"Who the fuck is that?" You huffed, glaring at the blonde waltzing up to the bar with Floch.
"An ex girlfriend." Eren said shortly, avoiding eye contact with you. "It's nothing, she's crazy and everyone knows she is." He complained.
You just nodded, the pit of jealousy you felt swelling within your chest not budging. I mean, he chose you. There was no reason to be jealous. But your brain tortured you with images of them together and it made you seethe.
Mikasa and Sasha joined you two, along with Jean and Connie when Floch was dragged to your group with her friend.
"Oh my god, so funny seeing you guys here!" She squealed and your eyes darted to hers, an unamused expression on your face.
"Hey, Historia." Jean mumbled, taking along sip of his drink as Connie was the only one that paid attention to her.
"Who's this?" She asked, pointing to you as she grabbed Eren's arm.
He pulled his arm back, snaking his left arm around your waist and slipping his hand into your back pocket.
"Y/n, this is Historia and her pet rat, Floch." Eren said, deadpan.
Everyone had to hold back a giggle as you leaned into Eren's side, sipping the glass of water he made you drink.
"It's so nice to meet you!" You beamed back, playing with the straw in your glass. "I've already met the rat, though." You added, shooting daggers with your eyes at Floch as she awkwardly stood behind her friend.
Historia laughed an obnoxious, fake laugh before throwing her arms around you. You were taken by surprise, spilling your water on yourself and her a little bit. Her sweet perfume was giving you a headache.
"I hope he's taking good care of you. We all know how Eren can be, right ladies?" She giggled as she asked Sasha and Mikasa who nervously exchanged glances with each other. She let go of you and put her hand on her chest when she saw that you didn't understand what she meant, confusion all over your face.
"Oh my god, you have no idea, do you?" She said with an over exaggerated concern in her tone.
"Come on Historia, don't start drama for no reason." Sasha warned. Your eyes kept darting between all three of the girls, unsure of who to look at. You glanced up at Eren who's face was stone cold.
"What the fuck are you guys talking about?" You said quietly.
"I'm not starting drama! Don't you think she should know that Eren and Mikasa fuck all the time? I mean, he literally cheated on me with her. I just saw them getting coffee together the other day, too! So clearly they still talk." She said as she shot him a disgusted look. Your stomach did a backflip as you looked at Mikasa with wide eyes.
"You what?" Your voice was almost a squeak, nausea rising in your throat.
"Y/n, it's not like that." Eren chimed in behind you and you ignored him, taking a step away from the group of friends.
"Oh, so she didn't know? Bummer." Historia said in a sympathetic way. "Sorry girlie."
"Did you know?" You questioned Sasha, your hands shaking as you gripped the glass of water you were holding as if it would ground you.
"I mean, yes.. But-" Sasha tried explaining. You quickly shook your head and slammed your glass on the table before walking towards the bathroom. How the fuck could they keep that from you? You had a right to know, especially if Eren and Mikasa were fucking all the time like Historia said. You knew they were close but not like that.
"Wait, y/n!" Sasha called out, grabbing your arm.
You ripped your arm back from her and shoved her away from you.
"Don't fucking touch me. Some friend you are, huh?" You said harshly, Sasha's eyes welling with tears as she begged for you to talk to her.
"I don't want to fucking hear it." You said as you turned around and slammed the bathroom door shut in her face. You were so thankful it was a single person stall so you could lock the door. You debated just leaving and going home at this point.
You heard loud footsteps walking up to the door and a few loud knocks.
"Occupied." You shouted through the closed door.
"Y/n, please listen to me." Eren pleaded and your heart sank. You never imagined him being with another girl, especially like that.
"Fuck off." You said through gritted teeth. You were beyond angry and hurt.
"I fucked up one time, okay? But never with you." Eren tried explaining as he shouted over the music through the door. "Please let me in and explain everything to you."
You hesitantly went to the door, unlocking it and opening it to see Eren standing there, his face solemn.
"Y/n, she was cheating on me all the time." He began to spew his reasoning as he stepped into the bathroom and shut the door behind him. "We weren't even really together it was just a fling."
"That doesn't make what you did right." You said lowly. Even if she was cheating on him first, just break up with her. "Two wrongs don't make it right. That's what we learn in elementary school, no?" You said, your eyes finally meeting his. He looked so sad, his face riddled with worry. It almost made you soften. Almost.
"Have you been seeing Mikasa behind my back?" You asked, your tone stern.
"Only to get coffee the other day. We ran into each other when I was in line and we just decided to catch up for a bit." He explained, anxiously picking at his chipped black nail polish as he spoke.
"Did you guys ever date?" You questioned him again, staring at the wall as you felt tears welling in your eyes and threatening to spill down your cheeks. You didn't want to cry, you were tired of being upset and crying all the time.
Eren shook his head, leaning against the door.
"No, we never dated. I think we tried to but it just didn't work out. I don't like her like that." He said confidently, his eyes never leaving yours.
Your head snapped to look at him, the tears retreating as his words made you hot with anger again.
"You only liked her enough to fuck her, then? How do I know that I'm not just a 'fling'?" You said quickly, making air quotes with your fingers.
Eren was silent. He didn't know what to say or how to comfort you, all he could do was look at you. Your eyes were tired and your lips were pink with the redness in your flushed cheeks. He reached his hand out to grab yours and you slapped it away.
"Don't touch me." You spat, moving to the side of him to open the door but he blocked it with his body and grabbed your hand again.
"I said don't touch me!" You almost yelled, your voice cracking when he pressed his lips to yours in a passionate kiss. You tried to pull away but Eren wrapped his muscular arms around you, tightly holding you against his chest as you softly kissed him back. The smell of his cologne was intoxicating and his arms gave you the sense of security that you seemed to always long for. It was a few more moments before he pulled away, his hand caressing your cheek with his thumb as he looked down at you.
"I would never do anything behind your back to hurt you. I love you so much, y/n." He said sternly, his voice a little raspy.
You just nodded once, avoiding eye contact with him as you pulled away and looked up at him as his hands trailed down your sides to your waist.
"Then show me." You said quietly.
He looked at you, scanning your face with his bright eyes.
"Show you what?" He asked.
"How much you love me." You responded, not breaking eye contact with his jade irises.
You saw the adam's apple in his throat bob before he hungrily kissed you again, not hesitating to explore your tongue with his as you kissed him back. Eren's hands grabbed your ass and he squeezed roughly as he lifted you up and carried you to the sink, sitting you down onto the counter as your hands knotted themselves in his silky hair.
Eren's lips moved to your neck as he playfully bit at your skin, softly licking the spots as he continued to kiss down your neck and slip his hands up your sweater. His greedy hands kneaded at your tits as he continued to nip at your neck and you wrapped your legs around him, tightly pulling him closer to you and smirking to yourself when you felt his length hardened though his jeans.
Your hands snaked down to his pants and feverishly unbuttoned them before you placed your hand over his cock and rubbed it through his briefs, inciting a soft moan from him. Eren stood straight and quickly did the same to you, unbuttoning your jeans quickly as he roughly slipped them off of your legs and wrapped them around his waist again. He grinned against your lips before rubbing his thumb against your clothed clit that incited a soft moan from your pretty lips.
Your hand trailed to his muscular back and you dug your nails into his flesh through his shirt, your body begging for more. He craned his neck to the side before sliding your panties over and rubbing his thumb over your sensitive flesh as he whispered into your ear.
"You want me to fuck you right here in this nasty bathroom?" He asked in a raspy low voice, his hot breath tickling your ear.
You smirked up at him and bit your lip, nodding as you bucked your hips forward slightly and tightened your legs wrapped around him.
"Yes, please." You whispered, a grin spreading across your lips at the thought.
Eren just smiled to himself before sliding his hands off of you and to his waist, slipping his cock through the front of his briefs and you leaned down, spitting onto the top of his shaft as he ran his hand up and down it. He hissed at the pressure when he pressed the tip of it against your wet core and slowly pushed himself into you.
You reached your neck up to him, kissing his plush lips feverishly and hungry for his touch. He began fucking you slowly but with force, inciting small moans from your mouth as you both panted into each other.
"Don't be quiet, I want them to hear." He said between breaths, biting at your neck again as you threw your head back in pleasure.
"Fuck, Eren!" You gasped as you felt yourself getting close to your peak. It must've been the drinks mixed with the pills that made your body give in so quickly. Your arms wrapped around his neck, pressing kisses to his soft skin when you heard the door swing open.
You gasped, eyes wide when you saw Historia standing in the doorway, her jaw practically on the floor.
"What... the fuck!?" She yelled, her cheeks flushing with blush.
Eren looked over his shoulder and grinned at her, not stopping his relentless thrusts into you as you choked back another mewl.
"Want to watch?" He said with a cocky tone, raising an eyebrow at her before she huffed and slammed the door shut.
Eren snickered and you couldn't help but giggle too, looking up at him as he squeezed your thighs and fucked you harder.
"I fucking love you." You breathed, your eyes not leaving his as you hit your climax and tugged at his hair.
"I love you too, baby." He said as he kissed your forehead, letting himself finish inside you and you felt the heat of him spread into you.
You slowly pulled away from him and he helped you hop off of the counter, brushing a few stay hairs off of your forehead as you cleaned yourself up quickly and you both redressed.
"Do you think she told everyone?" You asked him, raising a brow.
"Who gives a fuck?" Eren snorted, fixing his bun in the mirror and adjusting the waistband of his pants.
He pressed another kiss to the top of your head and left before you, you both decided to wait a minute in between leaving to make it a little less obvious that you were fucking in the bathroom.
You left the bathroom a minute later after touching up your makeup and putting on some gloss, avoiding any eye contact with other people as you left.
Once back with your friends, Sasha and Mikasa both approached you.
"Y/n, can we please talk?" Mikasa asked you, worry in her eyes.
You glanced at her and nodded, sitting at a small table with the two girls.
"I promise it's not like that. Eren and I had a thing years ago, but he never liked me like that and I moved on." She began to explain, waiting for you to respond. You just nodded, waiting for her to continue.
"We ran into each other at the coffee shop the other day and just wanted to catch up. And when he was with Historia... we were drunk and it was a mistake. It would never happen again." She word vomited, finally taking a deep breath after she explained.
"So have you moved on from Eren?" You asked her, reading her face. Sasha awkwardly watched you both talk, anxiously stuffing her face with french fries she ordered from the bar.
"Yeah, I swear. Jean and I have actually been talking.." she began to trail off and you couldn't help but giggle.
"What?" Sasha asked, her mouth stuffed with food.
"Jean, Eren, and I had a threesome. So I guess we're even, then." You said, shrugging as you stole a fry from Sasha and hopped off your chair to go find Eren.
You found him talking to the guys and hugged his arm, resting your head on his shoulder as you listened to him talk to them about his upcoming fight.
He took the hint that you were tired and wrapped up his conversation before dapping up the boys and finishing his beer, closing his tab on your way out of the bar.
The walk home was quick, as you were both cold and power walked to get out of the winter air. Once home you greeted Bishop and Peep before changing into your pjs and doing your nighttime routine, crawling into bed and turning the tv on.
Eren changed and just put on a pair of sweats, slipping into bed next to you and wrapping his arms around your waist as he pulled you closer to his bare chest.
"Who is your fight against next week?" You asked, your eyes closed as you began to get sleepy.
"Some guy named Colt Grice. Looks like a softie." Eren said confidently, flipping through shows on Netflix and settling on Parks & Rec.
You just hummed in acknowledgment and nestled your head into side of his chest, inhaling his scent as you drifted off to sleep.