Note: all of this music is music from my phone. I simply hit shuffle and the song that came up is the song that I chose. My apologises if you don't like/know the song!
Slenderman
Song: Gold Rush by Ed Sheeran
Slender had obviously never heard this song before, but you loved it. You sang along to the whole thing, and even did a little happy dance while doing so. He thought it was really cute of you to do that, and when he told you that, you denied it ever even happening.
Jeff the Killer
Song: Jet Pack Blues by Fall Out Boy
You are obsessed with Fall Out Boy, to put it lightly. You hardly listen to anything other than Fall Out Boy. Jeff wasn't a big fan but he tolerated them for you. The two of you sat in silence as this song played, mostly because you're too insecure to sing in front of Jeff. But he still enjoyed listening to you softly hum along.
BEN Drowned
Song: Video Games by Lana Del Rey
Upon hearing the title, BEN wanted to listen. He was kind of disappointed when it wasn't actually about video games..but he did suggest that you put on a sundress and then let him watch you undress... You blushed profusely while denying that you even owned any sundresses. He then insisted that you buy some just for the occasion.
Eyeless Jack
Song: Broken Home by 5 Seconds of Summer
You always cried to this song, because you related so much. Not so much now that you're older, but when you were younger your parents fought a lot. EJ didn't understand why you didn't just change the song, but he still sat and comforted you as you cried. Afterwards was when you had to explain to him why that song upset you so much.
Dark Link
Song: Hurricane by The Fray
You danced to this song, and sang along to it. Sometimes out of tune and sometimes in tune. You didn't actually realise Dark had shown up already, so when you turned around to see him there, you blushed. It was worth it though, because by the end of it, he hugged you, kissed your head and spoke softly, "You're my little hurricane."
Lost Silver
Song: Gasoline by Halsey
Silver was kind of shocked when this song started playing, it didn't sound like something you'd listen to. He was even more shocked when you sang along with the song, and even said the swear words. He really liked watching you sing, though. The way you closed your eyes as you sang and moved your body... It was kind of hot.
Ticci Toby
Song: Gods & Monsters by Lana Del Rey
You loved this song. You sang along to it every time, and you never skipped it. Toby just so happened to be with you today while you sang along to it. By the end of it, he had a whole new view of you, and definitely believed your innocence had been lost. (Though it hadn't! You're a precious angel!) He made some suggestive comments at the end, to which you shut down all of them insisting that you were still innocent.