"Yes! Yes! Yes! A million times yes!" Rachel yelled as she waited for him to slid the finger onto her ring finger "well it's about damn time" Rachel slightly laughed before she tackled him into a tight hug as she pressed kisses all over his face.

After a few minutes Finn stood back up and smiled down at her as she stared at her ring, "You like it?"

"I love it," Rachel breathed, "where did you get it?"

"My mom. That's the ring my biological dad gave to my mom. Apparently, he talked about giving it to me."

"When did your mom give you this? Two years ago."

"Seriously? And you're just now giving it to me?"

Finn laughed, "Thank you for your patience, does your left hand still feel naked?"

"I see you have been catching my comments."

Finn laughed, "Oh yeah, loud and clear," Finn chuckled and kissed her lips, "I love you, fiancé."

"I love you more, fiancée" Rachel giggled before pressing her lips back to his.

"This is definitely the best day of my life," Finn mumbled into the kiss with a smile.

"Okay, enough already! I want to see the ring!" Kurt said as he walked over with Quinn and Marley.

Rachel turned around in Finn's arms and held her hand out to him.

"This is beautiful. Where did you-wait-isn't this the ring Carol always wears around her neck? I haven't seen it in forever it feels like."

"Yeah, she gave it to me two years ago. It's the ring my dad proposed to her with."

"Your dad had amazing taste," Kurt observed, "I wonder whatever happened to you."

Finn rolled his eyes, "I'm not even going to let your smart ass remarks get to me tonight."

Kurt rolled his eyes and hugged them both, "I'm happy for you," he whispered in Finn's ear.

"Bro! Why did your speech have to be so good? Now Marley and Quinn are going to get on our asses for not delivering a good enough speech."

"You're damn right we are!" Quinn and Marley said.

"His speech to Rachel was beautiful," Marley smiled.

Finn chuckled, "Sorry…?"

Puck chuckled and shook his head, "I'm happy for you dude. Take good care of him, Rachel."

Rachel wrapped her arms around Finn's neck as she stared up at him lovingly, "I will."

"Congratulations,"

As expected, Rachel was attached to Finn side for the rest of the night. Everywhere he went she went and everywhere she went she pulled him along with her. He didn't mind though, he just kept his hand tightly wrapped around her's and if they weren't holding hands he had his arms wrapped around her waist.

"Thank you for tonight, baby," Rachel mumbled into his ear as she sat on his lap with her head on his shoulder while they waited for everyone to leave.

"No problem," Finn smiled and kissed her forehead.

"You know, I really thought you forgot my birthday," Rachel laughed softly as she ran her fingers through his hair, "I was pretty upset and I thought you were cheating on me."

"You what?" Finn laughed.

"Hey, I was pretty upset and when you called and I heard laughing from another woman when you were supposed to be at the gym and then you rushed off the phone. What was I supposed to think?"

"Anything, but that," Finn looked down at her, "I'd never do that to you."

"I know! That's what I said, but I didn't know what to think! I felt like I was going crazy."

"Didn't seem like it when I got home."

"Well, I didn't have any actual proof and you were being so cute."

Finn smiled, "Well, I'm glad my cuteness stopped you from questioning me because then I would have had to tell you about my surprise so you wouldn't start throwing things at my head or something."

"Not all women throw things when they are angry."

"Well, you haven't thrown anything at my head yet so, I guess, I believe you."

Rachel rolled her eyes, "How about we go home and have our own private celebration?" Rachel whispered in his ear before pressing an open mouth kiss to the spot right below his ear.

Finn stood up, making her slid off his lap, "I thought you'd never ask. Let me do a few things before, first, I'll meet you in the car."

Rachel nodded and pecked his lips before saying goodbye to her dads and going outside.

"Hey, Will, Emma, thanks for coming."

"We couldn't pass up free tickets to New York," Will laughed.

Finn smiled and picked up the little boy standing in front of him, "You tired William?" Instead of naming him Finn they decided to change it to being his middle name so his name is William Finnegan Schuester, which Finn is actually happy about because he really didn't like his name too much.

"Yes.." He nodded and laid his head on Finn's shoulder.

"You still want me to take you around tomorrow or do you think you're going to be too tired tomorrow too?"

"No! I not going to be tired!"

Finn chuckled, "Good, I'll come get you at noon okay? I'm going to get Noah jr and my other nephew come too, and we're going to have a guys day, that sound cool?"

"Yeah!"

"I don't think Willy being friends with Noah jr is a good idea," Emma scrunched up her nose, "I mean his dad is Noah Puckerman."

Finn laughed, "Puck is my best friend and I've turned out pretty good, plus, Kurt's son is a pretty good boy, he'll keep them both in check. Like Kurt keeps Puck and I grounded, sometimes."

Will laughed, "Well, we're going to let you get back to your fiancé, I know she is probably freaking out because you aren't next to her."

Finn shook his head, "She'll be alright, but I do really need to get back to her."

"I'll take him," Emma said as she reached out to take a now sleeping William.

"Congratulations again," Will smiled, "you've come a long way."

Finn smiled, "Thanks," he said before walking away. "Hey Kurt and Puck, both of your sons better be ready when I pick them up tomorrow, noon!" Finn said as he walked out of the restaurant.

"He thinks because he just got engaged he can be bossy. That's my job," Kurt rolled his eyes.

Yay finchel is engaged it's about time am I right😉 anyways guys I hopeyou like this chapter and my game of would you rather is now up if you wanna play it's now up on my page!

No Strings Where stories live. Discover now