Hello! I completely forgot to do a scenario where you guys become friends, so I apologise!
Hope you enjoy :)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jeff the Killer
"(Y/N)?"
"Yeah?"
"You already know I'm a killer, right?" He asked.
"Yeah, only because my creepy friends fan girl over you." You replied.
He shuddered and left the room, without saying another word.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
BEN Drowned
"Umm, (Y/N)?" BEN called out.
"What's up?"
"I kind of want to tell you something important."
"What?" You asked, fear appearing in your eyes.
"I'm a, uh, killer. Well, not necessarily, I mean, I don't kill them, but I drive them to insanity so then they commit suicide." He admitted, scratching the back of his head.
You looked at him oddly. "Umm, ok?"
"Are you fine with that?"
"I-I guess. Eh, I'll be right." You replied nonchalantly.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Slender Man
"My dear, you already notice that I kill for a living, due to the fact that you've heard the "rumours", correct?" He asked.
You nodded your head.
"And are you able to accept the fact that this is my lifestyle? Stealing innocents people's lives and claiming their pathetic souls?"
"I-I, I think so?" You answered, slightly unsure.
"Oh, splendid my dear." He said, pulling you into a hug.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Eyeless Jack
"Hey, you're probably wondering why I snuck into your house?" He said.
"Yeah?"
"Well, the reason why is because I steal people's kidneys."
There was a thick, awkward filled silence between the two before you spoke up.
"Eww, that's disgusting." You smiled. "But, that's alright I suppose, because you're my friend."
He smiled under his mask, knowing that he knew he had fallen in love.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Masky
"(Y/N) you don't mind if I kill people?" He asked in an annoyed tone.
"Yeah, sure cool bro whatever." You replied looking at some vine video.
He rolled his eyes and flicked you.
"Oww what was that for?" You yelled rubbing your head.
"That's for not listening now; do you care if I kill people?" He asked again giving you the evil eye.
"As long as you don't kill my parents." You muttered under your breath.
"Good." He said sternly before leaving the room.
"Man periods." You murmured.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hoody
"D-Do you care if I kill people?" Hoody mumbled.
"Nope as long as you kill people who actually deserved to have their lives taken away from them." You answered.
"Yeah that's what I do." He lied.
"Ok then we're good." You smiled, pecking his cheek.
He still hasn't admitted that he kills radom people he doesn't know.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Lost Silver
"(Y-Y-Y/N)?" Silver called out.
You took your attention from the book you were reading to Silver who was sitting on the edge of the sofa, twiddling his thumbs.
"Yeah?"
"I-I'm really sorry if I-I-I scare you away, but I k-k-kill people for a living." He admitted, tears falling from his eyes. You sat there, shocked, and couldn't formulate any words. "I-I don't want to do it, b-b-but I have to. I'm forced against m-my own will. I know you probably t-t-think I'm scum, but I want you to know that you're my friend and I'll d-do anything to protect you. I'm sorry..."
You sighed at his pitiful state and pulled him into a hug. He gasped at the sudden move, but smiled as he felt his heart melt in your arms...
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Glitchy Red
Red appeared back at your place and you ready to whoop his arse. You knew he was a killer, so you decided avenge the people who he killed.
He sauntered around your house, searching for you, until he got hit in the nuts with your baseball bat.
"Ouch, you midget!" He hissed.
That comment made you enraged, so you hit him once again in the nuts. Before you could swing it a third time, he grabbed your arms and pinned you to the wall.
His red eyes that once flamed with anger turned into shock as he realised how close his lips were to yours. a blush danced on his cheeks as he muttered incoherent words and pulled himself away from you.
Your cheeks flared up at his behaviour and you slapped him in the face.
"Ouch, Jesus shorty you have a lot of fire in that tiny body of yours!" He said, a smirk tugging at his lips.
You lifted up your baseball bat. "What?"
He lifted his hands up in defence. "Nothing... I'm gonna leave so I can soothe my swollen testicles. Later!"
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Laughing Jack.
"My dear, do you know what I really do for a living?" He asked.
"No, what do you do?"
"I murder people, that's what I do for a living."
"Eh, I'm not surprised." You replied.
"Really, darling, how so?"Jack questioned, a smile forming on his lips.
"Your appearance has "killer clown" written all over it." You said before walking out of the room.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dark Link.
"Would you care if I was uhh... I don't know a killer?" He hinted.
"Yes, I would call the police." You joked.
"Ha, pfft luckily I'm not, ha!" He laughed nervously.
"I'm joking, I'm not stupid Darkness. I know you're a killer."
"Oh well, deal with it..." He said, running out of the room.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ticci Toby
A knock was heard at your door as you read your favourite book. You raised an eyebrow because your weren't expecting anyone and slowly walked to your door. You opened it and gasped when you saw the boy from a few nights ago. You took a step back and looked down at the ground.
"Hey, I uh... Wanted to give you this as a peace offering. I've observed you from afar and I find you quite interesting. In fact, so interesting that I'm going to spare you your life." He forcefully handed you the bouquet of flowers before running off. You smiled slightly at the sight of the vibrant flowers and saw a small card tucked between two of them. You picked it up and began to read.
"I hope you're happy," it read. "I have hay fever."
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dr Smiley
"(Y/N)? You know how your friend told you that I was a doctor?"
"Yeah...?" You replied, slowly.
He chuckled and scratched the back of his neck. "I'm not really a doctor, I pretend to be, just so I can torture and murder my "patients"." He admitted.
"Oh."
"You ok?" He asked.
"Yeah, I'm just going to look up kittens on Google Images." You announced before walking out of the room.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Homicidal Liu
"(Y/N) I have a confession to make..." Liu stated.
"What...?"
"I'm homicidal."
"Uh, do you want me to get you psychological help?" You questioned.
"I'm fine the way I am, I just needed to get that off my chest." He paused for a moment. "Are you still going to be my friend?"
"I guess..."
"Oh thank you!"
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bloody Painter
"So, I uh..." Helen trailed off. You drummed your fingers on your table impatiently.
"You what?" You said, slightly irritated.
"I-I kill people, and ususally use their blood to create masterpieces." He admitted.
You raised an eyebrow. "Um what? I-I mean I know what you said, but why?"
He sighed and scratched his head. "It's a long story... I'll tell you some other time, so are you fine with that or...?"
"I guess I'll have to hear the story before I can make any judgements." You sighed. He grinned and pulled you into a hug.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Lord Zalgo
(A/N:You already know about Zalgo being a killer, sorry!)