Saved From Fangirls -
Aries - Masky
Taurus - Bloody Painter
Gemini - Puppeteer
Cancer - Homicidal Liu
Leo - Ticci Toby
Virgo - Jeff The Killer
Libra - Sally
Scorpio - BEN Drowned
Sagittarius - Jane The Killer
Capricorn - Smile Dog
Aquarius - Clockwork
Pisces - Slenderman