What Lies Beneath

By AEHelms

3K 450 160

Eight strangers find themselves trapped in a mysterious house, the only thing they know is that they each rec... More

Prologue
PART ONE Chapter One: The House
Chapter Two: Karen
Chapter Three: Karen's Letter
Chapter Four: The First Arrival
Chapter Five: Wyatt
Chapter Six: The Photograph
Chapter Seven: The Sound of Silence
Chapter Eight: Charlie
Chapter Nine: The Diary of Cassandra Knight
Chapter Ten: The Boy Next Door
Chapter Eleven: Sophie
Chapter Twelve: Secrets
Chapter Thirteen: When a Killer Comes a Knocking
Chapter Fourteen: Conversations
Chapter Fifteen: Shadows
Chapter Sixteen: Delphine
Chapter Seventeen: Lost in Translation
Chapter Eighteen: Ghost Stories
Chapter Nineteen: Unsolved
Chapter Twenty: Dinner and a Show
PART TWO Chapter Twenty-One: Consequences
Chapter Twenty-Two: Paul
Chapter Twenty-Three: A Death to Remember
Chapter Twenty-Four: Everlasting Sorrow
Chapter Twenty-Five: A Bend Before the Break
Chapter Twenty-Six: Greyson
Chapter Twenty-Seven: The Midnight Arrival
Chapter Twenty-Eight: Burning the Midnight Oil
Chapter Twenty-Nine: The Twins
Chapter Thirty: From the Shadows It Watches
Chapter Thirty-One: A Grimace and a Goodbye
Chapter Thirty-Two: Day Break
Chapter Thirty-Three: Darla
Chapter Thirty-Four: Those Who Linger
Chapter Thirty-Five: Together Forever
Chapter Thirty-Seven: Jason
Chapter Thirty-Eight: Whispers in the Wind
Chapter Thirty-Nine: Ben
Chapter Forty: Unburied
PART THREE Chapter Forty-One: Sabrina
Chapter Forty-Two: Powers and Downfalls
Chapter Forty-Three: Two Killers, One House
Chapter Forty-Four: Haunted
Chapter Forty-Five: Gwyneth
Chapter Forty-Six: The Beginning of the End
Chapter Forty-Seven: Heartbeats
Chapter Forty-Eight: Whispered Truths
Chapter Forty-Nine: Survival
Chapter Fifty: Escape
Chapter Fifty-One: Entombed
Chapter Fifty-Two: Defeat
Chapter Fifty-Three: Surrender
Chapter Fifty-Four: Idiosyncrasy
Chapter Fifty-Five: Fight
Chapter Fifty-Six: The Gatekeeper's Destiny
Chapter Fifty-Seven: Guardian
Chapter Fifty-Eight: Sacrifice
Chapter Fifty-Nine: Defenseless
Chapter Sixty: Soulless
Chapter Sixty-One: Dream Seeker Part One
Chapter Sixty-One: Day Dreamer Part Two
Chapter Sixty-Two: Clarity
Chapter Sixty-Three: Character
Chapter Sixty-Four: Declared
Chapter Sixty-Five: The Hour of Defeat
Chapter Sixty-Six: Reunion
Chapter Sixty-Seven: I Love You, Goodbye
Chapter Sixty-Eight: Bittersweet Sorrows Part One
Chapter Sixty-Eight: Bittersweet Sorrows Part Two
Chapter Sixty-Eight: Bittersweet Sorrows Part Three
Chapter Sixty-Nine: Countdown
Chapter Seventy: Battle of Betrayals
Chapter Seventy-One: Future
Epilogue

Chapter Thirty-Six: Lost and Found

25 6 0
By AEHelms

The house watched silently as all its' inhabitants moved about with all their different agendas. If houses could laugh, it would, but sadly all it could do was watch in silence, for now. It only had to wait for the last three to arrive before the real fun could begin.

Oh, and what fun it would be. It had been a long time since it had been able to indulge in the souls of the forgotten.


Joe didn't know where he was. It was almost as if he had been transported into a black and white picture movie like his father used to make him watch when he was young. Only instead of a silly and predictable story line he was back at the house. He didn't know how he had gotten there, only that he was somehow standing outside of the large entryway that he had left the girl from his taxi standing in front of.

He tried to push the door open, but it wouldn't budge. That's when the screaming started. It sounded like it was coming from deep within the house, but no matter how hard he pushed against the solid barricade, it never moved. Joe didn't know what to do. He had never been in a situation like this. His mind was racing with so many different possibilities, but still none of them would get him inside where he needed to be.

With a half-hearted attempt, he slammed his fist against the blockade one last time and then fell onto the old wood porch in a heap.

"Are you alright?" Joe jumped at the sound of a young boy's voice. He slowly raised his head to see who it was only to be confronted with the boyish face of his father.

"Dad?" Joe stared at his father incredulously.

"Perhaps, but not at the moment." His father said with a wry expression. Joe's father had always been like this. Quick to spouting out riddles, but never as quick when it came to answering them.

"How is this happening? Am I dead?" Joe didn't think that he'd died, but with all the crazy things that had been happening lately, he did not feel as though this was out of the realm of possibilities.

"Not dead, just asleep. We needed to talk."

"Talk about what?"

"This house. Why you feel the need to investigate it. The reason that you are currently lying unconscious on a strange man's couch right now. Or perhaps why you haven't met someone and gotten hitched yet. Take your pick." His father continued to smile at him as he spoke, but Joe could see the concern clearly displayed within his father's eyes.

"I- I dropped this girl off here a few nights ago and ever since then, I haven't been able to stop thinking about this place and what it means. Then this other kid, Paul showed up at my apartment and told me all this stuff and gave Bobby the address of the second richest guy in Connecticut. I figured that it was all connected and then I saw this photo of you in front of the house with six other people. Why is this happening dad? How are we connected to that house?" Joe had many more questions for his father, but he didn't know how much time they had, so he needed to ask the most pertinent ones right off the bat.

"My father took me to that house when I was a very young boy. My mother had just passed away and he was in search of work with his best friend Tom. One day when they were in a local tavern a man posted a help wanted ad. It was a job working on his house to which he would provide free room and board as payment. It was a great deal so they both decided to go for it. I didn't really think too much about it at the time, but it was a cool house and there was a beautiful girl living there on the property. She was the owner's daughter and I loved her very much. Then the incident happened, and we had to leave. I never went back to that house while I was alive, but it's so different after. It calls to us. It needs us. All of us. It will never let us go. Stay away Joe. Stay away for as long as you can." With that, Joe's father vanished like fog being blown away in the wind.


Darla, with the help of her grandmother bought a one-way-ticket to Connecticut the very night that she had seen her mother. They both knew that if her mother was telling her to go, then she had no choice but to follow through. With the hope that they wouldn't be apart for long, Darla said her goodbyes, but a voice deep inside told her that this would be the last time she would see her grandmother. She didn't tell her of course, otherwise her grandmother would have never let her go.

The flight only lasted four or so hours, but that wasn't what bothered her the most about the trip. Throughout the entire plane ride, she could feel the spirits watching her. Waiting for her to notice them, to talk to them and help with whatever it is that they wanted. Unfortunately, even after she got off the plane and out of the airport, she found that there was no escaping the ghosts. The streets were littered with them. It had never been this bad in New Mexico, not even in November.

"Just breathe my darling daughter." The words come to her like a whisper in the wind. Darla couldn't help but smile as they resonated with her. She wasn't alone. She had her mother with her like she had never before. The ghosts weren't there to harm or hinder her in anyway, they were merely there to help aid her in a new journey. She didn't have to pretend to be something that she wasn't anymore. There was no one around who knew her or her grandmother. She was free.


They had been searching for hours with no sign of their missing friend. Paul had tried to tell them that it was useless, but they didn't want to hear it. He didn't want to hear it either, let alone be the one who said it. Still, he couldn't help but remember his dream. He knew when he came here that only a handful would survive, if that. He even knew he wasn't going to be among them. Still he had to come here. He had to try and prevent the tragedy that had been plaguing his every waking and sleeping moment.

There was much to be done and looking for Sophie, as sad as her death would be, was not ranked very high on his to do list.


The house sat quietly on the hill as it waited for the next arrival. It could feel her. She was close, so very close. Soon it would wrap its arms around her, and she would belong to it forever more.


Joe woke up on what was probably the most uncomfortable couch that he had ever had the misfortune to be on. Bobby was quick to jump to his friend's side. Joe could see the questions that were so clearly displayed on his face, but he could not answer them, not now. Not when he was still trying to sort through all the information that his father had given him. The house takes you after you die. That was what he had been told. There is no way to escape it. His father had warned him to stay away for as long as he could, but how could he do that? How could he willingly leave those kids, that girl, in the house?

He had wanted to ask his father more, but he had disappeared after telling him that he and the kids were basically doomed for the rest of eternity. Joe didn't remember his father being so cryptic when he was alive. Perhaps that's what happens to you after you die. You become a cryptic self-serving bastard. Joe cursed himself for thinking like that, but he couldn't help it. How else would one describe leaving children alone to die so that you could live longer?

"What happened to you?" Joe looked at Bobby, pondering the very question that he didn't want to answer. The quiet had been so obtrusive that Bobby couldn't help but finally voice one of his many concerns.

"I'm not really sure." Joe tried to say as little as possible, but he knew that his answer wasn't good enough for his friend. Not after all of the crazy that they had been through the past couple of days.

"What do you mean you're not sure?" He could tell that his friend was frustrated, but still, he couldn't help but smile at his predictability.

"I mean, one second I am looking a picture and the next I am on this couch." Joe rubbed his head. He could feel a migraine starting.

"What picture?" The two friends jumped at the sound of John's voice. They had been so wrapped up with their own thoughts that they had forgotten that they were not alone.

"The one in front of the house that we came here to ask you about." Bobby said without thinking.

"What house?" John didn't want to admit it, but he already knew why they had come to see him. He had been told that this day would arrive by his father.

"The house with the seven people standing in front of it. One of which is my father." Joe didn't overthink his answer, or really think about it at all. He was angry. He had been getting the run around ever since he started his investigation. He'd had it with all the lies and the secrets. He just wanted the truth now.

"Right. I suppose that it's time then that someone knew."

"Knew what exactly?"

"It wasn't supposed to be this way. It was just a house once, or so we thought. You see when my grandfather was a young boy he lived in that town; you know the one just over the border. I don't remember what it was that they used to call it. I think it had something to do with the first settlers favorite flower or something like that. Anyhow, the people that used to live there were very prosperous. That is until the incident. Nobody really knows what happened, but there were all of these rumors. They said that the owner of the boarding house, built by himself and his late wife, had killed his daughter because she was sleeping the one of his employee's sons." Joe felt like he had just swallowed a huge weight that was ripping through his entire body.

"So, what does that have to do with anything?" Bobby couldn't see the connection to what was happening in the present, and honestly, neither could Joe.

"After he killed his daughter, a lot of strange things kept happening around the town. Kids would go missing and the town slowly slipped into what can only be called a drought of luck. I personally don't really know if any of it is true, but there was a lot of strange reports coming from the town until finally they reported a major gas leak and evacuation. The town has been abandoned ever since." John folded his hands behind his back. His story was finished.

"That doesn't make any sense. Things like that don't happen in the real world. I mean yes, people do get murdered, sometimes by their parents, but a whole town doesn't just evacuate and flee because of some missing children and a run of bad luck. If that were true, then New York would be a ghost town." Joe knew that there was no sense in trying to apply real world logic to this type of situation, but he was grateful that Bobby was still the same old rational Bobby that he knew and loved.

"I never said that any of it was true. This is all mainly things that I've heard. Gossip told by a bunch of old ladies through the years during book club." John looked hurt that Bobby didn't believe him. Part of Joe wanted to tell him that it wasn't at all personal, Bobby was simply a realist. Always had been and always would be.

"Wait, did you say that the town was still abandoned?" Joe couldn't believe how stupid he was being. He had gotten wrapped up by the current conversation and completely overlooked the most important part of the story.

"Yes. No one has lived there in a very long time." It was John's turn to be confused.

"But we've been dropping kids there over the last few days. How can it be abandoned?" With the new information now in the air, John felt like his heart was going to explode.

"That's not possible. That town has been fenced off for years. No one could be living there."

"How come? People buy things all the time, couldn't someone have bought the town or even just a house inside the fence?" Bobby was trying to be rational again, but this time Joe was on the same page. Why was it such an absurd idea for someone to have bought the town or even just the house?

"Because- Because I own it."


*PLEASE DON'T FORGET TO VOTE, COMMENT, AND SHARE IF YOU LIKE THIS. ALSO STAY TUNED TO MEET THE NEXT GUEST IN CHAPTER THIRTY-SEVEN: JASON. YOU WON'T WANT TO MISS THIS.*

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

13.6K 924 35
In the safe town of Riverwood, five students go out to the newly opened local Murder House for a fun night. But when things start to get too real, th...
91.2K 3.2K 30
A group of friends get trapped in their school along with their history teacher. A single game of Truth Or Dare to pass the time, soon turns into a g...
1K 102 23
Many mysteries were hidden Many secrets are untold A matter of life or death Will Alyssa be able to survive from that fatal disaster? Or will the evi...
The Dark Days By Olivia Kow

Mystery / Thriller

4.3K 311 25
Three girls stay over in a cabin. Only two come out alive, but with no memory of what happened the night before. A murder occurred, but no evidence t...