Dean: The Phantom of the Opera
Sam: The Lion King
Kevin: Frozen
Chuck: Wicked
Gabriel: Kinky Boots
Balthazar: Les Miserables
Lucifer: School of Rock
Michael: Hamilton
Castiel: Aladdin
Samandriel: Dear Evan Hansen
Gadreel: Anastasia
Benny: Waitress
Crowley: Bandstand