{⚠ This Part contains Mature subject matter }
Tyler couldn't help but respond, not knowing why all of a sudden both of them wanted something they had avoided for so many years, but he wanted it, he wanted her. Things had been different from the moment they had woke up this morning, they had started fighting for the first time in years, and now all these flashes of their memories from the past were haunting both of them.
He wrapped his arms around her, as though they had done this a million times over. Deepening the kiss he reached for the door and shut it behind them pulling Bonnie in. Even Bonnie couldn't explain why she had suddenly felt the urge to be alone with him in this way.
Neither of them felt the need to speak any words as they kissed their way towards the bed. Tyler slid his hands up her thighs and laid her down on the bed. He let his lips gently caress the base of her throat and down towards her cleavage before he gave her tank top a tug then lifted it over her head.
Tyler didn't want to waste even a second of their time, feeling Bonnie's body shivering below him. He nibbled lightly down her chest until he came to her scar. For a moment his eyes fell into it, and more memories flashed before him. Not just of the times they had actually been in a very similar position, but other interactions between them, no matter how little or minor they were.
One particular memory tugged at him, he had been at Football practice with Matt, and he had glanced over at the cheerleaders, which he often did, but this time it had been Bonnie and Elena who had caught his eye, most likely due to something Matt had said about Elena. Tyler had only been able to see the back of Elena, but he had a full view of Bonnie as she was stretching out carrying on a conversation with her best friend. He remembered the braids Bonnie had in her hair that day, and the look of uncertainty at something Elena had said.
Bonnie's green eyes found Tyler's brown, taking him out of the memory and back to the present with an intense gaze as she ran her slender fingers through his dark hair, and then down his cheek. She could never find herself admitting how good he looked with this 3 day stubble, and a desirable thrill coursed through her body. Perhaps Tyler had always been hot, and perhaps she had always known it.
Her eyelashes fluttered, her breath already semi laboured. She knew Tyler would be hesitant to touch her scar, because he knew if anyone touched it, anyone at all it triggered her darkest years of her life, everyone but Tyler.
He gently pressed his lips against the scar, his fingers linked inside the band of her Laced panties and tugged them down her legs, not waiting for the chance for either of them to hesitate. Why couldn't he do this with the mother of his children?
His thoughts were interrupted by the feel of her toes pushing at the waist of his pants and he couldn't help but chuckle leaning up to capture Bonnie's lips in another heated kiss. He could feel his body responding to her , and hers to him, and after a hitched breathe he broke the kiss and helped her relieve him of his pants.
Letting his hands explore every curve of her body, Tyler's fingers danced there way along her arms, leaving a trail of tingles behind them.
Had he been with anyone over the years? Yes but nothing serious and no one had ever managed to have the effect Bonnie had on him. For the longest time he thought it was purely a physical attraction, or the fact they had made three beautiful children together. Hell maybe it was the fact that in the end Bonnie had actually been the first girl he had been with, and now she was a women, a very beautiful one at that.
In that moment Tyler still wasn't ready to admit to anything, except the way her body was calling to his. He couldn't be sure when this attraction had actually happened, but there was something about the way she danced around that room with their children that made him want her right now.
Intertwining his fingers with hers he pinned them above her head, sliding his already hard length deep inside her warmth.
Bonnie gasped tilting her head back as she squeezed his fingers and brought her legs closer to herself, she too had been with very few people over the past couple years, but she had also been growing closer to Jeremy. A big part of her had wondered if they could have another shot, but lately she had found Tyler on her mind more frequently then she'd like to admit.
Both Tyler and Bonnie found themselves in an aura of bliss and desire, and she had to let out a moan.
Pushing deep inside her Tyler let out a soft growl, more memories flashing through his mind as Bonnies head fell backwards with a moan.
Were they actually doing this? Bonnie was still trying to figure out what possessed her to come to him tonight, but her body had the urgency to feel his moving with hers. Her hands wanted to explore every inch of his body, but she couldn't he had her hands pinned above her head, and she liked that too.
Wrapping her legs around Tyler she pulled him closer, needing to feel him deep inside her, she wanted to feel the sweet taste of his kiss, she wanted to indulge in the comforting smell of his skin, which still smelt of the forest even when he hadn't been there in days.
She bit down on her lip hard as Tyler's kisses linger across the smooth skin of her neck, his grip on her fingers tightening as though she would be ripped away from him in the blink of an eye. I moan fell from Bonnies lips, followed by a whimper as he pushed his length deep into her, her body moulding to the shape of his, "fuck" Tyler groaned picking up his pace, he could feel the onset of his release building quickly, he hadn't realized how long it had actually been since he had even kissed a women, that was hard for the wolf in him.
"Ty.." Bonnie started with a gasp, only to be silenced with a kiss, she too could feel the build up inside of her crying to release.
The coil in her stomach was tightening already, a shiver dancing down her spine just as quickly as his thrust had become. Locking her ankles behind him Bonnies back arched slightly and she nipped at Tyler bottom lip, this only urged him further, a desperation seeping from his body as he captured her lips in an intense kiss.
His tongue slid along hers and she fought it for dominance, which only excited, and challenged Tyler. His hands released hers, allowing his fingers to explore her curves, dancing their way down her thigh. Each touch sent a chill through the nerves in her body despite the heat illuminating from the both of them.
Bonnies hands fisted the fabric of the blanket, on Tyler's bed, his hands tucking under her thighs and pulling her down the bed further. Bonnie flinched for a moment but the quick pain from a the sudden harder thrust was quickly replaced with an intense pleasure she hadn't felt in a long time. Her walls clenched and unclenched securely around Tyler's now throbbing length.
Neither of them could lie, this would be the fourth time they had ever been wrapped up with one another's body, and even their first time hadn't been bad for two inexperienced teenagers. Now they were adults, and had children, it only made the feeling that much more intense this time, or so it seemed.
Feeling his eagerness, and her own, Bonnie reached up clasping the back of Tyler's neck and pulled him into a passionate kiss, unspoken secrets being exchanged, secrets they themselves didn't even know they had.
Tyler broke the kiss, and slowed his thrust to stare at her, his dark brown eyes holding an intense gaze with her green ones. She truly had beautiful eyes, the kind that could see right through anyone and find the bad, pushing it back to make room for the good.
Tyler pressed his lips to Bonnie's once more, slow and gentle at first. It sent butterflies through her body and she deepened it entangling her fingers in the back of his hair.
Tyler's hands left her thighs and made there way up her sides, not breaking the kiss as he tucked his arms behind her and pulled her closer, lifting her body off of the sheets. The deeper the kiss became the closer both of them came to their release without even moving.
Tyler wrapped his arms tighter around her, sliding one hand up to cup the back of her neck, the other securely wrapped around her hips and started moving her along his shaft again, no gentleness about it as he hungerly thrust up into her.
Bonnie let out a loud moan that echoed through the room, her sex clamping tightly around Tyler's length, she couldn't hold on any longer as she reached the peak of her release. With a breathless moan of his own Tyler let himself go, both of them losing themselves to the desire of their bodies.
Breathlessly Tyler slowly let go of Bonnie's body letting her gently fall back onto the bed before flopping onto his back beside her, sweat glistening on his chest.
For several moments they just laid their together, not touching, not speaking. Even their minds were silent.
Still laying on the bed Bonnie closed her eyes, covering them with her hands "did we just do that?" she said moving her hands to cover her mouth, her lips still tingled from the last kiss.
"yeah I think we did" Tyler answered glancing at her then back to the ceiling.
Bonnie sat up sitting in silence again "I'm gonna go..." she said standing up as she searched for her tank top and panties.
Tyler propped himself up on his elbow watching her confused "Come on Bon, it wasn't that bad" he smirked.
Bonnie couldn't help but smirk back, in actuality no, it hadn't been bad at all, but it wasn't the fact that they has just had sex again, it was all the other variables, especially now that they were back in Mystic falls. "no" she shook her head "it wasn't, its not that Tyler..."
Tyler stood up and reached for the shirt Bonnie hadn't found yet and handed it to her "what is it? you didn't even run off like this after the first time we ever had sex..."
Bonnie's eyes found his and she couldn't help but get lost in them. When had their relationship become this?
"and you came to my room" He teased, shooting her that cocky grin he often used.
That grin that she couldn't help but actually kind of adore...a flash from their past flooded Bonnies vision interrupting her thoughts.
It was a memory from the founders day parade, the first one after Stefan and Damon Salvatore had first returned to Mystic Falls. Tyler had been on one of the floats, dressed in an old war costume, he had an actual smile on his face for that moment and he had waved like a fool at Bonnie.
A smile found its way across her lips, but the second she realized it she wiped her face clean of it.
"mmmhmm, I seen that smile Bonnie Bennett, what were you just thinking right now?" Tyler chuckled pulling on a pair of gympants.
"huh?... nothing.." She answered solemnly.
Tyler knew her better then that, especially now that they had been raising kids together for the past 5 years. "Don't lie to me Bonnie, especially when you suck at it" he teased
"fine" she sighed rolling her eyes "I was actually just thinking about that Founders Day Parade, when you were on the Battle float, just remembering how much of a dork you looked liked waving at me that day with that goofy smile you seldom show"
Tyler laughed lightly, closing the distance between them. He stroked her cheek gently before pushing a strand of hair out of her eyes, his own admiring her delicate features.
She let him, finding herself leaning into his touch as she gazed up at him, resting a hand on his wrist, the other pressed against his still bare chest. Tilting her chin up towards him, Tyler captured Bonnie's lips in a slow sensual kiss, using his free hand to pull her slowly closer to him.
Despite her thoughts on all the reasons they shouldn't do this, every part of her couldn't help but get lost in the moment and kiss him back.
When the kiss finally broke she couldn't look at him, "Tyler we shouldn't do this..."
Tyler pressed his lips to her forehead then tilted her chin up again to catch his gaze. "but why?" he asked, his tone soft.
He wasn't even sure why he wanted to know this answer so bad, he was sure like the times before; tomorrow they would wake up and go back to normal. So why did this time feel so different?
"it will complicate things" her words were barely a whisper, desperate to keep the new feelings inside her quiet. Just like her mind always managed to be in his presence, even when they were kids growing up.
Tyler had a way about him sometimes, underneath all that macho jock stuff, she was sure he never even realized the way he could manage to put some sense of humour into every situation.
Bonnie also knew the vulnerability Tyler always had about him, that side that only showed at very specific times in his life, to very limited people. He was always looking for approval, but he never had to seek that with her, and she never found herself seeking that with him, especially since they had the triplets.
"its not that complicated Bonnie" Tyler sighed, still unsure where all this was coming from himself.
"but what Bonnie says goes right? Goodnight Bennett." he threw his hands up and sat down on his bed.
"don't do that Tyler" she pleaded with a sigh. Since when was he so adamant to push their relationship further?
"don't do what?" he groaned rubbing his eyes
"don't push me away like that" she shook her head pulling on her tank top
"I'm not trying to push you away" he snapped
"yes you are Ty, I know that tone, and I know you"
"your the one that pushes people away" he snarled standing up "Actually, I guess you don't push people away because that would require you actually letting someone in!"
Bonnie shook her head and headed towards the door, "I'm not doing this tonight"
"of course not, you're just going to walk away, like you always do!" Tyler snarled, his eyes turning to that glowing yellow of his wolf, but only for a moment before disappearing as he sat back down on the bed, with a groan.
Why was this getting to him so much tonight? why did he give a shit whether Bonnie Bennett wanted to be with him or not? and what the hell made him want to be with her so bad all of a sudden after all these years?
Bonnie pressed her lips together closing her eyes with a sigh, and opened the door, "goodnight Tyler"
With another groan Tyler threw himself back on the bed, hearing the door shut. Picking up the pillow from behind his head he whiffed it at the door as hard as he could, with a light thud it fell to the floor, and he left it there.
"goodnight" he said under his breath before rolling onto his side, more confused then ever.