Secretly I Think You Knew

By DrJohnHolmes

137K 8.3K 2.9K

John Watson never really bothered to notice the strange boy in his grade, the self proclaimed sociopath that... More

Let's Just Blame it On The Car
Straight Outta The 1800's
The Lonely Life Of Sherlock Holmes
Platonic Project Pals
Good First Impressions?
The Face on the Milk Carton
Pass Me The Aux Cord
Morning Mayhem With Greg Lestrade
Apology of the Ages
Beautiful Faces Immortalized in Graphite
Greg's Got to Chill
The Fractured Friend
The Things That Must Be Done
Friends or Freaks?
The Aftermath of the Argument
Pathetic Practices and Drama Queens
Personified Version of Love
Black Coffee and Steamrolled Pancakes
Solitude With Sherlock Holmes
He's Got his Back...and My Backpack
It's Not as Easy as it Looks
You Must Always Follow The Rules
Freezer Burnt Hearts
The Obscure Olive Branch
Idiotic Protection Program
Please Don't Be Our Guest
Dangerous Dining
How the Good Die Young
Freedom is Fabulous
Coming Out To My Friends And I'm Doing Just Fine
Make New Friends and Well, There are No Old...
The Family Needs To Know
The Historical Holmes Household
The Shadows Whisper Back
Greg's Been Guessing
Giving it All Up for Love
Food Shopping With the Freak
You're Never Truly Alone
The Devil Returning to the Fire
The Lie That is Love
Darn the Paparazzi
Back Stabbing Best Friend
The Voices Inside My Head
A Different Kind of Oath
Until We Meet Again

What Should've Been

2.8K 185 86
By DrJohnHolmes

"You can sit up here with me if you want, watch TV or something." John suggested, scooting over a bit so that Sherlock could sit next to him.
"Oh, yes, alright." Sherlock muttered, seeming very uncomfortable. "Would you like me to take my shoes off?"
"Sherlock, look at me, do I look like a guy who cares about your shoes on my bed?" John laughed.
"Well, um, I don't..." Sherlock stammered.
"You're fine, come over here." John insisted, grabbing the remote from the bedside table and turning the TV on. Sherlock crawled over, sitting as far away from John as possible as if worried their elbows might brush, as if that was such a tragedy.
"You can pick the channel if you want, explore the world of television." John laughed.
"I've only ever watched TV at school." Sherlock admitted, taking the remote gently from John as if it were the Holy Grail.
"You're so innocent Sherlock, it really is quite amusing." John admitted, watching as Sherlock flipped wondrously through the channels. Sherlock didn't seem to have heard him, as he kept flipping until he landed on some sort of superhero movie, the Avengers. Sherlock gazed at the screen as the hulk went parading all through the Heli carrier, smashing things and being all angry.
"Who is that?" Sherlock asked.
"That's the Hulk, have you heard of him before?" John asked.
"I sort of remember some kid having him on a lunch box..." Sherlock muttered.
"You need a lesson in pop culture." John decided.
"Oh, no thank you." Sherlock shrugged, continuing to flip channels as if worried he'd learn. John just laughed, and this time Sherlock settled on the football game Mr. Watson had been watching downstairs.
"This is professional football, right?" Sherlock asked.
"Tell me you've heard of this before." John insisted.
"Of course I have, the boys in our grade never shut up about it. I've never really seen the appeal." Sherlock admitted.
"I'll take you to one of the high school games one time; it's a lot more exciting live." John suggested.
"Oh, Mycroft wouldn't like that at all." Sherlock decided with a small laugh.
"Mycroft doesn't have to know." John assured. Sherlock stole a look at John once more, looking a bit scared to see John looking right back.
"Sorry." He muttered, staring determinedly at the TV as if suddenly very interested.
"You're apologizing for looking at me?" John asked with a small laugh.
"Well, yes, I mean, I'd think it would make you uncomfortable." Sherlock admitted.
"It doesn't, I assure you." John insisted. Sherlock nodded, still looking unconvinced.
"It makes me uncomfortable." He admitted.
"Looking at me?" John asked with a nervous laugh.
"You looking at me." Sherlock corrected. John still looked at him, as if trying to figure out what he meant by that. Sherlock didn't need to worry however, he liked what he saw.
"Why do I make you uncomfortable? I can stop, if you..."
"No!" Sherlock said quickly, turning almost instantly to look into John's eyes. It almost seemed to be an accident, but he didn't look away. "Don't stop." He muttered.
"Alright, I won't. You're very nice to look at anyhow." John admitted. Sherlock blushed, his beautiful blue eyes flicking over John's face as if he didn't know where to look, his eyes, his forehead, his cheeks, his lips...
"Oh, well, I wouldn't think that I'm that great." He muttered.
"You're joking, right?" John asked. Sherlock shook his head very quickly, John could sense his rising tension, but John could also sense something, there was something sparking between them, and he couldn't let that small spark die out. Maybe he could ignite it someway... Sherlock seemed to sense it too, with his blushing cheeks and awkward words; except he didn't do anything to snuff it out, which made John all the more confident to add kindle to the flame.
"It makes me wonder why you ever let Mycroft's rules control you, Sherlock you have so much potential. I mean, you're here now, what is stopping you from forgetting everything he's ever taught you?" John asked. Sherlock's eyes were wide, his lips slightly parted as he took sharp, quick breaths, he looked terrified.
"I um...I never really thought..." he stopped talking there, as if he didn't want to go on, as if he simply couldn't. John smiled reassuringly, looking down to see Sherlock's hand laying on the bed next to him, his fingers twitching once more as if longing to be held...
"Can I take your hand?" John asked softly. Sherlock's face drained of color, but John saw the smallest of nods, Sherlock's eyes following John's hand as he gently interlocked their fingers. A simple gesture really, it could show companionship, friendship, ownership, even a relationship. Right now, John wasn't sure which one he would prefer. Sherlock on the other hand seemed absolutely flustered, beyond words. His hand twitched and shook in John's but he didn't let go, he seemed like he never wanted to let go.
"Have you wanted this as well?" John muttered, so softly and so gently that he was sure his words wouldn't shatter Sherlock's poor fragile heart, just learning to beat. Sherlock's mouth moved but no words came out, he was as pale as a sheet, terrified yet determined.
"Mycroft..." Sherlock whispered fearfully.
"...Isn't here. He doesn't need to know." John finished. Sherlock seemed to relax just the slightest bit, his face regaining a little bit of color. John just loved the way he looked right now, the beautiful contrast between his white face and his dark hair, his cheekbones, his red lips, he looked like a piece of art. So John leaned closer, letting his other hand come up and press ever so softly against the side of Sherlock's face, leaning so close that with another inch their lips would be brushing together...Sherlock took a sharp, quick breath and jerked backwards, ripping his hand away from John's and swatting his other hand away. John retreated immediately, blushing in shame. Well that was it; he officially screwed up his entire new relationship with his friend/boyfriend. He had lost Sherlock for good.
"I can't do this John, I've told you... I can't." Sherlock muttered, scrambling off of the bed. He looked scared, scared beyond belief. John just couldn't tell if he was scared of John kissing him or what would happen if John kissed him. He might be scared of feelings, he might be scared of pain, but he was definitely scared of his brother. Even though Mycroft wasn't here, his shadow followed Sherlock wherever he went, restricting him from things that he wanted to do.
"No, Sherlock, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, please..." John started, but Sherlock had already run out of the room without a goodbye. John sat defeated on his bed, listening to the announcer on the TV yell about a foul as he sat accepting his mistakes. He had pushed Sherlock's boundaries and now he was going to pay for it...he had tried to love an unlovable boy.                                             

        Sherlock POV: Sherlock didn't really know why he ran, he didn't know why he was still running, and he most certainly had no idea why he was running away from John Watson. If there was any reason to run it would be for protection, for love, and for comfort, and John was the only person in this entire world that offered Sherlock all three. And he was running as if his life depended on it. Sherlock tore through the streets of the little development where John lived, down the main road, dodging all sorts of pedestrians, dogs, street lamps, trash cans, sprinting back to the library in case Mycroft decided to show up hours early. When finally Sherlock climbed all of the stairs to the main doors he was relieved to see that there was no Mycroft waiting for him at the entrance, there was no black car parked out front, obviously Mycroft had stuck with his end of the deal. Sherlock, of course, did not. He walked nervously into the library, trying not to look so terrified, trying to look as if he were returning from a carefree stroll with a friend, only a friend...that was all. Sherlock realized that he hadn't even grabbed his backpack, it was still at John's, he would have to come over and return it like he did the lunch box. Or maybe for once he would use what little bit of a brain he had and bring it to school. And then they would have to face each other, and look at each other, and all the memories will come flooding back and John would think that Sherlock hates him and will never want to talk to him again because he had run but that wasn't the truth Sherlock loved him he always loved him and now he was just....scared. Sherlock was absolutely bloody terrified. He walked over to the bathroom, which was hardly ever occupied thankfully, and shut the door, locking it and staring at his reflection in the mirror. He looked pale yet flustered with exercise, he was breathing heavy but he was sure that if he had just taken the bus he would still feel like he had finished a marathon. John Watson, the John Watson he had imagined and daydreamed and drawn about had actually tried to kiss him! But why, what did he do differently this time, what might he need to do next time, might there not be a next time? Sherlock might have screwed it up, this was probably a once in a life time opportunity, the minute John decides Sherlock isn't worth it is the moment his heart travels onto another poor soul that he decided to help. Sherlock was his charity project, his good deed for the year, so was he just playing around? Or did John actually mean it...did he want to hold Sherlock's hand and want to stare into his eyes and want to kiss him? Sherlock closed his eyes for a moment and he could see John coming closer and closer, his beautiful eyes starting to close, his mouth slightly open, his lips ready to get the first touch of Sherlock's lips, their souls fully prepared to intertwine. And then Sherlock could see himself running, falling over himself in a mad rush to get away even though that had been all he had ever wanted in life. Even Victor hadn't tried to kiss him; even Victor never held his hand. John was something special, different, entirely new, and Sherlock was going to lose him as well. But this time he wasn't going to have to kill him, this time it wasn't directly Mycroft's fault. This time it had been the remains of Mycroft's rules, the thought that the moment their lips met that John would be in more danger than Victor had ever been in. Sherlock had a strange feeling that John wasn't the best at keeping secrets, especially if he had a grudge with Greg about Sherlock's dedication to their friendship. He's want to parade his new boyfriend around the school and somehow word would leak out and somehow Mycroft would find out and Sherlock would finally see the betrayal and fear in John Watson's beautiful chocolate eyes as he slid a knife over his windpipe. Sherlock could never do that, no, for John's sake, for everyone's sake, there will be no romance. In fact Sherlock shouldn't even talk to him at all. Maybe it was best to let the things you love go, but this time Sherlock wasn't accepting them back. If John came back he would end up in the freezer, his frost bitten, cracking body lying next to Victor's, the blood clotted in ice crystals, the frozen eyes staring at the dark ceiling... Yes, that it what he will do. John might take it the wrong way, what if he thought this meant Sherlock hated him? What if Sherlock's sudden abandonment made him think that his feelings weren't mutual? No, that was a good thing. The more Sherlock hurt John the less he would ever want to come back. The more Sherlock hurt John, the safer he would be. Sherlock cupped his hands together and held them under the cold water of the sink, splashing it over his face so that he couldn't tell the water from the tears that dripped down onto his jacket. There was no difference, John's leaving wouldn't hurt him, he wouldn't dwell on the things that could've been, he would remember that because he is leaving John, the boy had a guaranteed future. Maybe he could find someone else, some woman, having children, buy a house, start a family and be happy. And Sherlock would still be with his brother, nowhere to go, no one to talk to, no one to protect him and no one to love. For years and years until finally Mycroft joined the souls in Heaven he had sent there. Well, maybe he would have a family reunion with their uncle down in hell. That was more like it.
"How was the project?" Mycroft asked hours later as Sherlock stumbled into the car.
"Oh, it was good." Sherlock agreed.
"Where is it? I expected an extravagant poster." Mycroft asked with a sort of laugh, pulling onto the road and driving off to their house.
"It was online, PowerPoint, so I had to use a computer." Sherlock shrugged.
"Where is your backpack?" Mycroft asked, eyeing Sherlock suspiciously.
"Backpack? I didn't have a backpack." Sherlock said quickly. Mycroft's eyes narrowed in suspicion but he couldn't seem to find anyway to blame John for this little apparent gap in his memory.
"I thought you did." He muttered, turning his eyes back on the road. Sherlock sighed, watching as the trees and the fields went by, feeling a dull aching where he had thought his heart had been. When they got home Sherlock disappeared into his bedroom, pulling the curtains around his bed once more, a handy little trick for secret diary drawings. Mycroft waited downstairs, oblivious of everything that had just happened in Sherlock's life, so many things he would be uncomfortable with. But obviously something of Mycroft was sticking to Sherlock; something was able to scare him away from any sign of romantic interest from anyone. Mycroft's rules had managed to scare Sherlock straight, almost literally. Sherlock sighed, grabbing a rather dull pencil from his bedside table and opening the book once more. This time he skipped straight through the Victor drawings, all from years past, weeks and weeks drawing and wishing and daydreaming about that boy. Oh, if only he could have Victor, oh, he would never notice me, oh, Mycroft might not approve. Might is the key word, because that was before Sherlock really knew the extent his brother's hatred went. Sherlock and Mycroft had a fabulous relationship before Sherlock actually grew up, grew...interested. They were the perfect siblings, both friends and family in their little cave of a house, not going outside, not caring what they were missing, living the life Mycroft had picked for them and not saying a word in complaint. Sherlock lived that life because he had no idea what it was like to live anyway different. He didn't know that relationships were wonderful, he didn't know the obsessive beauty love and crushes brought, he never knew that people were actually wonderful, not the monsters Mycroft described. As a little boy Mycroft had always taught Sherlock to fear people, women most of all. Maybe that's why Sherlock turned out to be gay after all, because Mycroft was terrified he would fall in love with a woman someday, and tried to turn Sherlock against them. He said they would bait him, kiss him, then tear his heart out and clear his bank account. Sherlock had been terrified of women as he started to grow up, so scared in fact that when he was in school he would only hang out with the other boys. But he soon found out that he wasn't much like those children, the boys in the backwards baseball hats and basketball shorts, the ones who played sports and liked bugs and thought girls were the best creation to walk to earth. Sherlock soon found that he had nothing in common with any of the children, until he met Victor Trevor. It was around freshman year when Sherlock had first met him; a boy dressed for an occasion, a boy wearing slacks and a button down for school. Just like Sherlock. He was a grade above Sherlock, which is why it had taken him ten years to notice, but Victor showed Sherlock kindness like no other. They shared a math class together and whatever Sherlock couldn't figure out (which wasn't math oriented, more like how to turn on his laptop), Victor helped with. He was charming, he was handsome, and everything Sherlock did seemed to amuse him. The boy seemed to be as taken as Sherlock as Sherlock was with him. Of course, Sherlock started to get thoughts, get feelings, although he couldn't place them, he didn't know what it meant. He had felt very odd, getting extremely embarrassed when Victor was around, blushing when the boy turned his brilliant blue eyes on him, and for once there seemed to be an aching, a yearning in the place Mycroft said his heart was. Soon the notebook started, picture upon picture until one day Sherlock discovered that this wasn't friendship, this wasn't admiration, he was in love. He was absolutely breathtakingly in love and there was nothing he could do about it. He knew Mycroft wouldn't like it, but he thought that maybe he'd grow more accustomed, that possibly by getting to know Victor he might accept that not all humans were bad. So Sherlock had told his brother, he told him...everything. That was probably that worst idea Sherlock has ever had, because as soon as dinner was over Mycroft gave Victor a tour of the house, starting with the basement. He encouraged him to go into the freezer, and locked him in there, until at least Sherlock was forced to come down. Forced to open the door and see his love freezing, terrified, knowing that the only thing he could do to Victor's fear was enhance it. That was the last Sherlock had seen of Victor Trevor, and Sherlock didn't want to lose John as well. He didn't want to have to watch Mycroft drag John down the basement stairs, he didn't want to have to hear him screaming, pounding against the freezer door, begging for help, as Mycroft selected the best kitchen blade to slit John's throat. Sherlock pressed the pencil to his notebook, taking a deep breath and letting his hand flow once more, his thoughts, memories, all pouring out onto the paper and materializing in graphite before his eyes. After a while Sherlock put his pencil down and observed his new creation. Once again it was he and John, both seeming as if they were sitting but there was no background, there never was in Sherlock's creations. Sherlock's hand was in John's, and they were centimeters away from kissing. This must be what had happened at John's house, they were sitting on the bed, watching sports, not a care in the world. In this representation though, Sherlock was looking eager, excited, excepting, as did John. Sherlock knew that if he could jump into the world of his pictures that this Sherlock wouldn't run, he wouldn't run from his love and from his life. The two lucky graphite lines would kiss and they would fall in love, something Sherlock could never do. He could never let John get too close to Mycroft; he could never get Mycroft too close to John. The two couldn't ever meet, they couldn't lay eyes on each other, because it they did, well, John's body would be lying downstairs in the freezer, where Sherlock could never see him, where Sherlock could never find him, where Sherlock could never love him.

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

3.9K 487 29
Greg Lestrade knew nothing of his reclusive old neighbor until at last he is called up to his house. Mr. Watson, the antisocial and rather mysterious...
330K 18.8K 47
Sherlock is the son of a rich business man, and there was only one thing that he wanted but couldn't have; John Watson. There was no way the Freak an...
30.8K 2.6K 52
John Watson moved to another town, to a rickety old house. Little does he know, someone already lived there. In 1940, the only thing Sherlock knew o...
371 1 16
heyaa this is a little Teenlock Story :) !Tw! There are places where violence or self-harm occurs. John, 15 years old, moves with his family into a...