"Is THE Toni Shalifoe asking little ole me to the movies?" She asked smirking
"I guess so" I responded
"I will love to go to the movies with you, what do you say I'll pick you up at 8:00pm? Reagan asked
"Yeah be ready" I spoke before walking off smiling then I saw Martha standing at the lockers
I walked over there
"I'm gonna kill you" I spoke
"So what did you guys talk about?" Martha asked nudging me
"She's picking me up for movies tonight at 8:00" I spoke smiling
"You're welcome?" Martha spoke
Shelby walked over... "for what?" She asked not minding her business
"I got Toni a date tonight at 8:00" Martha spoke smirking
"It's not a date we're just going to the movies" I spoke opening my locker
"With who?" Shelby asked
"This new girl Reagan, you should see the way Toni looks at her, looks like Toni is in love" Martha spoke playful hitting me on the arm
"Okay guys see y'all later" Shelby spoke walking away
Shelby pov
Why would she like this Reagan girl she seems weird.
She don't even look like Toni's type
Why do I care so much
"Hey babe" Andrew spoke coming up to me
"Hey" I spoke pecking him on the lips
"What's wrong you seem off?" He asked
"Nothing, I'm just tired of school, I just wanna go out or something, do you wanna take me to the movies tonight?" I asked
"Mmm sure why not, I'm not doing nothing" he responded shrugging
"Okay pick me up at 8:00" I spoke kissing his cheek and walking away
______
I don't know why it bothers me so much that Toni's going on a date, but ima be there to with Andrew and see how she feels about that
I got dress and put my dentures in
Even though we was going to the movies I dressed all the way up and did my full makeup cause for some reason I want Toni to see me
"Honey Andrew is here" my mom yelled
"Coming" I responded putting on some lipstick
I walked downstairs to see Andrew
"Hey babe" he spoke hugging me
"Hey" I responded
"Have fun guys but not too much fun" my dad spoke
"Thank you Mr. Goodkind" Andrew spoke opening the door
"You're welcome, may God be with you" my dad spoke
"You to" Andrew responded
*
We made it to the movies at 8:28
Reagan and Toni in front of us
"Can I get two tickets for Annabelle" Toni spoke
Toni handed the lady the money and she handed them the tickets
"The movies starts at 8:30" the lady said to them causing them to nod their heads and walk away
We got to the ticket stand
"Whatchu wanna watch?" Andrew asked
"Annabelle" I answered
"I thought you hate scary movies" he said looking confused
"I know but I just really wanna see Annabelle" I responded
He shrugged
"Two Annabelle tickets" Andrew spoke to the lady at front
_____
Toni pov
Me and Reagan sat in the second from the back row
A few seconds later I seen Shelby and Andrew come in, they decided to sit right behind us
Finally after the long commercial the movie started
Reagan grabbed my arm and wrapped it her as she leaned on me
A couple of minutes already in the movie and Reagan was already scared
She buried her face in my neck
"Tell me what happens" she whispered causing me to chuckle
"No, come on you have to watch, you told me you aren't afraid of scary movies" I spoke trying to make her watch
"This is different because it's based on a true story, which makes it ten times scarier" she responded
"True, but it's not that scary once you look at it, how about this I go get us some snacks and you watch the movie and tell me what happens" I said
"Yeah" she responded
"Whatchu want?" I asked
"Get a big thing of popcorn for us to share and I want a large cherry icy" she responded
I nodded before getting up and going to the concession stand
As I was grabbing the snacks Shelby walked in
"Hey Toni" Shelby says
"Hey" I spoke examining her body
"You look great, a little to dress for the movies but you look great" I spoke
"Thanks, so um the Reagan girl you like her?" She asked
"I guess, she's pretty cool" I spoke shrugging
"Oh that's good, I'm in a relationship, you getting into one" she said sounding a little weird
"Are you okay?" I asked
"Yeah I'm good but I do want to talk to you, I can't lie Toni I'm jea-
Reagan cut her off by walking in
"Toni our snacks" she spoke
"Oh right, already Shelby" I spoke walking over to Reagan as we walked back into the movies
YOU ARE READING
It's always been you (Shelby and Toni story)
FanfictionA girl name Toni fell in love with a girl name Shelby the only problem is Shelby ain't come out yet because she is religious and scared her family will disown her and Toni is gay and proud. Will this effect there relationship? Will they end up toget...
Part 4
Start from the beginning
