Old Me

By warriorpwr

7.5K 115 8

Beatrice has just graduated college and returned home to help at her family business: a tattoo shop. She isn'... More

Author's Note
Main Characters
Language Key
1 - Not My Type
2 - The Meet Cute
3 - Sleepover
4 - The Set Up
5 - Flirting?
6 - The Date Part 1
7 - The Date Part 2
8 - The Date Part 3
9 - Meet The Fam
10 - The Interrogation
11 - Party Preparations
12 - Sharing Secrets
13 - Can't Relate
14 - First Dance
15 - Second Date
16 - Coronado
17 - Don't Tell
18 - ReDo
19 - Dinner
20 - Netflix & Chill
21 - Closer
22 - Band Practice
23 - ER
24 - Cool Scar
25 - Results
26 - Past Is Apparent
27 - His Fault
28 - You're cute
29 - Betrayal
30 - Apologize
31 - Cuddle weather
32 - Lights Out
33 - Secrets
34 - Stay
35 - Exclusive
36 - Spill
37 - Official
38 - Goodnight
39 - Out of My Limit
40 - Room for Jesus
41 - Love
42 - Consequences
43 - Fair
44 - Salt and Sun
45 - Road Trippin'
46 - My Lips Are Sealed
47 - Don't Stop
48 - Can I Join?
49 - Fireworks
50 - Desperate
51 - Girls Talk Boys
52 - Empty House
53 - Love Bites
54 - Five Years Free
55 - Cold Feet
56 - Just Say It
57 - Ready
59 - Old Me
60 - Dirty Laundry
61 - Everything I Didn't Say
62 - Before I Met You
63 - Can't Help It
64 - I.F.L.Y.
65 - Mine
66 - Back to You
67 - She's Kinda Hot
68 - All the Small Things
69 - The Best Years
70 - Epilogue
Mikey POV Ch 1
Mikey POV Ch 4
Mikey POV Ch 7/16/17
Mikey's POV Ch 21
Mikey's POV Ch 60

58 - Better Man

89 1 0
By warriorpwr

I was still giddy from just having lost my virginity as I sat in the passenger seat of Micheal's car. Music played softly in the background, something acoustic that was unfamiliar to me. I couldn't help but smile as I watched him focus on the road. It wasn't until we were exiting the freeway that a pit started to form in my stomach.

Oh my gosh. What if my parents can tell? What if they find out? They will be so disappointed that I didn't wait until marriage...wait, did I just make a huge mistake?

The phone ringing loudly over his Bluetooth shook me from my thoughts.

"Sorry, just a second," he said as he pressed the accept button on his steering wheel.

"Hi, mom. I'm actually driving Bea home right now. Can I call you back in twenty?" Mikey explained, flashing me an apologetic smile.

"Hi, love. Oh, that's okay. Tell her I said hello. When are you bringing her over so that I can meet her?" She asked.

Her accent sounded much thicker than Michael's.

"Oh, um, I dunno. Can we talk about this later?" Mikey asked uncomfortably.

"Why don't you come next weekend? I'll prepare a nice lunch. I've already got the day off work on Saturday," she explained.

Mikey sighed and scrunched up his face.

"It'll be just you, right?" He asked hesitantly.

I wasn't sure what that meant. Did he mean that we would be excluding his dad?

"Yes, love. He'll be at work," she said, with a tone that almost sounded like sadness.

"Well I'll have to ask, Bea, but I'll let you know. Okay, bye now. I'll call you back," Mikey said, ending the conversation.

"Okay, bye. Love you, son," she said before Mikey hung up the call.

"Sorry about that. And please don't feel pressured to go. We really don't have to," he said, looking over at me after he placed his car in park across from my house.

"No, I want to meet your parents--or your mom," I corrected realizing that his father wouldn't be there.

After a moment of silence, I continued, "I mean unless you don't want me to meet her."

"No, no. It's not that. It's just..." he stared out the windshield in thought for a moment before continuing, "it's just that my family isn't as...nice as yours is."

"Baby, I don't care about that," I paused, realizing that I had just called him baby, "She's your mom. I mean, if this is going to last, I'll meet her eventually anyway right?" I smiled, grabbing his hand.

"Yeah, I guess you're right," he shrugged, lacing our fingers together.

We sat in silence for a moment before he suddenly spoke.

"How are you feeling?"

I knitted my brows together, not exactly sure what he was talking about.

"About the sex," he clarified, looking into my eyes.

"Oh," I said, suddenly feeling embarrassed, "fine."

I chewed on my bottom lip as the thoughts from earlier began to intrude. Am I fine with it?

"I'm serious, I want to know. Do you regret it? Because we don't have to do it again. I know that you had said you were wanting to wait until marriage and I meant it when I said I would wait if that's what you wanted."

I glanced up at his sincere face and smiled.

"Are you saying that one day you're going to marry me?" I asked trying to change the subject.

"Well, one day. But that's beside the point, Bea. I want you to be honest. Are you okay?"

I grumbled to myself staring at our interlocked hands.

"I don't know, I guess I don't regret it because I can't take it back. And...it was really fun. But, I guess I'm just worried about what my parents would think of me if they knew," I admitted softly.

He used his free hand to raise my head so we were looking eye to eye. The corner of his mouth was twitching to smile.

"I'm glad you had fun. And if you don't want to do it again, then we don't have to. You can set the boundary where you want," he said.

I nodded, biting my lip as I tried not to smile. How did I get lucky? What did I do to deserve such a sweet man?

"You know, most guys wouldn't ask these questions," I said.

"And I probably wouldn't have if you'd met me a year or two ago. But, there's something about you. You make me a better man," he smiled, leaning in to peck my lips.

I smiled but kissed him back, running my free hand through his hair.

He chuckled and pulled away after a few moments.

"You just can't get enough can you?" He teased.

I bit my lip, feeling flushed, and shook my head.

God, he made me want to melt.

I didn't want to leave him. I wished we could've ended the night in a sleepover. I could touch him all day and never get bored. It was electrifying.

"You should get inside," he smiled, releasing my hand from his.

I sighed and nodded reluctantly.

"When will I see you again?" I asked trying not to sound too disappointed.

"Hm, maybe Wednesday?" He suggested.

Ugh, that was so far away. I smiled, trying to seem happy about it, and nodded okay.

I collected my purse from the floor and unbuckled my seatbelt reaching for the door.

"Hey," he said softly, grabbing my arm.

I turned around waiting for him to continue.

"I love you," he said smiling.

I involuntarily smiled back, "I love you, too. I'll see you soon."

I exited the car and waved goodbye from the porch before entering the house. I sent a prayer that it wasn't obvious to anyone I had just had sex as I slipped off my shoes by the front door.

"I'm home!" I called out.

"In here," my mom called out from the back of the house.

"Hi mamma, hey Cat," I greeted, leaning against the island counter.

"How was school today?" I asked Cat, trying to push my paranoid thoughts out of my mind.

"Good, we got to help decorate the classroom for Halloween. Tomorrow we get to carve pumpkins during recess if we want," she said enthusiastically.

"Hm, you sure you are doing any learning at school?" I teased.

She scoffed and rolled her eyes dramatically, causing my mom and me to giggle.

"Cat, you've got to go get ready for bed. Put away your coloring," my mom instructed in Italian.

"Guess what happened today, mamma?" I asked, trying not to smile too widely.

"What happened?" she asked as she watched Cat clean up her crayons from the kitchen table.

"I told Michael that I loved him..." I paused for effect, waiting for her reaction.

"Seriously? What'd he say?" she asked wide-eyed.

"He said it back!" I said with excitement, bouncing on the balls of my feet.

"Aw," she sighed, "I'm so happy for you. I told you that you wouldn't regret it."

My face was feeling flushed remembering what happened afterward.

I cleared my throat, "Well, I'm going to go call the girls and tell them the good news. Goodnight ma," I said as I kissed her.

"Goodnight, tesoro."

I ran upstairs and threw myself on my bed as I unlocked my phone to video call Siena and Lucia. I waited anxiously for them to answer and rolled onto my back, staring up at the ceiling.

"Hello?" Siena finally answered.

"Oh my god, I have so much to tell you guys. Let's wait a second for Lucia to join," I said, sitting up and hugging a pillow from beside me.

"Oh my god, you had sex didn't you?" she said raising her eyebrows in shock.

"Shh, just wait," I sighed, giggling to myself.

"Oh for fucks sake! Lucia, answer your damn phone already," Siena said impatiently as if she could hear.

Moments later Lucia's face popped up on the screen.

"Hey Luch," I greeted.

"Enough with the pleasantries, spill already," Siena said with glee.

"Okay okay," I sighed, "Well, first off. We said I love you."

I couldn't stop myself from grinning as they awwed at my announcement.

"And then we might have gone back to his place..." I began.

"You little shit," Lucia said playfully.

"And we...had...sex!" I said as loudly as I dared, fully aware that my parents could eavesdrop outside my door at any moment.

"Oh my god! Our little Beatrice is all grown up!" Siena exclaimed.

"So, did it hurt?" Luch asked.

"Honestly, no...I thought it was supposed to right?" I asked confused.

"He must really know what he's doing..." Siena cooed wiggling her eyebrows.

"Shut up," I scoffed.

"Wow, I can't believe you did it. I was so sure you were going to wait," Lucia added.

"I know, I know. I feel weird now," I admitted.

"Why?" Siena asked.

"I dunno, I just feel like if my parents knew they would be so disappointed in me," I said picking at my comforter nervously.

"Seriously, don't worry about what other people think. What matters is what you think. Do you regret it?" Siena asked.

I thought about it for a moment before responding. 

"Well, no. I mean, I can't take it back so it's not worth regretting."

"Exactly. Besides, it was awesome wasn't it?" Siena added.

"Kinda," I giggled to myself.

"Yeah, well, that's the point," Lucia lectured, "As long as you don't regret it, screw what anyone else thinks. You're an adult, Bea. I think you made a good decision to wait until now. But you're in a committed relationship. You trust him, he trusts you. So there's nothing to be ashamed about."

I nodded, still smiling to myself. 

"Thanks, girls. Well, I'm going to go shower and get in bed. I've got to go to this meeting with my dad tomorrow downtown."

"Alright, I'll talk to you guys later. VVB," Lucia said.

"G'night, VVB," Siena added before I hung up the call.

I sighed and rubbed my cheeks. They were hurting from all the smiling, but I couldn't control it. I was still on cloud nine.

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

395K 16.5K 26
She didn't reply and I felt her finger move across my skin, lower, and almost all the way down my lower back. A shiver coursed through my body, stran...
3.6M 87.9K 59
She looks up at me, taking a step forward and smiling slightly, "How can I ever get hurt when I have you here to protect me?" "But you could have got...
35.5K 1.9K 40
⚠ Mature content. ⚠ Follow up of my first (and worst) love story ever. Ash might have salvaged his friendship with Val, but when they start working...