The Neighbor

By batchofhiddles

75K 2.7K 306

Cassie is a struggling writer in Chicago. She deems her life as pretty fulfilling, but the only thing she's m... More

Any Other Day
The Morning After
Just the Way I Like It
Breaking Bad
Something Sweet
A Gentleman in the Streets and A Freak in the Sheets
In Dreams
Ownership
Suspicions and Surprises
Harsh Goodbyes
Sister's Night In
For Your Head...For Your Heart
Baby Steps
Meet the Parents
Moment of Truth
Sickingly Happy
A/N
Cutting it Close
Barbecue
June, 1994
New Faces
Unfortunate Encounters
It's Time
You Shouldn't Have Said That
Public Affairs
Court Date
Lurking
My Name is Chuck
Thirty Days
Dark Corners
That Damn Scrapbook
The Waiting Game
Videotapes
Correcting the Problem
Visitation Hours
Home (Not so) Sweet Home
Slowly
The Calm Before the Storm
Curiosity Killed the Cat
The Storm
Sequel!!

Party Foul

2.3K 75 10
By batchofhiddles

"Love, are you ready to go?" Ben called as he walked down the hall in Cassie's place with an overnight bag in one hand and a small, neatly wrapped box in the other. They were going to Halyee's birthday party at Timothy O'Tool's Pub. It was a great place and Cassie couldn't wait to show Ben off to the friends he hasn't met yet. 

Ben walked into her bedroom to see her struggling to put on a necklace. He chuckled and asked, "Need help?" Cassie turned to him and smiled. "Actually, this thing is so old, I think I need a new chain. I'm afraid I'll lose it tonight if I put it on." She put the necklace back in her jewelry box and Ben couldn't help but notice her looking a little sad when she did. "Good thing I bought this for you, then," he told her, while holding up his hand with the small box. Cassie gave him a look that said, "Really?" She took it anyways and unwrapped the paper. When she opened the box, she gasped and put her hand over her heart. "Oh, Ben," she cooed. She took out a beautiful silver necklace with the letter B and a diamond on it. It was so thoughtful and sweet, she wanted to cry. 

"B for Ben," she whispered to herself. She looked up at him and said, "I love it so much. Thank you, babe." Ben almost looked relieved that she liked it. She turned her back to him and asked over her shoulder, "Help me put it on?" He smiled and took the necklace from her. He swept her hair away from her neck and put the silver jewel around it, and then clipped it on. Before she could turn around, he started placing gentle kisses on her neck. She giggled and turned to face him. He wrapped his arms around her and pulled her close. "Now everyone will know," he whispered. "I can stop doing this." He traced his finger around one of the many hickeys he's given her on her neck. 

He's been keeping the "you are mine" bit to himself, but he always found ways to remind her or show everyone. It was always love bites on her collarbone or neck for everyone, but to remind her, he'd leave them on her stomach, breasts, or even her bum. She didn't mind because they were signs of affection. She wasn't going to complain.

"Ready to go?" He asked after a moment. She nodded, but stood up on her tippy toes to give him a smooch. "I love you. Thank you," she said against his lips. He gave her a peck and said, "You're welcome. And I love you, too." He entertwined their hands and started leading her out of her room. Once they were by her door, he took her jacket and helped her put it on, while saying, "You look gorgeous, by the way." He was hungrily eyeing her silk, purple, knee length dress. Cassie blushed, but told him, "You look pretty hot, yourself." He was wearing a white button up, black blazer, and jeans. They were staring each other up and down, both clearly aroused. "If we don't leave now, I won't promise letting you out of bed the entire week," Ben purred. Cassie really didn't want to miss Haylee's party, so she took Ben's hand and led him out the door.

**

As soon as the two arrived at the pub, Cassie and Ben were surrounded by the people she hasn't introduced him to. Ben being Ben, quickly charmed them up and was soon dragged away by the other boyfriends, while Cassie was whisked away by the girlfriends. She was sitting in between Haylee and Sarah, listening to Pheobe talk about her recent trip, when she felt a pair of eyes boring into her. She smiled and decided to tease Ben by not looking back at him. She continued to listen and continued to feel his eyes on her, so after a few minutes, she glanced over to him...but he wasn't looking at her. As a matter of fact, he had his back to her. 

She thought that was a bit odd, so she just ignored the feeling. After Pheobe was done telling her story, Cassie and Sarah decided to go get some drinks. They each ordered the same (Whiskey on the rocks) and while they waited, made some small talk. "So, how are you and Ben doing?" Sarah asked. Cassie smiled and told her, "Good. He got me this today." She showed her the necklace and Sarah's mouth just about dropped to the floor. "B for Ben?" She asked with a tone of awe. Cassie giggled and nodded. "That's so sweet," Sarah whined. "Why can't Alec do shit like that?" They both laughed. A few seconds passed in silence before Cassie said, "Can I tell you something?" Sarah scoffed, "Of course!" Cassie took a timid glance back at Ben to see he was still facing away from her, and then looked back at Sarah. In a more hushed tone, she said, "Ben is...scaring me lately." The bar tender set their drinks down in front of them and Sarah grabbed them before gesturing Cassie to follow her.

Sarah led Cassie to a corner table at the other side of the room. They sat down with their drinks and she asked, "Why is Ben scaring you? How?" Knowing what James had done in the past, Sarah had immediately gone into overprotective big sister mode. Cassie took a deep breath and said, "Well, he goes through this thing where he tells me that I belong to him, that he owns me. At first, I thought it was just a sex thing, but now I'm not so sure. When he gave me this necklace, he said, "Now everyone will know" and said he could stop giving me hickeys." Sarah nodded and listened intently. Cassie continued, "And a few weeks ago, he had a really bad dream. He woke up sweating and when I was trying to comfort him, he started crying. He kept saying that he hurt me in his dream and that he never wanted to hurt me. Then, he started getting angry, talking to himself and pacing the room, so I was going to give him some space, but he begged me not to leave him. Like, literally, begged on his knees. I don't know, this is all...bizzarre."

Sarah took a moment to go over everything in her head. She didn't want to ask, but she had to. "Is he hurting you, Cass? Physically and/or emotionally?" Cassie shook her head and said, "No, no, he would never. If he did, I'm afraid he would kill himself for it." That made Sarah more at ease. "Well, you two have been dating for a couple months now...have things gotten worse since you started?" Cassie thought for a moment and said, "He's been better, but I know he's bottling up his feelings. I mean, he gets insanely jealous if a guy even looks at me. He doesn't think I notice, but I do." Sarah scoffed, "Well yeah! You two had only been together for a fucking day and he looked like he was going to murder that waiter, remember?" Cassie nodded and started looking around. She saw Ben staring at her from the bar, while drinking his vodka and tonic. She gave him a small smirk and looked back to Sarah who was staring at Ben. "He looks like he either wants to kill you or fuck you into next week. I can't tell." Cassie sighed and told her, "Sometimes I don't even know. Though, so far, it's been the second one." Sarah looked back at her and asked, "He still a freaky beast in bed?" Cassie nodded enthusiastically. "The only thing is...I'm never..." She struggled to tell her older sister this problem. Sarah just encouraged her by taking her hand. After taking a breath, she said, "I'm never on top. I'm never...in control, so to speak." Sarah shrugged and said, "So? Make yourself in control. If he tells you no, you tell him yes! Be assertive! This guy has probably never been told no by a woman and you need to be the first! Tonight, you make sure he knows who he belongs to. Play along with it, be a slut." Cassie broke out into a fit of giggles. "I can't believe I'm actually going to listen to you," she told her. 

They continued to talk for a few more minutes, then went back to join the crowd and the party. Ben was still at the bar, so Cassie made her way there. When she got to the bar, Ben linked an arm around her waist and held her close. "Everything alright?" He asked. She nodded and told him, "Yeah. Just sister talk." He hummed and kissed her head. Again, he was taken away by the men, but Cassie stayed at the bar. As she was contimplating what to order, she felt a hand at the small of her back. She turned and saw someone she really did not need right now. 

James.

"Wow, you are looking hot tonight, Cass," he purred. Cassie pushed his hand off her back and said, "Please don't. I'm here with someone and I don't think he'd appreciate your gestures." James let out a cackle that sent an uneasy feeling through her. "Let me at least buy you a drink," he insisted. Cassie ignored him and continued looking at the drink menu. She heard him, and then say, "I broke up with Kate. So I was thinking...your place tonight?" She scoffed and asked a bit loudly, "Did I not just tell you that I was here with someone?! Jesus, James, give it up!" That didn't set well with him. Next thing she new, he was squeezing her wrist and harshly tugging at her arm. She tried to fight him off, but he was too strong. He was pulling her to him when she heard Sarah shout, "LET GO OF HER!" 

Then...he came out of nowhere. Ben attacked Jamie; grabbing him by the shirt collar, and then flipping him over on top of the bar, smashing every glass that was in his way. Cassie slumpped to the ground, holding her shoulder and Sarah rushed to her side. Ben was seething with anger. He stared crazy eyed at James and shouted, "WHAT THE HELL WERE YOU DOING TO HER?!" He lifted James upper half and slammed him back down on to the bar, causing his head to smash against the broken glass. James groaned in pain, not being able to answer him. Ben put his lips close to his ear and whispered (so no one could hear) in the most sinister tone, "If you come near her again, I promise I will skin you alive. If you so much as look at her, I will kill you. She belongs to me. She is mine and you do NOT lay a finger on her again. Undertand?" James weakly nodded, staring wide eyed at him. Ben leaned back up and loosened his grip on Jame's shirt collar. James started to get up as Ben turned away, but then Ben spun around hit James so hard, he fell off the bar, hitting bar stools, and landing limp on the floor. The crowd around them gasped, but Ben ignored it and went straight to Cassie. She was now at a table with Sarah and the girls, still holding on to her shoulder.

Once Ben got to the table, he knelt down in front of her and put his hands on her hips. Cassie noticed that his entire demenor changed. Instead of looking like he was going to kill someone, he looked incredibly worried and scared. "Baby, are you alright?" He asked quickly, while flicking his eyes over her face. "Yeah," she told him. "My shoulder just hurts a bit." By now, Alec had ordered everyone to continue having a good time, so weren't any prying eyes on them. Ben got up and looked over her shoulder. He saw it was a little swollen. 

Alec came over after helping the other guys get James out of the bar and into a cab, and checked out her shoulder more thouroghly. "It's not out of place, which is good," he told her. "But it is sprained. You need to keep off it and switched between icing it and heating it every twenty minutes." Ben kept thinking about how lucky James was to be gone, or else he would have gone back a beat the shit out of him. After Alec was done giving Cassie orders, Ben suggested that he get her home. She agreed and started to make her rounds of goodbyes and apologizes with Ben by her side. When they got outside, Cassie snuggled up to Ben and he carefully put his arm around her. While he was waving down a cab, she looked up at him and said, "Thank you for doing that. For protecting me." Ben put down his arm and smiled at her. He kissed her sweetly on the lips and said, "Honey...I would kill for you."

He waved down a cab and got her safely inside.

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

99.9K 2.6K 84
What do you think will happen if WWE turned to a High School and all your favourite Superstars turned to students in this High School!! I think you w...
10.4K 183 28
The animatronics instead of trying to kill Gregory they're all become Parental yanderes to him. ( fnaf security bridge belongs to Scott and steel woo...
126K 2.2K 104
Breanna, an army Sergeant, has never been the easiest to get along with and has struggled to get close to people due to some past traumas. With a ch...
20.3K 256 17
The story where the joker from Suicide Squad is an evil person and so mean to everyone but Arabella a shy girl from Gotham city. He's a serial killer...