Looking past them I skimmed over the boys. Two were a dirty blond and one had the same chestnut colored hair as the second girl. Probably related, I guessed. One of the blonds stuck out to me for some reason. There was just something about him. He was bent forward, laughing, so I couldn’t really get a good look at him. The other blond was laughing as well, but not entirely hunched over. Looking at him, I recognized the jaw line and cheekbones. He was a werewolf. Looking over everyone else, I saw they all were. Was everyone in this town a freaking werewolf? I stifled my bewilderment about how many were’s there were when I realized they were walking towards the store I was in. I ducked my head and moved behind a rack. I was suddenly nervous for them to see them, and I didn’t have the slightest clue why. The door opened and the musky scent of them came over me.

            “I just have to grab a quick present for Leah. I totally forgot to do it yesterday, and with that BBQ tonight I won’t have time to get it.” The brunette was explaining as she walked in, with everyone close on her heels. Up close I saw she had soft brown eyes, and a kind heart shaped face. The guy with the same color hair had the same face, except somehow manlier. Stronger.

            The blond nodded and I looked at her closely too. She had dark blue eyes and a gentle smile. Both of the girls looked nice, but, as I should know, looks can be deceiving. I don’t exactly look like a wolf, but I am one. The three guys were even better looking in person. They walked to the other end of the store and I waited. Waited to see some kind of reaction to my scent. Only one person seemed slightly puzzled, the blond guy who I’d felt a weird attraction to when looking at him.

            “Is it me, or is there a strange scent on here?” he asked quietly, but with my senses I could easily hear him. From where I was, they couldn’t yet see me.

            “Well, yeah. It smells like a werewolf, but what’s new about that. Actually, hold on,” the blond said sniffing. I held my breath. “I don’t recognize the scent. And I know everyone’s scent.” She said after a second.

            Making a quick decision, I decided to move from my spot and at least try and act normal. If they were going to find me, I didn’t want to look like some scared, little pup. I was Sutton Collins. The girl who was rarely afraid. Though, with them around something in me seemed vulnerable. And I didn’t like that feeling. Moving away from the rack I was hiding behind, I walked forward to wear a table full of necklaces was. From here, the group still couldn’t quite see me, but at least it wouldn’t look like I was hiding.

            “Do you think one of the new ones is here? I’m so psyched to go to their BBQ tonight. I hear they have a daughter our age and she’s bangin’.” A guy’s voice said. New ones? Is there someone else new in town? And what BBQ are they talking about?

            “Dog.” The blond said, chuckling and forgetting about my scent for a second. I let out a breath of relief. Big mistake. They heard that. Suddenly, I felt five pairs of eyes stare at my back. I tensed, sensing that “something” I’d been feeling was about to happen. My sister saved me.

            “Second day here, and I’ve already made a new friend.” Taylor said, nodding towards Sadie. I smiled at her, trying to act normal.

            “Uhh, Tay. I think I’m done here, why don’t we get home. We’ve been gone awhile and we still have some unpacking to do.” I told her, and pulled her with me towards the door without giving her a chance to reply.

            They were there so suddenly, I caught my breath. Both the girls from the group were standing in front of me, smiling eagerly. Looking carefully at them, I saw nothing but friendliness and kindness in their faces. Back in New York, if you looked like either of them you were a royal bitch. However, I got the feeling these two girls were the sweetest people I’d ever meet.

            “Hello. Your Sutton right? Just moved here from New York. I’m Elise,” the brunette spoke first. She smiled again. I gave a tentative smile and nodded. Wait, how does she know my name? That’s right, everyone knows my name already.

            “She makes it her job to know everyone before they even meet her. I just prefer to go the old fashioned way and get to know them when I oh, I don’t actually meet them,” The blond girl said, laughing. I laughed softly with her. Already my feelings were at ease with these two girls. I can’t figure out why I’d been so nervous to meet them. “I’m Lisa” she said.

            “I guess this is the part where I say I’m Sutton and I say how I’m new here, but you guys already know that.” I said to them, laughing again. They joined in and we smiled warmly at each other. We were going to be good friends, I just knew it. And judging from their expressions, so did they.

            “Sut, let’s go already. I want to go home and try on all my clothes again.” Taylor’s impatient voice cut in. I looked at her, slightly annoyed but reluctantly nodded. I turned to apologize, but Elise and Lisa were already a step ahead of me.

            “It’s alright. We’ll see you tonight at the BBQ” Lisa said, hugging me. After a moment of surprise I hugged her back, and then was enveloped in Elise’s hug.

            “We do hugs here” She explained. “Ok, just me and Lisa do. But we already know you’re going to be one of our best friends, so it just felt natural to hug you.” I nodded and started walking towards the door, flashing them a quick smile. I had just reached the door, with Taylor already outside when it registered that Lisa had said she’s see me tonight at the BBQ. What BBQ? I turned around to ask her, when I saw that all three guys were staring at me. The brown haired one and one of the blondes held open curiosity on their faces. The other blond guy was staring at me as well, and as our gazed locked something in me clicked. It’s hard to say what held my gaze with him, just that I had this feeling wash over me. The air seemed electric and alive. The guy was looking at me in awe. His eyes held many emotions. Happiness, joy, awe, and one that looked startlingly like…love? No, it wasn’t love, I told myself. Staring at him, I couldn’t help but see how amazingly good looking he was. Perfectly tanned skin, piercing blue eyes that seemed to twinkle, high cheekbones, and perfect lips that pulled into a smile, revealing two rows of white teeth. I felt weak kneed.

            We probably looked like idiots, standing there smiling and staring at each other, but in that moment the whole world danced away and left just me and him. I got the overwhelming urge to run over and wrap myself in his arms, never letting go. God, what was wrong with me? Get it together, I commanded myself. I tried to tear my eyes away, but that pesky feeling returned. I almost did run to him, I probably would have, had his phone not rung and interrupted our little staring fest. He frowned slightly at the interruption and I took that as an opportunity to turn quickly and practically run out. Sparks filled the air, and everything else seemed to fade away for a moment. My sister regarded me with a curious look, having just seen that little stare off. I pointedly ignored her, and walked down the street briskly. My wolf for some odd reason didn’t like me walking away and begged me to go back. I told her to shut up tried to still my swirling thoughts, focusing on just one.

What the hell just happened?

I'm Sorry, Did You Say Mate?Where stories live. Discover now