Jacob:
You and Jacob were sitting on his couch watching tv and he said it
Jared:
He said he loved you when you too were on a date and it slipped.
Seth:
You too were making out when he said it.
Sam:
He said it when you got hurt and were losing a lot of blood but you didn't die.
Quil:
You made him laugh and he said it.
Embry:
You to got reunited from when you were in college.