Travis pov
Lawrence swallows my cum without any problems.
"mm sweet" he licked his lips
"shocking I would've thought because of his salty attitude he'd be salty" Garroth smirked
I'm still panting after ejaculating while these two idiots are rating my cum.
Garroth grabbed some more lube to lubricate his dick.
"now time the main event" Garroth smiled
He raised my ass and massages my butthole before penetrating with his cock.
I tear up as it starts to stretch me out as it goes deeper.
" it's ok Travis he's almost in" Lawrence reassuring tone tries to calm me down
"Lawrence..." I moaned and leaned on him
Garroth stopped moving and let my body adjust to the size. He rubbed my nipples and kissed my neck.
"you're doing great for your first time" Garroth whispers
"please move" I looked up at them
I think I felt something throb in me
"I'm moving Travis"
Garroth slowly moved in and out but gradually increase the speed when it was easy for me. Lawrence kissed me then lowered my head to his hard cock.
As if Garroth fucking my ass wasn't enough.
I licked it at first, but then it went den my throat.
"Travis you're so tight" Garroth groaned
"Travis!" Lawrence moaned and thrust his cock in and out my throat.
My head couldn't concentrate on both ends being fucked.
I screamed when Garroth's dick went deeper and hit my weak spot.
Lawrence grabbed my head and went faster as his cock was throbbing erratically.
"ahh" he moaned and cummed in my mouth
I choked on his cock that was releasing too much semen in my mouth.
Garroth pulled me up and went in harder than he did before.
"I'm about to ahh" I moaned
Garroth bit my shoulder and licked the blood the leaked out from the bite. It left a hot sensation in my body that made me cum on the bed.
Garroth came in me a minute after and laid down with me.
"Now you're officially our mate" Lawrence smiled and kissed me on the forehead
---
I woke up to the smell of soap, I was in a bath tube with Garroth behind me.
Huh, I don't hate him as much as I did before, is because I'm his "mate" or something?
Garroth stirred awake and look down on me and smiled
"you're awake... I was cleaning you up at first but I thought we could relax in the tub together-"
"get out" I cut him off
"why?" he asked confused
"Just leave," I said annoyed
"..." Garroth got up and left with a towel around his waist
I sighed and sank into the water.
Yesterday was intense... Dammit, I wanted Lawrence to take my first time, not the stupid mutt. Ugh, that's why I even let them make me their mate.
But at least I get to see Lawrence's expressions that I didn't know he could make. He drank my cum and let me my mouth on his, I got to suck his cock...
I look down to see I was hard just thinking about him.
I started to jerk off with his image in his head
When are we going on that date he promised? I bet it's a dinner date or something fun like the carnival. Does he like simple dates like taking a stroll at night at the park or picnic alone under a tree?
"ah... fuck Lawrence" I moaned cummed in my hands
I can't wait...
Garroth Pov
Geez... When do I tell Travis that I can hear his thoughts loud and clear now that we're mates?
I could feel his strong feelings for Lawrence
I looked down at my boner and sighed
He must love Lawrence a lot... He didn't think about me once except called me a stupid mutt.
I heard Dante come downstairs and yawn
"Hey bro" he greets and took a box of cereal and ate it from the box
"hey didn't get much sleep?"
"no I was covering for a colleague at the hospital and then I was called in again" he whined "but how's Travis doing? Does he still hate you?"
I flinched and said "well he's dating Lawrence and I but he likes Lawrence more than me"
"well, he'll come around. Trust, me I've been with him since high school, and even though he's as stubborn as a goat he will like you on his own time" Dante pats my shoulder "well I'm taking a nap"
Thanks, Dante I would believe you if I didn't hear his thoughts while fapping to it...
Travis came down wearing jeans and a turtle neck with his lanyard.
"hey, I made you breakfast-"
"I'll get a latte at Starbucks," he said indifferently
"oh I can drop you at work" I suggested
" I can walk" he took his keys and left
I growled and looked at Dante who witnessed everything.
"don't give up Garroth you got this" even Dante don't sound too sure about his own words
Travis pov
I checked in the clinic and put my white dentist coat on.
"Hey Travis" Lucinda greeted with coffee
"hey guess what?"
"you moved in and got a boyfriend?" she guessed
"close but I'm dating Lawrence now," I said excitingly
"whoa that's great but isn't he Garroth's mate?" she asks
my face and mood went down.
"oh forget I said that, congrats on landing your first boyfriend" she smiles
"what Travis got a boyfriend?" Blaze walks in
"yeah Lawrence~," I said happily
"Lawrence? But why do you smell more like Garroth?" he asked while sniffing me
My face and mood went down.
"yikes sorry I said anything but" Blaze pulled my coat and sleeve aside to reveal a blue and golden moon mark on my shoulder "aha so you are Garroth's mate but does this mean you're his second mate?"
"Yeah, I guess..." I frowned
"so your dating Garroth and Lawrence" Lucinda trying to piece the facts together
"Yeah but I'm dating Lawrence" I glared not wanting to continue this conversation
"you're so mean..." Blaze said "Garroth cares for you as much as Lawrence does and now that you're his mate now I bet he felt hurt when from feeling your hate towards him and not giving him any love"
"he took everything from me!" I yelled "my first love and my virginity! I'm not letting him take my first date!"
"guys keep it down" Lucinda warns us as some workers glance at us.
" I feel sorry for Garroth right now I would reject my mate if they're acting like you" blaze shakes his head and left.
I don't get it why am I getting blamed I didn't do anything wrong.
"Lucinda am I a bad person?" I asked her
"well not right now you're just confused about your feelings between Garroth and Lawrence since it hasn't been long that you mated with Garroth." she gave me a reasonable answer
" What's a mate?" I asked her again
"well a mate for werewolves is a partner for life, mates love and care for each other, werewolves that choose their mates, and to protect their loved ones from the harm of any kind. since you're a second mate this applies to you too" she explained
"you loved Lawrence your whole life and wanted to be with him only it's common sense your feeling this way. But since the time you've been turned to a mate has your hate towards Garroth changed?"
"well, I guess I don't hate him like before I'm just avoiding him..."
"you see it'll be fine, now let's get back to work"
---
I'm on a lunch break with Lucinda and Blaze.
"I'm sorry I yelled at you" I apologized
"it fine I shouldn't have gotten mad its not my love life" he smiled and first bumps me "oh I forgot to mention there some rare side effects when it comes to being a mate like being able to reproduce, super smell, being in heat, and cramps but like I said it's rare"
"but just in case" Lucinda handed me a bag of birth control pills, expensive condoms, and a heated pad.
"...thanks" I sweat dropped
--
I got home and immediately got pinned down to the floor by Garroth.
The air was full of tension and Garroth's strong scent made it hard to breathe.
I looked to my right to see Dante on his laptop with headphones on.
"Gar... Wait..." I struggled to speak because of his presence
"Why do you hate me so much? Is it because I confess to Lawrence first? Did I make your longtime crush a bottom? Because I took your first time? I offered you to be our mate you still hate me, I offered you food you still hate me, and I offered you a ride to work and you still hate me. Why do I smell another werewolf scent on you? Did he touch you? Did he kiss you? Why Travis huh WHY?" he growled but I could hear that he's hurting
Blaze was right
"Garroth please let go and hear me out" I smiled at him
He quickly lets me go and waits for what I have to say.
"listen I indeed hated you before but because of Blaze and Lucinda at work, I learned that I'm warming up to you. Slowly. As for your questions... Yes I hated you for confessing first, maybe I also hated you turning my crush and high school role model into a bottom, yeah I was saving my first time for Lawrence but you had to do what you had to do, you're only smelling Blaze because he showed me your mark and gave me the rundown on mates with Lucinda, and no he did not kiss me he wouldn't do that to you and me" I sighed after answering
"Can I kiss you?" Garroth asked
"... I guess-"
Garroth cut me off giving me a long deep kiss before pulling away from me.
"Lawrence asked if you're still up for a date that he promised" Garroth scratches his head
"Yeah I'm free tomorrow" I blushed with a smile on my face.
1 hour later
"I'm home~" Lawrence entered and kissed us on the cheek.
He lifted me in his arms and held me close.
"hows are little mate doing?" he smiled
"great you must be happy" I blushed
" I beat a guy in court and I get to come home to my lovely people," he said brightly and passed me to Garroth "I'm going to take a long warm shower"
He skipped up the stairs and left me in Garroth arms.
"... Can you put me down?" I asked
"no~" he refused to give me up and hugged me tightly
Yikes this is long and there's a part 3
👁👄👁💧