I Don't Want to be Right

By neverendingstory1820

691K 18.6K 3.9K

More

Drunk Sammy
At Bobby's and a Motel
Between Jobs
Distractions (Smut)
Handcuffs and Whips
Meant to Be
Starry Nights
The Nightmares
Author's Note
Cuddles
Illness
THANK YOU!!
Ordinary
Jealously
Werewolves
Despair
The Incident
The Morning
Stress Relief
Apologies
The Baby
On the Job
One Night Stand
The Angel
The Mistake
Caught
The Difficult Case
Dean's Birthday
Doing the Dishes
Objectifying
Punishment
The Break
The Break Part 2
Promise
Happiness
Coming Out
Payback (Smut)
Movie Night
Forever
Authors Note
Autumn Kisses
The Shower
Sandy Shores
I'm So Lost Without You
Weekend At Bobby's
The Last Beer
Inducement
New Year's
Pancakes
Deadline
AN
This is Halloween
Research
Haunted Date
A Thanksgiving Attempt
Love
Tickling and Cuddling
Answered Prayer
Protector
Ice Skating
Surprise! (mpreg)
Surprise! Part 2 (mpreg)
Surprise! Part 3 (mpreg)
Pour Some Sugar On Me
Confessions
Confessions: Epilogue
Just The Beginning
Handcuffs and Whips: The Smut
Author's Note
Please Don't Leave Me
Be Bold
Please Don't Leave Me: Part 2
Be Bold: Part 2
Never was Right
Teenage Mistakes
Authors Note *Please Read*
Dreaming of a Family
Be Bold Part 3
Teenage Mistakes Part 2
Too Far
Coming Out Part 2
Failure
Dreaming of a Family Part 2
Author's Note
Demonic Love
Rage Time
Father-Son Time
Pep Talk by Gabriel
Faith
Author's Note
Demonic Love Part 2
Rage Time Part 2
Fatherhood
Faith Part 2
Rage Time Part 3
We Take Care of Each Other
Fatherhood Part 2
Rage Time Part 4
Author's Note *Edited*
Demonic Love Part 3
We Take Care of Each Other Part 2
10 Facts About Me Tag
Two Timed
Drunken Confidence
Demonic Love Part 4
We Take Care of Each Other Part 3
Alone Time
I'm a Horrible Brother
Note...
Malec Oneshots!
Two Timed Part 2
Drunken Confidence Part 2
Dean's Girlfriend
Note
Demonic Love Part 5
Mystery Spot
Demonic Love Part 6
Into You
Hold Me Sam
Deaf
I'll Never Regret Loving You
It was an Accident
Authors note.
Deaf Part 2
Tag
Dean's Fear
Deaf Part 3
Baby
Undercover
Demonic Love Part 7
Brothers?
Author's Note
Undercover Couple
Heartbreak
Cheating
Cheating Part 2
Cheating Part 3
Note
Sympathy for the Samifer
Did I Force You?
Sympathy for the Samifer Part 2
Sympathy for the Samifer Part 3
Story Teller
The New Boyfriend
Sympathy for the Samifer Part 4
The New Boyfriend Part 2
Two Babies?!
Author's Note
Pregnancy of Team Free Will Part 2
Pregnancy of Team Free Will Part 3
Naughty
Author's Note
Pregnancy of Team Free Will Part 4
Trust Me, Love Me
Lucifer: Reborn
Crossdressing
Caught
Bloodlust
Caught Part 2
Bloodlust Part 2
Caught Part 3
Bloodlust Part 3
Caught Part 4
Dean's Secret
Dean's Job
Announcement
Bloodlust Part 4
Dean's Secret Part 2
Well.... (A/N)
Lucifer's Baby
Dean's Secret Part 3
Lucifer's Baby Part 2
Movie Marathon
I Can't Do This
Dean's Secret Part 4
Running Away
Dean's Secret Part 5
The Aroma of Sam Winchester
Dean's Secret Part 6
Regret? Never.
The Hot Tub
Am I Pretty Enough?
The Djinn
Cursed Love
The Secret Leviathan Dean Let Out
Fetish
Important Note

Pregnancy of Team Free Will

1.7K 44 22
By neverendingstory1820

Well, earlier this week, I found out Heath Ledger has been dead for ten years. He was one of my favorite actors as a child. I loved the movie A Knight's Tale when I was like 6 or 7. (Yes, I was a weird child). I felt crushed, then listened to some Bowie, after remembering he was also dead, so I'd never be able to see him or any of his songs from 2016 live, I gave up on the night and went to bed.

Suggested by: PrincessPeach211

Sam didn't have much explanation for it, but he just felt that he was pregnant. It had to be impossible, but in order to ease his mind, he went to the doctor. Shockingly, the doctor actually confirmed his thoughts. Some now, by some miracle possibly, Sam was pregnant. The first person he wanted to tell was Dean. He quickly went home after his appointment.

Dean wasn't anywhere in the motel room. Left on Sam's bed was a note.

Sammy -

Went out for a bit. Be back soon.

-DW

Sam sighed, he wanted Dean to be home now. Acceptance of his pregnancy already settled in, as he'd already convinced himself before going to the doctor. Now he was excited. He wanted to tell the world, he wanted to celebrate.

Not long later, Sam heard the Impala pull up outside the motel room. Sam watched from inside as Dean got out of the car. The passenger door opened, and Cass also stepped out. Sam wasn't surprised. Dean liked Cass' company on trips when Sam wasn't available. Both of them, though, looked confused and upset over something. They walked up to the motel in silence.

"Hey, Dean, I have something important to tell you," Sam said when Dean and Cass walked into the motel room.

Dean looked at Cass, then at Sam. "We have something important to tell you too. You first."

"I'm pregnant, Dean," Sam said confidently. Dean and Cass looked at each other with equally shocked faces.

"Um, Sammy. I'm pregnant too," Dean said.

"As am I," Cass said.

"What? This is insane," a surprised Sam said.

"Who was the last person you had sex with?" Dean asked Sam.

"Gabriel," Sam answered, a twinge of red appearing on his cheeks. "You?"

"Gabriel," Dean said back. Sam and Dean both looked at Cass.

"Gabriel," Castiel answered.

"Gabriel, get your feathery ass down here," the three said simultaneously.

The sound of feathery wings was apparent in the room as Gabriel appeared. Immediately, he knew what was going on, and that he was in trouble. He tried to disappear as quickly as he'd appeared, but it was too late.

"Explain," Dean boomed. "You cheated on all of us with each other. That's low, man."

"Did you think we'd actually never find out?" Sam continued.

"Father would not approve of this," Cass interjected.

"Guys, look, I'm sorry," Gabriel pouted. "I love each of you. There's no way I could choose Dean over Cass, or Cass over Sam. You each mean so much to me. I didn't want to let any one of you go. I didn't want to mess up this badly, though. That one's on me. I should've known that you'd all be angry. I'm sorry."

Sam, Dean, and Cass thought about what Gabriel said. They each loved him dearly, too. Dean looked up at Cass, then moved his gaze toward Sam. He could tell they were all thinking the same thing. Maybe, just maybe, this could actually work out. It's not like they don't get along. They're all best friends. Sam gave Dean a quick nod. Dean looked back at Cass, who also nodded.

"Gabe, we forgive you," Dean sighed, "We all love you, and we're willing to see if this will work out. It's worth a shot."

Gabriel gave Sam, Cass, and finally Dean each a big smile.

"Thank you. I promise that I will never try to lead any of you on again. I don't want to lose any of you, and I will be there, for all of you, through the birth and raising of our children," Gabriel said sincerely.

Sam was the first to hug Gabriel, Dean and Castiel quickly followed.

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

15.5K 935 102
"who are you?" "castiel. who are you?" -purposely lowercase [completed]
31.7K 1.5K 25
There is no escape for Castiel. The hell he lives in offers him no solace, and he has come to terms that this is the way his life will always be. Whe...
2.9K 111 20
I opened up to him. He knew my darkest and deepest secrets. And he still spoke with a smile as he said, "I love you." X