- "Cabin days" Complete
- Reads 18,797
- Votes 350
- Parts 14
- Time 43m
After the Slenderman forces Jeff and Ben to go to a cabin for a whole week what adventures will the two killers have? And what feelings will they come to realize? this is a Ben x Jeff story, so if you don't like it then don't read it. Ben is 18 and Jeff is 19 - Dead Again - Jeff The Killer x Reader Complete
- Reads 705,094
- Votes 18,894
- Parts 35
- Time 2h 21m
Jeff The Killer x Reader *Mature language *Gory/upsetting scenes *Basically just a meme at this point *im on crack For all you Jeff fangirls :) (I'm one myself don't worry) Enjoy. STARTED: 06/06/19 ENDED: 09/07/19 - Creepypasta Headcannons Book 2 Complete
- Reads 994,285
- Votes 16,151
- Parts 197
- Time 45m
Well whaddya know whaddya know I actually managed to fill up an entire book with these bloody headcannons. And, surprise surprise, I have an overactive imagination, so here we go again! NOTE: Read the first headcannons book before this one. You'll thank me later - Creepypasta Headcannons Complete
- Reads 2,118,138
- Votes 42,973
- Parts 199
- Time 49m
I've read so many of these headcannon books, so I thought why not make my own? - ⌫ " Our Story. " ~Jeff x Ben~ Complete
- Reads 15,633
- Votes 447
- Parts 9
- Time 47m
♔ " "I was TEASING you," he said, cutting Jeff off. Jeff looked up. Ben couldn't help looking into his eyes. "Well... There was some truth to it, I guess..." Jeff mumbled. "And- that's totally okay," Ben added, smiling comfortingly. I wish we could just get away by ourselves. Even if he doesn't like me- I just want to spend some time alone with him. I'm not being selfish, right? Ben thought. " ♔ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ This is a really old Jeffrey Woods x Ben Drowned fanfic I wrote a long time ago lmao. I think I'm going to continue it. (((Btw, one of my friends is very briefly this story because we have a joke about her being a self insert into creepypasta. So... yeah! (I know this is a bit cringe, but it's fun, so, oh well.))) - (DISCONTINUED) Creepypasta 7 minutes in heaven Complete
- Reads 17,201
- Votes 189
- Parts 7
- Time 19m
The story will include (hopefully I can't guaretee cause I might get lazy and give up on this story) EJ, Ticci Toby, Jeff, Ben and maybe more - jeff the killer x ben drowned Complete
- Reads 25,314
- Votes 300
- Parts 7
- Time <5 mins
smut 18+ Ben is told to get along with jeff but what will happen when Ben finds out Jeff's gay ..... read and find out - Jeff The Killers Pet ( jeff x reader ) Complete
- Reads 112,894
- Votes 2,134
- Parts 35
- Time 3h 4m
What would you do if you become the pet of one of the most wanted killer in the world.... Read to find out.. - Blood (Jeff x reader) Complete
- Reads 471,504
- Votes 13,612
- Parts 25
- Time 1h 58m
"You..." you say, shocked to see him. "Y-Your the guy from the park... Aren't you?" "That's me all right," he says. "I believe I didn't introduce myself. My name is Jeffrey Woods, but everyone knows me as Jeff the killer. I'd prefer if you call me Jeff, thank you." - Glass Closet (Ticcitoby X Ben Drowned) DISCONTINUED Complete
- Reads 1,892
- Votes 41
- Parts 9
- Time 25m
-🐀 This story is discontinued and I probably won't be working on it again - Creepypasta Headcanons Complete
- Reads 951,637
- Votes 15,145
- Parts 131
- Time 1h 7m
Creepypasta and Marble Hornets [ NONE OF THESE ARE FACTS UNLESS BLATANTLY STATED, THESE ARE ALL HEADCANONS, WHICH ARE MERE INFERENCES ] - Creepypasta: All Characters x Reader (One Shots); Seven Minutes in Hell Complete
- Reads 272,025
- Votes 2,894
- Parts 9
- Time 31m
Just a common Creepypasta Seven Minutes in Heaven. Reader insert and also beware of warnings. The story contains: gore, rape themes, curses, smut (lemons) and much more. Please be aware of those before starting to read this~ - ~painful love~ Jeff x Ben Complete
- Reads 4,933
- Votes 58
- Parts 5
- Time 27m
🪷IM NOT SURE IF ILL BE ADDING MORE/ CONTINUING THIS STORY, MAYBE LATER ON BUT IVE BEEN A BIT BUSY🪷 ⚠️TW:⚠️ some self harm. cursing/cussing maybe smut later on? ------------------------- 🤍 A creepy pasta story of Ben drowned and Jeff the killer. how both males hide feelings for each other, the pains and struggles they both go through to figure out how to show affection , or because of how much love hurts.💚 🔪I know this ship is a bit controversial! but just to clear things up, In the original stories Ben is 12 and Jeff is 13! In my story they are both in their teens! (they should be in there late teens to early 20s now idk specifics but you can research if you want) 🔪 Please do not send any hate to me or any other people who support this! and if you personally don't like this ship Its 100% okay! and I respect your decision! just please don't hate on others!
You are seeing 15 of 5.7K results