitchen. "I have work tonight but I'll be home before 10. I expect you to be asleep by then," he said. Yeah, he still doesn't know.

I nodded and made us some turkey sandwiches. We ate at the table and Two-Bit decided to tease me. "So are you and Johnny together now? When I saw you two at the DX yesterday I was sure you were a couple." Johnny and I met up at the DX while I waited for Two-Bits shift to end. We talked a lot and at some point he held my hand and we just kept holding hands until I had to go. "No, we're not official yet," I said. He smiled and looked over at the clock. "I should be going," he said standing up and putting on his leather jacket. He was wearing his favorite shirt, his Mickey shirt. "Be good at work and most importantly be safe," I said. Two-Bit looked at me and his smile went away. After that night I was afraid to go out alone. It turns out they also threw a bottle at Dallas. It hit him but it didn't hurt him badly.

"Hey, don't worry about me. I'll be ok," he said coming over to hug me. He hugged me tightly and I hugged him back. When we let go he kissed the top of my head. "I'll be home soon," he said grabbing his keys. "Love you Keith," I said as he opened the door. "Love you Beth!" He said before closing the door and heading out the door. I did my homework and started reading a book that Ponyboy recommended for me to read. I was too scared to leave the house so I had nothing to do. While I read I put Paul Anka music on. I got bored of reading so I started looking through our photo albums. I found a picture from my first birthday party. Two-Bit was three years old and he was putting icing on my nose.

I flipped to the next page and saw Ponyboy and I when we were three. His parents were beside us pointing to the camera. I miss them so much. They were like my second parents to me and whenever I needed them they were there. I flipped to the next page and saw Ponyboy, Johnny, and I on our first day of kindergarten. I didn't really know Johnny but Ponyboy wanted him in the picture. We all looked so adorable. I kept flipping through the books and before I knew it it was night. I kept looking through the book until the doorbell rung. I jumped and carefully grabbed my blade and headed to the door. It rung again so I quickly ran to the door and opened it. When I opened it Dallas was at the door. I instantly knew something was wrong. "Bethany, you need to come with us," Dallas said grabbing my arm and pulling. "What happened?" I asked but he dodged the question.

"We need to go," he said. "I'm not going anywhere until I know what's happening!" I scared him by raising my voice at him. Dallas sighed and looked away and then back at me. "Two-Bit was jumped by the Socs," Dallas said. My heart dropped like a stone and all the air left my body. My adrenaline rushed through my body and I felt as if the world was spinning. "Ok, let me get my sweater." I said turning around and getting a sweater from the rack. I put it on and headed out the door. I got in the car with Dallas and he instantly pulled out which scared me. I kept thinking a million things on our way to see him. "Where is he at?" I asked Dallas and he turned to look at me. "The hospital," he said. I felt like crying the instant he said that but I fought it back.

"Did you see who jumped him?" Dallas shook his head and I took a deep breath. I had an idea of who it could've been. "You're calmer than I thought you'd be," he said looking over at me. "Oh trust me, I'm losing my mind at the moment." We pulled into the hospital and I didn't even let him finish parking when I got out of the car. "Woah, woah! Hold on!" Dallas yelled but I didn't listen. I ran into the hospital and ran up to the receptionist. "Hello, may I help-," the lady said but I cut her off. "I'm here to see Keith Mathews. I'm his sister Bethany Mathews," I said so quickly I'm surprised she actually knew what I said. She looked in her book as Dallas walked in and joined me. "I know where he is. Come on," he said grabbing my arm lightly. "Wait! Honey, you need this," she said sticking our hand. She put a bracelet around my wrist and then Dallas led me to his room.

I was practically running. He pointed to the room and I instantly ran in. Two-Bit was sitting on his hospital bed talking to Darry. When he saw me he sighed in relief and I ran up to hug him. He hugged me back and let a few tears go down. "Golly Two-Bit, you scared me so badly," I said. "I'm sorry Beth but I'm ok. I just need a few stitches and I'll be as good as new." I smiled and let go of the hug. He wiped the tears off my face and I saw the bandage on the side of his head. "What did those idiots do to you?" I asked him. "I went outside to throw out the trash and they drove by. They threw a broken bottle and the sharp end cut me on the side of the head." I frowned and he clearly saw so he lifted my chin a little. "Hey, I don't want to see you frown. I'm in pain and I would feel much better if you weren't sad," he said. I smiled for him and he gave me his cheesy grin.

I looked up and I realized that all the gang was here. Including Johnny. The doctor walked in and told us that he needs to examine Two-Bit. I stepped aside and Johnny headed my way to hug me. I hugged him back and Ponyboy raised his eyebrows at me. I rolled my eyes at him as Johnny and I let go of the hug. "We'll put on the stitches and then you can rest. We'll check you again in the morning," the doctor said. He smiled at us and then left. "You're staying here tonight?" Two-Bit sighed and nodded. "If you want she can stay at our house. The boys could crash on the couch," Darry said. "No, I wouldn't want to bother you guys," I said. "Johnny, do you mind staying at our house and keeping an eye on her? You can stay in my room," Two-Bit said.

I realized what he was doing but I had too many things on my mind to worry about that. "If that's fine with you then I'm ok with it," Johnny said. "Of course he's good with it," Dallas said winking at the both of us. Johnny blushed and shook his head. "That's not what I meant," he said turning to look at me. "It's ok Johnny, I know what you meant," I said grabbing his hand. He looked over at me and smiled. "Dallas, you mind driving her home?" Two-Bit asked him and Dallas shook his head. I let go of Johnny's hand and walked over to Two-Bit. I hugged him again and he carefully hugged me back. "Don't worry about me. You go home, get some sleep, and I'll be there tomorrow," he said. I nodded and kissed the top of his forehead. And with that we all headed out the door leaving Two-Bit to rest.

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

14.9K 210 19
An epilogue yet beginning to Johnny and Ponyboy's friendship continues as they realize the way there seen and felt towards each other is not just fri...
50K 699 31
At a young age, Loren Areno lost her mom to cancer. Not long after, her dad was sent to jail. Mrs. Curtis let her stay with them since she was good f...
4.1K 171 15
Ponyboy comes home for the holidays and is learning how to act on his feelings. - Copyright ©️ | @-TheFandomLife- (2022) Cover by: @greaserbabes #1...
85.3K 1.4K 15
Ponyboy has been your best friend since the very first day of school, and everything goes right when you wanted to be something more. But sometimes...