Sabrina Carpenter as Alyssa Clarke
The Broken One
Matt Cornett as EJ Caswell
The One Who Tried To Save Her
Hugh Jackman as Lewis Clarke
The Abuser
Peyton Meyer as Wyatt Clarke
The Overprotective Brother
Joshua Bassett as Ricky Bowen
The One That Was Too Late
Olivia Rodrigo as Nini Salazar-Roberts
The Best Friend
Julia Lester as Ashlyn Caswell
The Other Best Friend
Sofia Wylie as Gina Porter
The One Who Is Like A Sister