In our book club, we appreciate (and welcome) constructive feedback and helpful people. Every three rotations of our book club, we nominate the best commenter, the person who gave the best comments to their partners during this period. Our book club admins carefully check every comment and select the best comments and commenters.
As a reward, the best commenter gets a free promotion of their book and, also, either a free review of the first five chapters of one of their stories or a new free cover.
The best commenter for the weeks 6-8 was Phenabeana