Idea Requested by fangirlingalloveryou
You stand in the back room aka the dressing room with about a dozen other girl trying to pull down the skimpy skirt you are currently sporting.
They so owe me. You think with a scowl as you internally cuss at the two Winchesters
The Winchesters plus you are currently working a siren case up in Oklahoma. Normally sirens stick to Greece but lately, monsters have been going crazy and well somehow one siren ended up in the States. The siren has been using this strip club to catch their prey and then lore them back to their house before they kill off the victim. So the Winchesters somehow convinced you to be the bait slash informative. The siren kept flip-flopping between being a customer before killing one of the dancers and being one of the dancers then killing a customer. So either you could find out which girl backstage is the siren or hopefully, you can be bait and get chosen by the siren to be their victim. Reluctantly you had agreed to their plan not seeing one better but now you are really starting to regret that decision.
The bright red colored cowboy boots accompanying with a red plaid bikini top and very tiny jean shorts the whole outfit making you feel quite uncomfortable especially since you have to dance in it in front of a bunch of people.
You look around the room where the group of girls is wearing similar outfits to yours. You try to look out and see if you find a girl that seems like she could be a siren trying to distract yourself from the huge pot of nerves in your stomach.
You weren't so nerves about having to dance half naked in front of a bunch of guys but having to dance in front of Dean, the guy you have been harboring feelings for is making you extremely nerve. You knew you would never see the other guys in the room again and Sam probably would be too focused on finding the siren to even see your dance but knowing Dean he will be front and center to watch.
You let out a sigh as you don't notice any of the girls standing out to you as the siren.
"Okay, girls, get lined up you are on in five and do any of you know where Candy?" yells the owner as he enters the room
When no one replies, the bald man lets out a sigh and turns away which is when you all get in line unaware of the person that just slipped into the room.
Dean sits exactly where you had guessed he would right in the room and center where he could see everything holding a bunch of money in his hands. An excited look is on the Winchester's face while he looks at the currently empty stage when his younger brother takes a set next to him.
"Okay, I checked my side of the room and I didn't see anyone suspicious." says Sam before he notices that Dean isn't even paying attention to him
"Dude." loudly says Sam as he sports his famous bitch face
"What?" asks Dean annoyed at his brother's interruption of him watching the stage
"Did you even check your side?" asks Sam referring to the fact the brother's had split up the room to look for the siren
"Dude, yeah." lies Dean as he rolls his eyes
Sam's eyes narrow at his brother suspecting that he is lying to them until the lights on the stage turn on and the announcer starts talking.
"Okay, everyone now it's time to get this show started. Remember no touching! That is the big rule here. So now we have clarified that it's time for the main event...Girls come on out." says the announcer through the intercom
One by one the girl's head onto the stage with the announcer introducing them to the crowd. Dean and Sam were paying attention mostly for the fact of trying to find the siren...well at least for Sam until you stepped out to the stage. Sam and Dean knew they would tease you about this forever.
They watch you step on stage and Dean's jaw immediately drops at the sight of you.
"Damn." mumbles Dean thinking you look extremely good right now as the announcer introduces you as "Crystal."
You walk down the stage with a fake confident attitude actually feeling like throwing up since this is a bit out of your comfort zone. You are a hunter, not a beauty pageant contestant. This is the first time you have ever even been on stage before.
Sam rolls his eyes at his brother while you pose with the rest of the girls at the end of the stage forcing a smile on your face.
Dean stares at you even as the announcer moves onto introducing more girls. Dean continues to stare at you until you look at him which causes him to look away.
Dean's eyes return to the center of the stage as the next girl enters making Dean's eyes widen. Though they didn't widen for maybe the reason you are expecting, they widened because this girl looked identical to you.
Dean looks back and forth between you and the identical girl introduced as "Candy" walks down the stage.
"What does that girl look like to you?" whispers Dean to Sam as who Dean is pretty sure is the siren
Sam looks at Dean confused.
"Uh, she has long blonde hair and brown eyes. Why?" says Sam
"That's the siren." says Dean with quite a serious expression
You stand back in the dressing after performing the sexy dance with the others. Luckily this one didn't involve any stripping but you might have done one or two pole dancing moves.
You quickly change back into the clothes you were wearing before you change into the awful costume and immediately feel quite better.
You look around the room to see that most girls are either gone or back on stage for their second performance until you notice someone interesting in the corner.
What is Dean doing back here? You think as you rush towards the green-eyed man
"Dean? What are you doing back here?" You question confused
"Dean" then looks at you with confusion.
"I'm not De-I mean I just came back to see my girlfriend and tell her how good she did." says "Dean" putting a flirty smile on her face
A confused expression is on your face until you realize that the man in front of you is not your Dean and that it's actually the siren. At first, you are taken back surprised by the fact that your deepest desire is Dean before you quickly push that away deciding that you need to focus and take the thing in front of you down.
"Oh, really? That's so sweet." You say with a fake smile and happiness
The siren smirks as it wraps their arms around you.
"Of course babe, you looked so hot up there. You are such a good dancer." says the siren getting closer to you as more of the girls leave the room
"Well, maybe I can give you a private show later." You fake flirt back with a wink
The siren's smirk grows before the siren presses their lips to yours. You have to force yourself from grimacing into the kiss as it's awful.
This thing maybe has Dean Winchester's face but does not have Dean's moves. You think as you remember the one kiss you shared back with Dean sadly though it was just for a case and the two of you haven't talked about it since
The two of you pull apart both of you fake smiling at each other which is when Dean and Sam sneak into the room using the doors behind you.
"Siren?" mouths Sam and you nod subtly as the siren doesn't even notice the two men behind
Dean gulps but steps forward with Sam both of them holding blood coated bronze daggers in their hands. Even though Dean knew it was a siren he still felt weird since it would look like he is killing you and not some monster.
"Okay, babe, let me grab my things and then we go." You say as you pull away from the creature
"Sounds good." says the siren which is when Sam pierces his dagger into the siren bringing some relief to Dean since he didn't want to be the one to kill this monster
"You....you bitch." shrieks the monster before it tries to lung for you but Dean tackles it spotting the monster
The monster spits at Dean before it finally dies.
"Well, that was....quite easy for once." says Dean with a shrug as he stands up wiping the blood in his hands off onto his jeans
"By the way Y/N hot moves." says Dean with a smirk but that is wiped off when you throw him a death glare and grab him by his flannel
"You bring anything of this up again and I will key Baby, you got it?" You threaten to make the man gulp knowing you are serious
"Got it." scrambled out Dean with a nod and you smile at him glad that you got your one way
Sam chuckles at you let go of the man before you head away towards the doors.
"Dude..." says Sam laughing
"Shut up." mumbles Dean shaking his head and glares slightly at his older brother as he follows you out the door
Sam and Dean sit in the front of the Impala and you are currently asleep in the back seat like you have been since they start the ride home.
"Dean, just curious, how did you know that Candy was the siren? I mean you didn't ask me about any of the other strippers." asks Sam curiously through his question makes Dean nervous
Dean uses the rearview mirror to check to make sure you are still asleep before he speaks next.
"Because Candy looked identical to Y/N and I knew Y/N was going to be introduced as Crystal so....I knew it had to be the siren." answers Dean softly making Sam's eyes widen
"Dude....you got to tell her about her feelings. I mean it's not some random reason why you saw Y/N. Plus you have been pining after her for so long now it's pathetic." says Sam causing Dean to roll his eyes
"I'm going to tell her once we get home." plans Dean with a burst of new found confidence but Sam just gives him a look of disbelief
"What? I am!" argues Dean
"Sure..." says Sam sarcastically before Dean glares at him
The three of you pile into the bunker after the five hour drive that you slept during. You weren't tired after the drive so you were watching some television in your room when Dean walked in.
"Hey." greets Dean with a nervous smile as he heads over to you
"Hey, can't sleep?" You ask noticing that Dean seems nervous as you sit up in your bed while Dean sits down on your bed
"No, it's..not that. I just I need to tell you something." says Dean softly as he gathers the courage to look into your eyes
"Okay." You say with slight worry in your voice
Dean lets out a shaky breath before he reaches out and takes your hand in his.
"I....I'm...uh, I have feelings for you Y/N. Like romance feelings." scrambles out Dean awkwardly feeling quite vulnerable right now
You look at Dean in shock because even though you had a crush on him, you never thought that the Winchester would like you back. You start to response happily to Dean's words ready to confess the feelings you have harbored for him so long until you remember what happened earlier.
"You aren't just saying this because of the dance I did earlier?" You ask with an almost angry look in your eyes finding his timing with this confession a bit off
"What?" questions Dean took back and slightly offended by your question
"No, of course not. I can't believe you would ask that." adds Dean with an upset expression
"Dean, you have to attempt you're timing is a bit weird. I mean you haven't showed these feelings before." You reason remembering the kiss you shared with him and how he wouldn't even look at you for a few days after it
"That's not true. I've showed these feelings before I mean..I mean I can't remember anything specifically right now but i know I must have somewhere in all the years I have been falling in love with you." replies Dean knowing that he should just put it all out on the table now since there is no turning back
"Then why tell me now?" You question confused still a bit worried that the man is only saying this because he has found a new attraction to you after your little performance
"Because I saw you as the siren Okay! There happy! This is why I'm telling you all of this because sure I knew that I had feelings for you but I'm not good enough so I kept them at bay. Though but after seeing that siren as you I can't anymore and I...I just had to tell you because all I can think about is you and being with you. It's driving me crazy. I'm crazy deep in love with and I just need to know if you feel even a fraction of the same." exclaims Dean knocking all the air out of your loves
"I-I....Um, earlier in the dressing room I knew who the siren was because it looked like you." You admit softly as you look into Dean's eyes and your words cause a spark of happiness to light in his eyes knowing what you seeing him means
"But he was a shitty kiss so he obviously got the man I love's looks but not his moves." You add with a smile as a grin forms on Dean's face
"Oh, is that so?" asks Dean as he moves his face closer to yours
"Well, I wouldn't want you to be stuck knowing that the last kiss you had was awful so how about I give you a better one?" asks Dean
"Sounds good to me." You answer with a smile before Dean presses his lips to yours
The kiss is soft and filled with all the feelings that both of you have been keeping back exploding into the kiss. The two of you to kiss before the attract that two of you have also been keeping at bay surfaces.
You then somehow get to the position of you straddling a now shirtless Dean as he lays on your mattress with your lips kissing roughly down his jaw. Dean lets out a throaty moan that makes you let out an low moan. You move so that your face is above Dean giving him a smile before you crash your lips onto his. Dean's hands tug at your shirt signaling he wants to take it off as the two of you kiss. You pull away from the kiss allowing Dean to take your shirt off.
"Aww, darn you don't have the plaid bikini top on." teases Dean cheekily causing you to shake your head while stifling a laugh
"Why did I have to fall in love with such a dork?" You ask teasingly with a smile
"I don't know, but I'm glad you did." says Dean not knowing what he did to deserve you
You smile at his words before you lean close to the Winchester and press your lips back to his.
The next few hours though didn't stay that sweet and PG-13 friendly......or with the two of you wearing any clothing.
_______________________________
I don't know how I think about the title but it's the best I could think of so 🤷🏻♀️