I Don't Want to be Right

By neverendingstory1820

690K 18.6K 3.9K

More

Drunk Sammy
At Bobby's and a Motel
Between Jobs
Distractions (Smut)
Handcuffs and Whips
Meant to Be
Starry Nights
The Nightmares
Author's Note
Cuddles
Illness
THANK YOU!!
Ordinary
Jealously
Werewolves
Despair
The Incident
The Morning
Stress Relief
Apologies
The Baby
On the Job
One Night Stand
The Angel
The Mistake
Caught
The Difficult Case
Dean's Birthday
Doing the Dishes
Objectifying
Punishment
The Break
The Break Part 2
Promise
Happiness
Coming Out
Payback (Smut)
Movie Night
Forever
Authors Note
Autumn Kisses
The Shower
Sandy Shores
I'm So Lost Without You
Weekend At Bobby's
The Last Beer
Inducement
New Year's
Pancakes
Deadline
AN
This is Halloween
Research
Haunted Date
A Thanksgiving Attempt
Love
Tickling and Cuddling
Answered Prayer
Protector
Ice Skating
Surprise! (mpreg)
Surprise! Part 2 (mpreg)
Surprise! Part 3 (mpreg)
Pour Some Sugar On Me
Confessions
Confessions: Epilogue
Just The Beginning
Handcuffs and Whips: The Smut
Author's Note
Please Don't Leave Me
Be Bold
Please Don't Leave Me: Part 2
Be Bold: Part 2
Never was Right
Teenage Mistakes
Authors Note *Please Read*
Dreaming of a Family
Be Bold Part 3
Teenage Mistakes Part 2
Too Far
Coming Out Part 2
Failure
Dreaming of a Family Part 2
Author's Note
Demonic Love
Rage Time
Father-Son Time
Pep Talk by Gabriel
Faith
Author's Note
Demonic Love Part 2
Rage Time Part 2
Fatherhood
Faith Part 2
Rage Time Part 3
We Take Care of Each Other
Fatherhood Part 2
Rage Time Part 4
Author's Note *Edited*
Demonic Love Part 3
We Take Care of Each Other Part 2
10 Facts About Me Tag
Two Timed
Drunken Confidence
Demonic Love Part 4
We Take Care of Each Other Part 3
Alone Time
I'm a Horrible Brother
Note...
Malec Oneshots!
Two Timed Part 2
Drunken Confidence Part 2
Dean's Girlfriend
Note
Demonic Love Part 5
Mystery Spot
Demonic Love Part 6
Into You
Hold Me Sam
Deaf
I'll Never Regret Loving You
It was an Accident
Authors note.
Deaf Part 2
Tag
Dean's Fear
Deaf Part 3
Baby
Undercover
Demonic Love Part 7
Brothers?
Author's Note
Undercover Couple
Heartbreak
Cheating
Cheating Part 2
Cheating Part 3
Note
Sympathy for the Samifer
Did I Force You?
Sympathy for the Samifer Part 2
Sympathy for the Samifer Part 3
Story Teller
The New Boyfriend
Sympathy for the Samifer Part 4
The New Boyfriend Part 2
Two Babies?!
Pregnancy of Team Free Will
Author's Note
Pregnancy of Team Free Will Part 2
Pregnancy of Team Free Will Part 3
Naughty
Author's Note
Pregnancy of Team Free Will Part 4
Trust Me, Love Me
Lucifer: Reborn
Crossdressing
Caught
Bloodlust
Caught Part 2
Bloodlust Part 2
Bloodlust Part 3
Caught Part 4
Dean's Secret
Dean's Job
Announcement
Bloodlust Part 4
Dean's Secret Part 2
Well.... (A/N)
Lucifer's Baby
Dean's Secret Part 3
Lucifer's Baby Part 2
Movie Marathon
I Can't Do This
Dean's Secret Part 4
Running Away
Dean's Secret Part 5
The Aroma of Sam Winchester
Dean's Secret Part 6
Regret? Never.
The Hot Tub
Am I Pretty Enough?
The Djinn
Cursed Love
The Secret Leviathan Dean Let Out
Fetish
Important Note

Caught Part 3

1.2K 38 8
By neverendingstory1820

I honestly don't have a good excuse for this being late. Truth is: my friend is letting me borrow her origin account to play sims 4, and she's on vacation, so I'm playing as much as possible until she comes back. 😂

"I can't believe this," Dean said. 

"Please, don't get upset," Sam asked. 

"Sammy, Cass, I'm not upset, I'm just shocked. How long?"

"Since we were kids," Sam answered, "I was always afraid of what Dad would do to me." 

"And I've felt something for you the moment I met you when I pulled you out of hell," Cass said. 

"And you guys kept this away from me for all this time?" 

"We were afraid of what you'd think. I didn't know if you were into guys, or would be grossed out by me, and I mean, Sam is your brother, so obviously he was worried what you'd think." 

"And we figured that since you told us about your crossdressing secret, we should tell you about this." 

"I've loved you both since I first met you, too," Dean said happily.  

"You mean you aren't going to choose one of us?" Sam asked. 

"How could I do that? It's an impossible choice," Dean answered. 

Sam smiled, "Well, Cass and I thought it was a pretty easy choice, actually." 

"What you do mean?" 

"Dean, I'm your brother," Sam said. 

"I don't care, I still love you." 

Instead of saying something, Sam grabbed Dean and pulled him into a tight hug. Dean hugged Sam back, and felt Cass wrap his arms around Dean, too. Somehow, Dean knew, no matter how messed up this thing was, it was going to work out. 

*** a few days later ***

Dean woke up to the feeling of lips pressing against his lips. He opened his eyes as they pulled away and was greeted by two bright blue eyes. 

"Good morning, Dean," Cass said in an impossibly deep and husky morning voice. 

"Morning, Cass," Dean answered, still slightly surprised by the wake up kiss. He looked around the room until his eyes landed on Sam, who was getting dressed and laughing to himself at Dean and Cass' interaction. 

"Get up, we're going to breakfast," Sam said. 

With a sigh, Dean got up and quickly showered. He dressed in a short black skirt and a light grey deep v-neck shirt. 

"What if people make fun of me?" Dean asked. 

"We'll protect you," Cass said.

"We'll make sure they regret it," Sam said at the same time. 

Dean smiled and walked out of the motel with his newfound confidence. 

The trio arrived at the diner and seated themselves. After a few minutes, a server came over. She looked at everyone, pausing on Dean for a second. She pursed her lips and introduced herself to everyone. She took everyone's orders and quickly left. 

"Did you see the way she looked at me?" Dean said worriedly. "She was so judgmental."

"I know," Sam said, "I'm going to say something when she gets back." 

"Something needs to be said, but please don't do anything stupid," Cass begged. 

"She can't do that to Dean," Sam snapped at Cass. 

"It's fine, Sammy, really, I'm okay," Dean said as the server came back with their drinks. 

Sam opened his mouth to say something, but saw that Dean was shaking his head. He decided to keep quiet. 

After a few minutes, everyone's food came out and they quickly ate. 

"For what it's worth, I think you look great," Cass said suddenly. 

Dean smiled widely, "Thanks, Cass, but you don't have to say that just because of what she did."

"I'm not just saying it, I mean it."

The server came back to ask how everything was. 

"Food was great, but I need to ask you not to look at my brother like that again," Sam said curtly as he paid the bill. 

"Well, I'm sorry that I found it odd that he's dressed that way," she huffed. 

"He likes what he likes, and shouldn't be judged on what he wears," Sam said as he stood up. Dean and Cass stood up with him and they walked out together. 

"Thanks, Sammy," Dean said gratefully as they got into the Impala. 

"I was going to say something, but you beat me to it, and truth is, you were kind of frightening just now," Castiel said with a smile. 

"She made me feel so dirty when she looked at me like that, and not the good dirty feeling, either," Dean said, making Sam laugh. With a smile on his face, Dean started the Impala's engine and they went back to the motel. 

I was going to write some smut, but I feel like it wouldn't fit here now, so we'll save it for next time. 😊



Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

538K 19.2K 94
The story is about the little girl who has 7 older brothers, honestly, 7 overprotective brothers!! It's a series by the way!!! 😂💜 my first fanfic...
1.2M 51.3K 97
Maddison Sloan starts her residency at Seattle Grace Hospital and runs into old faces and new friends. "Ugh, men are idiots." OC x OC
160K 5.7K 91
Ahsoka Velaryon. Unlike her brothers Jacaerys, Lucaerys, and Joffery. Ahsoka was born with stark white hair that was incredibly thick and coarse, eye...
1M 18.7K 43
What if Aaron Warner's sunshine daughter fell for Kenji Kishimoto's grumpy son? - This fanfic takes place almost 20 years after Believe me. Aaron and...