you (reader) as sarah williams
sarcastic, aggressive, kind, but just wants to be accepted by everyone.
sadie sink as ziggy berman
rebellious, troublemaking, tough exterior, but just young and insecure.
emily rudd as cindy berman
cookie-cutter sister of ziggy, uptight, innocent, but just wants to live a normal life.
ted sutherland as nick goode
junior counselor, know-it-all, bound to become sheriff of sunnyvale, yet likes ziggy.
mccabe slye as tommy slater
cindy's perfect, innocent boyfriend. he's good-natured, yet something's off about him.
ryan simpkins as alice
cindy's ex-best friend, and current enemy, tired of everything, but just wants her life to be normal again and have someone love her.