If I had known going on a date with a strange would end up with me tied to a chair and my ex glaring at me, I would of stayed inside.
"Hello Gabriel." I said as I leaned back in the chair.
"Okay I helped you get her now can I leave?" The man asked.
"Go." Gabriel said as his eyes stayed on me.
"I will get you back for this!" I yelled at the guy as he left the room.
"Always had a thing for brunette's didn't you." He said as he kept his eyes on me.
"Sue me." I said calmly.
"I wish I could, for all the pain and suffering you caused." He said angrily.
"All I did was leave, and you are just mad that I didn't tell you I was leaving."
"No! I'm mad you walked out on me after I saved your life!" He snapped as he put his hands on either side of my chair.
"I didn't ask for you to save me." I whispered.
"You didn't have to ask...... why did you leave?" He asked calmly.
"Didn't see a reason for staying."
"Lier! Why did you leave? If you tell me I'll let you walk out that door and I'll never go after you again. All I want is to know why you left."
I met his eyes and saw tears threatening to fall, a part of me wanted to lie, wanted to say I left because I didn't love him, but the other part of me wanted to grab him and kiss away the pain I had caused.
"Because.... I don't love you." I said softly.
"I don't believe you." He whispered.
"Why? Why don't you believe me? Why can't that be the reason?"
"Because if you didn't love me..... you wouldn't be crying."
I looked away and my eyes landed on a mirror. I watched as the tears streamed down my face and I shook my head.
"I can't." I whispered.
"Why.... talk to me." He whispered.
"My brothers.... they told me if I stayed with you... that I would have to choice between you and them.... and so I choose neither."
"(Y/n)....."
"I can't choose Gabriel.... I can't lose Sam and Dean but I can't lose you.... I don't want to choose."
He snapped his fingers and the rope around my wrists disappeared. I looked up at him and he pulled me into a hug. I felt tears stream down my face as I wrapped my arms around him and held him tightly.
"Then I'll choose for you.... I love you." He whispered.
The last thing I heard was a snap of his finger before everything went dark.
I shot up in bed and shook my head as I looked around.
"That was a weird dream." I whispered as I stood up.
"Morning Sis." Sam said as I walked into the kitchen.
"Morning, Dean up yet?"
"Yea he left to go talk to an old friend." He said softly.
"Which old friend?" I asked softly.
"Gabriel."
"Who is Gabriel?" I asked confused.
Sam looked at me shocked and I frowned as he watched me.
"What? Who is he? Do I know him?" I asked softly.
"You don't know who Gabriel is?"
I shook my head no and I turned to see Dean wall into the bunker with a man with brown hair.
"Dean we need to talk." Sam said softly.
"Alright." He said as Sam grabbed his arm and walked away.
"So you must be Gabriel, I'm (Y/n)." I said as I held my hand out.
He shook my hand and looked away. I raised my eyebrows and turned to see Dean walk into the room.
"Bring her memory back now." He said angrily.
"Why? Why let her remember when you will make her choose?" Gabriel asked angrily.
"Because she deserves to remember... and if she chooses you then fine... but I want my sister back." Dean said angrily.
I looked at Dean confused and then at Gabriel. I watched him snap his finger and I felt my head start to spin. When the room stopped I shook my head and looked up at Gabriel.
"You bastard!" I yelled as I moved to smack him.
"I did it so you wouldn't lose your brothers." He said as he grabbed my hand.
"Yet I have to lose you! What would happen if I remember on my own and you were dead?" I asked angrily.
He looked away and I saw Dean send me a small smile.
"If you still want to be with feathers then you can, but just promise to stay in touch." Dean said softly.
"I promise, now you and me are going to have a long talk." I said as I glared at Gabriel.
He snapped his fingers and we appeared in his house. He looked down and me and before he could say anything I pulled him into a deep and passionate kiss.
"You ever make me forget about you again and I'll kill you." I whispered against his lips.
"Yes ma'am." He said as I pulled him into another kiss.