Jeff the Killer: Jeffery Woods
Ben Drowned: Benjamin Lawman
Ticci Toby: Tobias Rogers
Homicidal Liu: Liu Woods
Sully: Sullivan Harrison
Luring Lyra: Lyra Rogers
Sally Williams: Salina Williams
Sam Williams: Samuel Williams
Lucille Stoner: Lucille Stoner
Milo the Electrocuted: Milo Moretti
Hung Iris: Iris Phang
Clockwork: Natalie Oulette
Zero: Zero (Alice Ndlovu)
Alma Richardson: Alma Richardson
Vailly Evans: Vailly Evans
Nathan the Nobody: Nathaniel Lux
Crystal the Hidden: Crystal Lux
Eyeless Jack: John Nichols
Lost Silver: Hitori Fujikawa
Kate the Chaser: Katelyn Milens
Charlie Matheson: Charlie Matheson Jr.
Rouge: Heather Marshall
Wilson the Basher: Wilson Pabhu
X-Virus: Cody Pulman
Masky: Tim Wright
Hoodie: Brian Thomas
Alex: Alexander Kralie
Jay: Jay Merrick
Seth: Seth Wilson
Sarah: Sarah Reid
Amy: Amy Locke (maiden name Walters)
Jessica: Jessica Locke
Stripes: Stripes/Eloise Lambros
Lazari: Lazari Swann
Red Death: Sifreid Gadriel
Gas Mask Maid: Marion Gadriel (maiden name Hawkins)
Bleedingman: Alexander Grant
Shadow Walker: Roger Wheatley
Jane the Killer: Jane Richardson
Mary Vaughn: Mary Vaughn Richardson
Nina the Killer: Nina Otis (maiden name Hopkins)
Puppeteer: Jonathan Blake
Bloody Painter: Helen Otis
Judge Angel: Dina Angela Clark
Suicide Sadie: Sadie Blake (maiden name Jakobsson)
Zachary the Proxy: Zachary Gibson
Rosemary: Rosemary Gibson (maiden name Masterson)
Nurse Ann: Ann Faheem
Kagekao: (unknown)
Jason the Toymaker: Jason Mayer
Killing Kate: Katherine Adler (maiden name De Herrera)
Chris the Revenant: Christine Myers
Randy: Randy Harrison
Keith: Keith Harrison (maiden name Brahms)
Troy: Troy Green
Prowler: Lucas Oulette
David Felton: David Felton
Laughing Jack: Laughing Jack
Isaac Grossman: Isaac Grossman
Raven: Manon Plume
Sammy Kingsley: Samuel Kingsley
Lulu: Lucille-Tiffany Greatfield
Dollmaker: Vine Voliakov
Svetlana: Svetlana Voliakov
Candy Pop: Candy Pop
OCs
S.O.S.: Sloan Nielsen
Ella: Ella Brahms
Indigo: Indigo Brahms
Odessa: Odessa Brahms (maiden name Ivanchenko)
Engine: Chase Pierson
Ace of Spades: Celeste Adler
The Mourning: Brittany Winchester
Harbinger: Francis Sandalo
Quentin: Quentin Atjuk
SweetNightTerrors's OCs
Theo Hunter: Theo Hunter
Rapid Fire: Jolene Burke