Hello! So I don't kow if these characters have a canon sexuality or not but these are my headcanon's for their sexualities. Also, Ticci Toby is no longer a Creepypasta and I will not be writing for him anymore. It is also very likely that I will remove him from the book entirely when I go back and rewrite the chapters. Thank you for understanding.
If you guys have your own headcanon's about these characters' sexualities feel free to comment them! These are just my personal opinions on these characters.
...
Slenderman: Aromantic, asexual
Jeff the Killer: Biromantic, demisexual
Eyeless Jack: Biromantic, bisexual, no preference
BEN Drowned: I'm not really sure. I kinda see him as not having a label on his sexuality. I don't see him as straight but I think he would either be questioning or queer.
Masky/Tim: Biromantic, bisexual, a heavy preference for women
Hoodie/Brian: Homoromantic, asexual
Bloody Painter: Panromantic, grey-asexual
Laughing Jack: Aromantic, asexual
Homicidal Liu: I see Liu as not having a label on his sexuality or just going with queer and not elaborating any further than that. I see Sully as straight.
Jason the Toymaker: Biromantic, bisexual, slight preference for men
...
Please remember that these are just my opinions. I hope everyone is doing well. I know that queer is a reclaimed slur and some aren't comfortable being called it. I also know that there are many people that label themselves as queer.
I've decided that I will no longer write for Ticci Toby because I don't think it would be fair to his creator. I hope everyone understands and please don't send me any hate because of it. Toby's creator doesn't want to be associated with Creepypasta anymore and I don't want to write for Toby in this book as almost all of the characters are Creepypastas. I don't want to further associate the character with the fandom.
I hope everyone is doing well.
Ttfn~