Select All
  • Camp Creepypasta {Ticci Toby x Reader} [BOOK 1]
    155K 3.9K 27

    Basically, you're 18. You were homeschooled your entire life but you were fine with that, you preferred to be alone. Your parents never cared to spend time with you and they neglected you which was part of the reason you were so used to being alone. You loved creepypastas and read them whenever your parents would negl...

    Completed  
  • Nightmare or Daydream? (Ticci Toby X Reader)
    224K 5.8K 47

    (I started this when I was about 13 so please don't hate the first half too much!) "It was you all along, looking out for me?" Toby nodded looking down. "Of course." #623 Horror - August 30 2018 #255 Ticci Toby - February 1 2019 #12 Guy x girl - June 2 2019 #85 Creepypasta x reader June 2 2019 #295 Creepypasta - Janua...

    Completed  
  • Childhood (Ticci Toby x Reader)
    1.6M 51.4K 37

    A little girl. No older than 3. Abandoned in the forest and left to die by her parents. The only thing she had was her family scrapbook and a stuffed animal. Befriended the beast called The Rake that day. She ate some poisonous berries by accident and almost died. Her new friend hollered to the being known as Slenderm...

    Completed  
  • Sᴜʀʀᴏɴᴅ (Tɪᴄᴄɪ ᴛᴏʙʏ × Rᴇᴀᴅᴇʀ)
    26.2K 768 37

    You live up in a mountain. Most of the people that know of your existence call you a 'hermit'. So, you were excited when two men went knocking on your door. Though, they weren't there to give you some company. They were there to recruit you for something but, promised that you'd finally make friends. Notable ranks :∆...

    Completed  
  • How Far Will You Go? (Yandere Ticci Toby X Reader)
    129K 3.2K 26

    Hey everyone! Long story short I'm going to be posting the Ticci Toby story on this new Wattpad account. Sorry but Wattpad wasn't able to let me back in my original account :( ______ Toby seems to have new feelings towards a new girl. She's bold, confident, and surprisingly nice. No one has been this nice since his si...

  • Trapped (A Ticci Toby Story)
    36.6K 1.3K 27

    ***This story is told completely through Toby's POV*** My life has stopped... I was supposed to keep training. I was supposed to keep developing the skills that it took to be the slenderman's proxy. I was supposed to be there for Sally when she couldn't sleep. I was supposed to be between Jeff and Ben while they tried...

    Completed  
  • Forgotten Promises: The Revision
    17.6K 707 10

    "You promised a lot of things to me. You must remember at least one of them, or at least remember me. Are you sure you don't remember any-" "I'm sorry. I really don't." STARTED: APRIL 4, 2020 ENDED: ON GOING A TICCI TOBY X READER FANFIC HIGHEST RANKINGS: #67 in shortstory (190k+ stories) #117 in creepypasta (61k+ stor...

  • Cut it. (Ticci Toby x Reader!)
    210K 4.2K 26

    A normal dawn turns into a crucial kidnapping by the one and only, Tobias Rogers. Afterwards you raise a bunch of red flags that soon uncover your past. ------------------ Send me a message if you know the covers author. highest ranking in tags is; Ticcitobyxreader- #1 creepypastaxreader- #1 creepypas...

    Completed  
  • Axe-idental | Creepypasta | Ticci Toby x Reader |
    12.9K 338 13

    "It's not an axe. It's a hatchet." He said, annoyance very evident in his tone. "What's the difference?" "A lot." ------------------ It's my first x reader, so cut me a little slack There should be trigger warnings in this story, but just in case I forget to add them, there will be mentions of suicide, homicide, and r...