Why? Part 2 • Imagine

2.9K 53 37

by squishbitch

by squishbitch

Finn Wolfhard
*read previous imagine to better understand what is happening*

Previously: That night you stayed with Millie, not wanting to be in your trailer. You layed on the couch, a few tears making there way down your cheeks when someone knocked on the door.

You life your head, curious as to who would be at the door at 3 AM. You tenderly lifted the blankets off your body and softly padded over to the door. You twisted the door knob and cracked the door open. You were met with the tear stained face of Finn.

"What-what are you doing here?" You whispered.

"Noah said I could find you here." He replied, rubbing a hand through his wild curls which now looked disheveled.
You made a mental note to kick Noah in the shin for giving away your hiding spot.

"Listen y/n I know you probably want nothing to do with me. What I did was a complete dick move and I don't deserve you, I never deserved you but"
You notice his bottom lip quivering, he takes in a deep breath to keep himself together. "But just know that I love you, always have and always will. Will you give me a second chance?"

You ponder for a moment, really deciding if he meant all those words he just spoke to you. It's like the angel and the devil on your shoulders. The angel saying to forgive him and the devil saying if he loved you, he wouldn't have done it in the first place.

"I-I don't know Finn, what you did really hurt me and I have no idea how long you were doing this behind my back. I think-"
You pause for a moment, everything in your body wanted to hug him, kiss him, tell him that you forgave him. But that was to easy, you had to be strong.
"I think it's best if we stay friends." It took all of your strength to say that to him. You could tell his hopeful face had fallen to disappointment. "Oh." was all he was able to say.

"I'm sorry, goodnight Finn." You whisper and shut the door. You listen to hear the gravel crunch underneath his shoes as a signal he walked away and he did. That's when you broke down. You slid down the door, pulling your knees close to you. Soft sobs escaped your lips, no doubt waking up Millie.

You and Finn had been through so much together. You were a couple for almost 7 months and it went down the drain that fast. Millie comforted you that night, sending angry texts to Finn telling him to leave you alone.

It was hard but you made it through. The cast was always there for you throughout filming but you would always catch Finn staring at you with sorrow filled eyes..

Was this good? Is a part 3 needed? Until next time!

Word count: 493