Story cover for What I Should Have Done ✓ by katrin_writes
What I Should Have Done ✓
  • WpView
    Reads 9,719
  • WpVote
    Votes 636
  • WpPart
    Parts 49
  • WpHistory
    Time 7h 14m
  • WpView
    Reads 9,719
  • WpVote
    Votes 636
  • WpPart
    Parts 49
  • WpHistory
    Time 7h 14m
Complete, First published Jun 10, 2020
|*| Ambassador-featured |*| 2022 Bootcamp Mentee |*|

Grace Bellamy knows exactly how her junior year at a prestigious New England liberal arts college will go: good grades, an established social niche, and a clear vision for the future, all to stay on track for grad school and a successful career in psychology. None of these plans include the charming, but unavailable soccer player John Jay.

But then her carefully constructed plans threaten to collapse like a house of cards: her academic goals are put in jeopardy, old family wounds break open, and, on top of all, trying not to fall for the athlete who represents all the privilege she despises proves more and more difficult-and leaves her boyfriend less and less understanding of their friendship. When given an opportunity and an ultimatum, Grace is forced to question if her values and beliefs are really her own. Suddenly she stands to lose it all. Can she figure out in time what she truly wants?


Word count: ~100,000
Content warning: some swearing, one non-explicit scene of harassment (warning included in chapter)

Previously or currently featured on @NA, @NewAdultReads, @newlywrittenbooks, and @StoriesUndiscovered.
All Rights Reserved
Sign up to add What I Should Have Done ✓ to your library and receive updates
or
#5status
Content Guidelines
You may also like
Tangled Hearts | 18+ by RennyTee
70 parts Complete Mature
[BOOK 1] What they have is messy, reckless, and impossible to walk away from🦋 ************* "I won't leave" I whisper, and he smiles, "I know, baby" he says softly, and my lips tug upwards into a smile. "You're the exception" he continued, his tone tender as he pressed a short, sweet kiss to my forehead. I didn't know it then, but I started falling in love with Finn Brookes, we were each other's exceptions. * * * Lily Garcia didn't come to university looking for love-especially not with someone like Finn Brooks. He's charming, infuriating, and a walking complication she doesn't need. But no matter how hard she tries to keep her distance, there's something about him that feels like gravity, pulling her closer with every encounter. Beneath his cocky exterior, she senses the fractures he tries to hide-the same ones she's been running from her entire life. Finn's been through hell, and love isn't part of the plan. He's good at keeping his walls high, locking out anyone who might get too close. But then Lily shows up, and suddenly his carefully controlled life begins to unravel. She's everything he didn't know he was missing, and that scares him more than he's willing to admit. But with their pasts threatening to destroy what they could be, and old friends trying to drive a wedge between them, trust becomes their biggest hurdle. And when a new love interest steps into the picture, everything Lily and Finn thought they were building starts to fall apart. Fighting their demons was never supposed to include each other, but now they have to decide if the risk of heartbreak is worth the reward of finally letting someone in.
Half of My Heart ✔️ by koolkenz
68 parts Complete Mature
how far would you go . . . for someone you love? ♔ Levi steps forward, placing himself between me and Jack. Like he's protecting me from him. But I don't need protecting, certainly not from Jack. "Who do you think you are, dude?" Levi spits, getting in Jack's face. "Look, Scarlett was just helping me out with a proj-" "I'm not your dude," Jack bites, and I want to tear my hair out of my head. This is going downhill very fast. Jack turns to me. "Scar, we need to talk," he says lowly. Then loud enough for Levi to hear, "So can you please get this kid to leave." "Hey, you don't get to come in here and start ordering her around," Levi says harshly. "You don't control her." "And you think that you do?" Jack spits. ♔ When Scarlett moved off to college, she hoped to start anew and find her way in this world alone. Two problems. One: her older brother goes to the same college, and it seems like he's everywhere, keeping her from doing everything she hoped to do as a college freshman. Two: her brother's devastatingly handsome best friend also seems hell-bent on ruining her college experience . . . but in a different way. Their paths keep crossing, and Scarlett is reminded of the powerful attraction that they've both ignored for far too long. Not to mention, a new face begins to occupy everyday Scarlett's thoughts. When Scarlett is paired with an allusive, darkly handsome stranger for a film project, her world begins to open in ways she never thought possible. But as his mystery unravels into dark secrets, she wonders if she's falling a bit too hard. Before long, Scarlett is forced to realize that balancing the hearts of two boys at once just might result in the breaking of her own.
𝐄𝐃𝐔𝐂𝐀𝐓𝐄 𝐌𝐄 [𝟏𝟖+] by havennoelle
36 parts Ongoing Mature
His student is off-limits...but the temptation to have her is much greater. ❧ 𝐑𝐎𝐒𝐄 𝐖𝐈𝐍𝐖𝐀𝐑𝐃 is a stubborn, hardworking, and studious twenty-one-year-old senior at Darwin State. She's worked two jobs and relied on her academic scholarship to pay her way through her years at the prestigious university. Her life isn't all that, but she knows better days are ahead. ❧ 𝐑𝐎𝐌𝐀𝐍 𝐖𝐇𝐈𝐓𝐋𝐎𝐂𝐊 is a dominant, alluring, and passionate thirty-three-year-old Business Professor at Darwin State, now entering his third year of teaching. His parents are the largest donors to the university, so rules don't necessarily apply to him. But coming from a wealthy family doesn't always mean happiness. What happens when Rose walks into Roman's lecture on the first day of her last semester? They both know it's wrong, yet they still test the waters. It could cost them everything, but are they willing to risk it for true love? It's forbidden. It's tempting. It's addictive. ✎ 📈 HIGHEST RANKINGS: ☻ #1 in university | 12/02/2024 ☻ #1 in goodgirl | 03/13/2025 ✎ 🚨 PLEASE READ THE DISCLAIMERS/CHARACTERS PAGE TO SEE THE WARNINGS, TROPES, ETC. READING THE PROLOGUE WILL ALSO HELP YOU UNDERSTAND THE BOOK BETTER. 💌 THANK YOU FOR READING! DON'T FORGET TO ADD, VOTE, COMMENT, AND SHARE! 📋 PLAGIARIZING ANY PART OF THIS BOOK OR BOOK COVER IN ANY FORM IS STRICTLY PROHIBITED. 📕 BOOK COVER BY: @havennoelle Copyright © 2024-2026 by Haven Noelle
You may also like
Slide 1 of 10
Tangled Hearts | 18+ cover
Law of Attraction cover
1.1 Worth The Fight | ✔ cover
Loving Her cover
Blackout ✓ cover
Long overdue cover
[Not Just Any Other] Ghost Story cover
Half of My Heart ✔️ cover
Silent Love cover
𝐄𝐃𝐔𝐂𝐀𝐓𝐄 𝐌𝐄 [𝟏𝟖+] cover

Tangled Hearts | 18+

70 parts Complete Mature

[BOOK 1] What they have is messy, reckless, and impossible to walk away from🦋 ************* "I won't leave" I whisper, and he smiles, "I know, baby" he says softly, and my lips tug upwards into a smile. "You're the exception" he continued, his tone tender as he pressed a short, sweet kiss to my forehead. I didn't know it then, but I started falling in love with Finn Brookes, we were each other's exceptions. * * * Lily Garcia didn't come to university looking for love-especially not with someone like Finn Brooks. He's charming, infuriating, and a walking complication she doesn't need. But no matter how hard she tries to keep her distance, there's something about him that feels like gravity, pulling her closer with every encounter. Beneath his cocky exterior, she senses the fractures he tries to hide-the same ones she's been running from her entire life. Finn's been through hell, and love isn't part of the plan. He's good at keeping his walls high, locking out anyone who might get too close. But then Lily shows up, and suddenly his carefully controlled life begins to unravel. She's everything he didn't know he was missing, and that scares him more than he's willing to admit. But with their pasts threatening to destroy what they could be, and old friends trying to drive a wedge between them, trust becomes their biggest hurdle. And when a new love interest steps into the picture, everything Lily and Finn thought they were building starts to fall apart. Fighting their demons was never supposed to include each other, but now they have to decide if the risk of heartbreak is worth the reward of finally letting someone in.