Cordelia Goode x Reader x All...

By stayevildarling

9.2K 487 104

Disclaimer: This is a work of fan fiction using characters from the American Horror Story world, which is tra... More

Last spring
Hurting & Fighting
It's so cold
I wanna cry
Another love
Make you feel alright
I wanna kiss you
That would be just ours
No more goodbyes

And if somebody hurts you

686 41 18
By stayevildarling

TW: violence, guns

After Ally asks you inside you feel beyond nervous and it feels like your mind is racing and screaming at you with all the thoughts. ''Please sit down'' Ally points towards the sofa and you and Cordelia sit down. ''Anything to drink?'' she offers and although she is polite you know deep down Ally is also nervous. ''Some water would be nice please'' Cordelia says and Ally looks at you and says ''What about you darling?'' but you shake your head. As Ally goes to the kitchen to get the water for Cordelia you turn to her and say ''And what now? what should we tell her?'' Cordelia turns to you and says ''Y/N we have two options but we gotta tell her about danger, so either lie and make up something or just tell her we are witches'' and you look at her and say ''No way I am not lying to her, with Ally's past I will never do that'' and Cordelia simply nods. ''But she won't just believe us we are witches Cordelia'' you say and the supreme answers ''It's okay let me tell her alright?'' and you nod and it still feels like your heart might just beat out of your chest. After Ally returns she hands Cordelia the glass with water and she sits down across from you two. ''So are you two gonna tell me what is going on now?'' she asks and you look at Cordelia. ''Wait you two aren't gonna tell me that you made a decision Y/N?'' she asks and it breaks your heart a little that she would think you could betray her in such a way. ''No Ally I would never go behind your back'' you say and look at her and she sees that her thinking that hurt you so she quickly says ''Okay just making sure''. Cordelia clears her throat and Ally looks at her ''Listen Ally we have to tell you something and it might be hard for you to believe at first but this is important'' and Ally furrows her eyebrow in confusion what this might be about. ''I'm just gonna be honest with you, there is a possible danger and someone might be after me or Y/N or both of us we don't really know and the truth is they might have followed us here and it's not safe for either of us , you or your son''. Ally thinks for a moment and looks at you then Cordelia again. ''Wait what kind of danger? and who would be after you two and why?'' and now this is the complicated part where your breathing gets heavy and you are terrified of your girlfriends reaction. ''Okay so you might think this is hard to believe at first but the school Y/N attended and the school I lead isn't just any school it's an academy for witchcraft'' Cordelia explains and at first Ally's expression is calm but then she chuckles a little and says ''You two are kidding me right? are you both high or something'' but she quickly realizes by your and Cordelia's expression that you are both serious and not joking. ''Wait so you two are trying to tell me you are what? witches with magic?'' she asks with a hint of sarcasm in her voice. Cordelia simply nods and you look down because you feel bad for never telling this to Ally and not letting her in on this part of your life. ''Ally look I am sorry that I never told you but this knowledge is dangerous and I never meant to bring Oz or you into any danger'' you say and Ally's eyes meet yours again and she still seems sceptic about the whole thing. ''Fine if you both are witches, let's say you aren't high or just completely insane prove it to me'' she demands and you look at Cordelia. The supreme focusses on the glass of water on the table in front of everyone and she raises her hand slightly and the glass starts slowly moving from one side of the table to the other one. ''This power is called Telekineses and it means you can move objects'' you explain and Ally looks at the both of you shocked. ''Is this all some prank? like am I on live television or something and strings are attached to this table and glass'' she asks and you can see in her face she is desperately looking for something to convince her that this isn't real. ''Ally babe please we are serious'' you plead and she turns to you and says ''So you are a witch too?'' and you simply nod. ''Fine you prove it to me too then'' she says and you close your eyes and take a deep breath and next thing you know you disappear from the sofa and you appear behind Ally. ''Woah'' she says and you chuckle a little and you are relieved she is finally seeing this as no trick or prank. ''Fine let's say I believe this.. who is after you?'' she asks still confused. Cordelia explains about witch hunters and that they have been after witches and her coven for years and she talks about Hank and everything that happened today and you can slowly feel Ally starting to panic a little. ''Wait what are we gonna do? we gotta get out of this house then'' she says and you take her hands into yours and say. ''Listen I have a plan, is there anyone Oz can stay at for a few days? maybe his friends'' and Ally thinks a moment before meeting your eyes and nodding. ''Okay we will take him there and then we can stay at my apartment, they don't know that location and we should be safe there for now'' you say and Ally nods. ''Okay you call Oz's friends mother and I will pack his stuff with him okay?'' you ask and Ally gets up and walks to the phone. Cordelia and you make their way upstairs to tell Oz that he is staying with his friend. ''Hey buddy'' you say as you knock on his door and he is currently sitting by his desk reading some comics. ''Oh hey'' he says barely looking at you and Cordelia because he is so into his comic book. ''Listen Oz we have some news, you gotta stay at your friends for a few days'' you explain and he looks at you and Cordelia and asks ''Why is everything okay?'' and you nod and say ''Yes everything's fine but your mommy and me have a few things to take care of over the next few days'' and he nods a bit sadly. ''Hey come on it will be fun and you can take your comics'' you say and cheer him up and a big smile spreads across his face. You help him get his backpack and you get a few clothes out for him and some of his toys. Cordelia watches you and Oz with a smile and as he goes to the bathroom to get some of his things she moves closer to you and says ''You are amazing with him truly'' and you turn to her and see a hint of sadness in her eyes. ''Thank you, you would make a great mother too'' you say and she looks at you with pain in her eyes but also a little smile. ''Really?'' she asks almost needing to hear it again and you say ''Really, Cordelia you are amazing with people and children and you really would make an amazing mother'' and she smiles as some tears build up. Your moment is interrupted when Oz comes back with his backpacked full and ready to get going. ''Okay you ready?'' you ask and he runs out the door excited to go to his friend. After Ally called, you all get into Ally's car and drive him and Ally goes inside with him and drops him off. You and Cordelia make sure no cars have followed or anything suspicious around. After she dropped him off you all make your way to your apartment and as you stand in front of the main entrance of the building Cordelia looks at you two and says ''Well I will stay in my hotel room if you need anything I'm just a building away, we can figure everything else out tomorrow okay?'' and you nod and Ally says ''Thank you Cordelia'' and as you part ways you wish you could have also invited Cordelia into your apartment because you feel bad for her and at the same time you are worried she will be on her own with the threats around. As you and Ally take the elevator to your apartment she can tell you are a bit distracted so she asks ''Are you okay darling?'' and you simply nod and ask ''How about you?'' and she chuckles a little and says ''It's a bit much finding out your girlfriend and her old crush are both witches but apart from that I'm fine'' she says and you both chuckle a bit and you kiss her as you are thankful she is this understanding with the whole thing and already manages to joke about it. After tidying your apartment a little because you haven't been there for a while you and Ally go to bed completely exhausted and it doesn't take long for the brunette to fall asleep but you are wide awake that night your thoughts are preoccupied by the witch hunters and the worrying about Cordelia and also Ally and the guilt of not telling Ally sooner and bringing her and Oz into danger.

That night you barely got any sleep and eventually you gave up on the idea of sleep and you have been sitting on the sofa just staring at the wall for hours. As the light from the sun rising is slowly filling your apartment the exhaustion now hits you because you feel tired after work yesterday and everything that has happened since. Thankfully you don't have a shift at the cafe for the next few days and Ally also got a few days off after what happened and cancelled her meetings. Your plan for today is to find Cordelia with Ally and figure out a plan to find out more about the men that came to the cafe and any way of finding out if they really are witch hunters. Ally wakes up only to find the bed empty and she sees you sitting on the sofa so she makes her way over to you. ''Hey darling'' she says as she wraps her arms around you from behind. ''Hey Ally'' you mumble and as she walks around the sofa and sits next to you she can see how tired you are. ''Didn't you get any sleep?'' she asks and you shake your head. ''I'm worried Ally if they really are after you and Cordelia I couldn't live with myself if anything bad happened'' you say and she cups your cheeks and says ''I understand baby but everything will be fine I promise'' and as you look into her brown eyes you look for any sign to doubt her but she seems so genuine and sure so you believe her. ''Okay'' you mumble and she pulls you into her arms. ''Listen we should find Cordelia and figure something out'' you say and Ally agrees and you both start to get ready by taking a shower and getting changed. You give Ally some of your clothes because she didn't have any time to pack and she wears a sweatshirt and some jeans and you also wear some jeans and a hoodie. After grabbing a bite to eat you and Ally walk hand in hand to Cordelia's hotel. You remember the room she stays in so you lead Ally there and after knocking Cordelia opens with a smile on her face. ''Hey you two'' she says and as you walk inside you can't ignore how stunning she looks again but you can also see how tired she is and that she probably had a hard time sleeping as well. ''We gotta figure something out'' you say and you all take a seat on the sofa in her hotel room. The supreme sits on her bed with her hands on her lap and she says ''Well I have been thinking when we were at the cafe I took a photo of these men and do you know a way we could like track down their identities?'' and you look at Ally hoping she can think of something. ''Hmm I remember we have a register on my work computer from all the voters with photos maybe that could help but it would take hours getting through them because you can't filter them'' but you say ''It doesn't matter as long as we have got a plan right?'' and Cordelia nods and adds ''Can we go there today is that possible?'' and Ally nods. Just as you you are about to leave Cordelia's hotel room to get to Ally's office Cordelia's phone rings and she says ''Hang on it's Zoe''. You take Ally's hand as you are both standing by the door you say ''Thank you, you are a genius'' and she kisses your cheek. As you look at Cordelia you can tell something is off ''Wait Zoe slow down what is going on?'' and you and Ally walk closer to her and panic is written across the supreme's face. The call ends abruptly and she looks at her phone with so much worry and confusion. ''That was Zoe she said someone is at the coven and they are in danger'' and you look at both of the women with panic written across your face. ''It must be those witch hunters we gotta get there'' and Cordelia nods and grabs her things. ''We have to teleport there now Y/N'' and you look at your girlfriend ''I wanna go too'' Ally says but you protest ''No way Ally I am not letting you near danger'' but she says ''Y/N I am your girlfriend I might not be a witch but I won't let either of you go there alone'' she looks at Cordelia and the supreme nods and you still try to protest but it's no use. ''Come on take my hands'' Cordelia says and Ally takes Cordelia's left hand and you her right. ''Ready 3..2..1'' and as you close your eyes you take a deep breath and as you open them again you feel that it's even colder where you just teleported to. 

You take in the familiar white mansion and the black gate and a million flashbacks come flooding in. ''Come on'' Cordelia says and you take Ally's hand and she looks a little stunned at what just happened. You follow the supremes lead inside the coven and you notice an unfamiliar car parked in the parking lot by the greenhouse. As you enter the coven is completely quiet like dead silent and you don't remember it ever being this quiet and the more steps you take towards that front door your body is warning you some threat is around. ''Delia'' you whisper and she looks at you ''There is someone here'' you whisper and she closes her eyes in an effort to find anything a noise hinting what is going on. The three of you jump when you hear a high pitched scream and you all start running towards it immediately. By the long staircase you find a girl passed out with some blood on her face, you don't recognize her so she must be a newer student at the academy. Cordelia kneels down in an effort to heal her and her being supreme and the injuries minor, she manages and the girl breathes heavily as she wakes up. ''Shh shh calm down'' Cordelia says and tears stream down the girls eyes. ''There were some men here they they have guns'' the girl explains and Cordelia leads her to the nearest bathroom and locks the door and tells her to hide in there until this is over. ''Ally you should stay with her please I don't want you getting hurt'' you plead and Cordelia backs you up and says ''Please Ally look after that girl for me'' and Ally doesn't want too but she listens and you make sure to put a protection spell on the door so neither Ally nor the girl can get hurt. ''Follow me'' Cordelia says and you do without hesitating and you and the supreme very quietly make your way upstairs to find someone anyone but there is no sign of anyone. After checking upstairs you both go back downstairs and Cordelia turns to you and says ''Y/N focus you should be able to sense where they are'' and you focus on your body and you take a few steps towards each direction and when you step towards the greenhouse that's when you feel your body acting up the most. ''It's the greenhouse Delia'' you whisper and she nods and takes your hand and leads you to the greenhouse. You carefully open the door only to find pretty much all of the girls in there hiding. ''Oh my god Cordelia'' Zoe says and you can hear how thankful she is to see the supreme there. Queenie and Madison also approach her and that's when they see you. ''Oh my god Y/N'' they say trying not to shout from excitement and forgetting about the circumstances for a moment. ''You found her'' Queenie says with a smile and you suddenly see one of the girls behind you panicking and looking behind you and Cordelia and that's when you see the familiar three men with guns in their hands and masks on walking towards the greenhouse. ''Girls hide now'' Cordelia says and she looks at you and you say ''Cordelia stay in here and protect the girls'' but she takes your wrist and says ''No way Y/N'' but you let go of her grip and you teleport out the greenhouse and in the meantime you lock the greenhouse with another protecting spell making it impossible for the three witch hunters to ever enter. You suddenly stand in front of them and they stop walking and look at you. ''Who are you?'' you shout and they don't say anything but simply point their guns towards you and just in time you manage to teleport away behind them so the bullets don't hit you. ''Did you really think it was smart coming to a place with witches and magic'' you say but all they do is turn around and continue to aim at you for a while. You think of the girls and Ally all locked inside and you know you gotta get the danger away from them so you slowly start walking backwards into the coven to lead them away from Cordelia and the girls. In the meantime the supreme is furious you would bring yourself into danger like that  and she turns to Zoe ''Zoe I gotta get out I gotta help her'' and the four witches join their magic together to try and get rid of the protecting spell so they can help you out. You successfully lead them into the house but you make sure to keep them away from the bathroom Ally is in. You are standing in the middle of the hallway when they keep aiming their guns at you but they quickly realize it's no use because you keep teleporting away from the bullets. The three of them look at each other and they split up which makes it harder for you to get away from them. You teleport to the top of the stairs and one of them is approaching from one side and the other one from the other when you suddenly feel a push and next thing you know you land at the bottom of the stairs and you hit your head slightly but you get up and ready to fight them and protect the coven. They start running towards you and fight you with their bare hands and with all the power you have left in you and ignoring your warning system you try to fight them as best as you can. Meanwhile Ally and the girl can hear fighting and she is trying to get out that door to help whoever is out there. Cordelia and the witches are trying the same and by joining their magic together they manage to get out of the greenhouse and they make sure that Madison stays with the younger witches and Zoe and Queenie follow the supreme inside. In the meantime you are trying to fight them off and you successfully managed to knock one of them out, he is currently on the floor but the other two are harder to fight because whenever you see to punch or push them they only come back stronger like some kind of machine. The wound on your head hurts and you try and not focus on the pain but on protecting everyone and defeating the witch hunters. You are focused on fighting one of them when the other one suddenly grabs you and throws you onto the nearest wall next to the bathroom. ''Ah'' you scream out in pain and Ally must have heard you because she is banging against the door screaming for someone to let them out but you wouldn't let them near her. ''You are finished witch bitch'' the other one shouts and picks you up and for the next few seconds or so they just continue to punch and kick you and your vision is slowly becoming blurry and you can taste blood in your mouth. At this point your body is giving up on you and you try to hit them and get you away but it's no use and in the matter of seconds you suddenly hear footsteps and many things happen at the same time. You can see Cordelia and the girls through your blurry vision. Zoe let's out Ally and the younger witch and Queenie uses her voodoo magic to knock the witch hunters out and your body drops onto the floor away from their grip. At the same time Cordelia and Ally run to you and they find you on the floor beaten and unconscious. ''Y/N'' they shout at the same time and that's the last time you hear their voices for the next few days.

After you passed out Cordelia and Ally took you to the greenhouse where Cordelia got all of her healing potions out and tried to soothe your wounds. After a fight like that she can't completely heal you because there might be internal damage but she uses some spells on you to get you to heal and she reassures Ally that you will be okay once you wake up again. The two of them stayed in the greenhouse with you for a while before the supreme moved you to her bedroom and Ally stayed with you day and night for the first two days. It's particularly hard for Ally because she felt powerless and weak when she heard you fight for everyone and she couldn't do anything to protect you, she is worried sick about you and she would often sit on the edge of the bed and stroke your cheeks but making sure not to hurt the bruises. Cordelia in the meantime tried to distract herself from what happened in her own way. She blames herself for letting you go out there to fight them on your own and that she couldn't get there sooner to protect you. After taking care of you in the greenhouse and moving you to her bedroom she spent the next few days in her office and with the girls and she made sure they are okay and she also used a spell on the witch hunters to learn about them, their intention and if there are any more. They learned that those three are left from the Cooperative and since Hank and Fiona killed Harrison a few years back they were some of the last witch hunters left on their own mission. Them tracking down Cordelia was a coincidence and they used Michigan as a distraction and last night they came all the way back to the coven. Madison suggested to just kill them but Cordelia isn't cruel so she wiped their memories completely and they have no knowledge of each other or their past life and she gave them a second chance somewhere. Ally wondered why Cordelia wasn't also staying with you or checking up on you but she had no idea that Cordelia is. The supreme would go into the room late at night when everyone is asleep and she sits next to you and strokes your head with tears streaming down her face seeing you like this. Cordelia sees Ally asleep on a chair and she gets a blanket and wraps it around the brunette before she goes back to her office. The supreme sits in her office for hours until her body would give up and she falls asleep on the chair her head resting on the table. It has been like this for two days now and you haven't woken up yet. The next morning Ally wakes up only to see you in the same position and she moves closer to you and holds your hand when she suddenly feels your hand pressing hers lightly. ''Y/N?'' Ally almost shouts her heart beating fast. ''Ally'' you mumble and you try to open your eyes but your entire body hurts so you only open them a little bit. ''Baby you are awake, how you are feeling?'' she asks and her hands cup your cheeks. ''I wanna go home Ally'' is all you mumble before falling asleep again the pain too much to handle while being awake. Shortly after Cordelia walks into the bedroom after hearing Ally call your name. ''Is she awake?'' the supreme says and Ally gets up and walks closer to the blonde. ''Yes she was awake for a second and she said she wants to go home?'' Ally says with a bit of hesitation. ''I also have to get back to my son'' Ally says and Cordelia looks at you, then down to the floor and says. ''Okay sure I can take you both home''. Ally walks to the bed and holds your hand and in her other hand she holds Cordelia's. The supreme closes her eyes and next thing you know your body is still in the same position but in Ally's bed back in Michigan. ''Thank you Cordelia'' Ally says and the supreme says ''It's my pleasure, I remembered your bedroom from looking after her once and that's how I was able to teleport here''. Both women look at you and it breaks both their hearts to see you this vulnerable and hurt. ''I need to go back to the girls and the coven'' Cordelia says and looks at Ally. The brunette looks at the supreme surprised and says ''Please don't go'' but Cordelia insists ''I gotta get back to the girls I can't just leave them after an attack like this they need me'' and as she is about to leave Ally grabs her wrist and says ''We need you too, please at least come back?'' and the surprised supreme meets Ally's pleading eyes and whispers ''I promise'' and next thing Ally knows the supreme is gone back at the coven in New Orleans. 


Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

26.6K 1.2K 13
Disclaimer: This is a work of fan fiction using characters from the American Horror Story world, which is trademarked by Twentieth Century Fox Film C...
61.5K 1.9K 101
Her whole life Cynthia Primrose Moore felt unloved and misunderstood. She felt like she was missing something. That was until she met Michael a boy w...
10.7K 436 31
Jackson is boy who on his last year of high school, his parents made him go to camp. His family weren't really a rich type of family but he was popul...
57K 2.5K 48
Disclaimer: This is a work of fan fiction using characters from the American Horror Story world, which is trademarked by Twentieth Century Fox Film C...