Primrose | REVIEW SHOP [ OPEN...

By Rose-Gold_Community

8.8K 597 726

Welcome to Primrose, the premier review shop of the Rose Gold Community on Wattpad. At Primrose, our dedicate... More

💖 Welcome 💖
💖 Rules 💖
💖 How to Collect Your Private Review 💖
💖 Join 💖
✨ REVIEWER: Nir [OPEN]✨
✨ REVIEWER: Claire [OPEN]✨
✨ REVIEWER: Yasmin [OPEN]✨
✨ REVIEWER: Trilogy [OPEN]✨
✨ REVIEWER: June [ON HOLD] ✨
✨ REVIEWER: Cadence [ON HOLD]✨
✨ REVIEWER: Holly [ON HOLD]✨
✨ REVIEWER: Kailyn [ ON HOLD ]✨
✨ REVIEWER: Ananas [ON HOLD] ✨
✨ REVIEWER: Sara [ON HOLD]✨
✨ REVIEWER: Amanda [ON HOLD]✨
✨REVIEWER: Pooja [ON HOLD]✨
✨ REVIEWER: Cyian [ ON HOLD ]✨
✨ REVIEWER: Corina [CLOSED]✨
✨ REVIEWER: Abi [CLOSED]✨
✨REVIEWER: Maria [CLOSED]✨
★ { Ananas } Of Moons and Blood
★ { Pooja } Blood and Bodies
★ { Pooja } Badminton Lovers
★ { Maria } The Matchmaker
★ { Corina } Saving Michael
★ { Corina } Yemisi's Dilemma: Unmasking the Class Bully's Demise
★ { Corina } Poor In Heaven/The Lake Club
★ { Trilogy } Tangled Claws
★ { Corina } Lucid
★ { Ananas } Dungeon
★ { June } SELENOPHILE
★ { Corina } Better Than Before
★ { Pooja } Take My Soul
★ { Yasmin } Silver: The Lost Royal
★ { Yasmin } Rhyshannon Chronicles | Book 1: A Path of Swords
★ { Kailyn } Vipersong
★ { Kailyn } Stay Mine
★ { Yasmin } A Ballad of Falling Light
★ { Corina } So Far Away
★ { Romana } The Prep's Diary: How the Prep Became so Preppy
★ { Kailyn } Finding You
★ { Yasmin } Out of the Shadows
★ { June } A Secondary School Survivor
★ { Ananas } The Lethal Heptagon
★ { Ananas } Captivity
★ { Yasmin } 17
★ { Pooja } White Trash
★ { Romana } The legend of Zelda; Breath of the Spirit
★ { Ananas } Lost in 30 Days
★ { Kailyn } Past in the Spotlight
★ { June } The Salvador Legacy
★ { June } Fate of the Fae
★ { Kailyn } Breathing in Your Blues
★ { Kailyn } Within the Mist
★ { June } Taken by Lucifer
★ { Pooja } Stay
★ { Trilogy } The Kingdom Shall Bleed
★ { Abi } Stay With Me
★ { Kailyn } There's Only You
★ { Corina } Hiraeth
★ { Nir } A Fictitious Reality (Reality Series #1)
★ { Nir } Yemisi's Dilemma: Unmasking the Class Bully's Demise
★ { Cadence } Warrior of Oirasora
★ { Ananas } Slate Gray
★ { June } Off Limits
★ { Nir } Love, Mr. Client (TayNew AU)
★ { Holly } You Said, Forever and Always
★ { Cadence } The God's Game
★ { Holly } A Ballad of Falling Light
★ { Holly } The Words Left Unsaid
★ { June } Playing Revenge
★ { Kailyn } Pristine's Problem
★ { Holly } Ancilla
★ { Nir } On the Run
★ { Nir } No Pills
★ { Holly } Against The Dark - A Dramione Fanfiction
★ { Nir } A Broken Heart's Last Wish
★ { Nir } MY ONLY VALENTINE

★ { Cadence } Lost in the Fray

80 5 8
By Rose-Gold_Community

Reviewer: CadencePadgett0

Author: AsiaAlexandria

Focuse On Request(s): Worldbuilding and pacing

Title: 5/5

The title is unique and easy to remember. It conveys the essence of the story. Overall, I like how it's not a cliche teen romance title and has an important meaning of the book.

Blurb: 5/5

The blurb is great! It introduces the characters and the conflict nicely without giving away too much details. Overall, it got my attention and made me want to read more.

Cover: ⅗

I like the style of the cover, but I didn't understand the purpose of having the main characters behind the screen and on the screen. But I do like the font choice, however I suggest you move the author's name up a little so it doesn't look like it's being cut off. If you haven't already, I encourage you to get a new cover and experiment to see what works best for your story. Overall, the cover looks very nice and has a fun vibe as for a teen romance novel!

Characters: 10/10

I love the characters! You did a wonderful job on developing the relationships that Milo and Nia have with each other and their friends. I like how you set up their personalities nicely and their internal conflicts. I can totally relate to Nia wanting to blend with the crowd at her new school. Overall, the characters are great!

Plot: 10/10

So far, the plot is pretty good. It's easy to follow and it's different from what I normally read. For example, the new girl trope but added a medical condition is something I have never read in YA before. Overall, I think it's good and not cliche.

Writing Style: 10 /10

I adore your writing style! I enjoy reading the descriptions and it's beautiful. And it's on point. It was written like a professional novel.

Grammar: 10/10

I didn't notice any major errors.

World building: 10/10

You did a beautiful job on building the world from the character's perspective and not info dump.

Pacing: 7/10

The pacing was good. I like how you slowly introduce the characters and their personalities. The dialogues and descriptions are in perfect balance to a good pacing.

But the only problem with pacing is the chapter size.

I would have enjoyed it more if the chapters were a bit shorter. When I started to read, I noticed that it was longer than I normally read. So after I read five chapters, I went on my laptop and realized how long the chapters actually are. It's about 18-25 minutes long!

That is the part I have struggled to finish in one chapter during the day.

Every reader is different; some like longer chapters, some enjoy shorter chapters. I prefer it if it was somewhere around 1,500 - 2,000 words. Anything outside of that word count, is considered too long. Just keep in mind that most readers are probably on mobile and likes to finish a chapter quickly rather than finishing up a long chapter.

Anyway, I suggest you break some scenes into new chapters so that way it's easier for readers to finish the chapter quickly.

Overall, I enjoyed the book and hope to continue reading!

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

11.3K 224 21
UN-FINISHED FIC SORRY :( this story picks up right where the glass queen finishes and its what I think/hope will happen in victoria aveyards book tha...
2.2K 247 9
OPEN (#) JUDGING() RESULTS() Welcome to OUR WISHING SOCK awards 2024!!! These awards are the extension of "OUR WISHING SOCK MAGAZINE AND BOOKCLUB". W...
2.2K 399 13
☆OPEN ✔ ☆JUDGING 🔒 ☆CLOSED 🔒 Introducing The Amethyst Awards 2023: The inaugural celebration of literary excellence! We proudly present the 1st edi...
4.7K 347 25
(Starting 2024) The Creative Writing Awards 2024 Readers and Writers can enter their favorite stories. All ongoing and completed stories. And all la...