Toby has dimples, so he'd rather not smile. He only does with people he trust and if you get him to smile when your not one of those people, you'll be in shock. Masky and Hoodie think its cute, Ben thinks their adorable and some others think their the cause of dying from cuteness. In all honesty he thinks he shouldn't smile a lot so he wont be teased.
Creepypasta Headcannons(w/ M...
Af Hufflepuff_Heaven
ENJOYYYYY Mere