"How did you know it was my birthday?" I asked Niall.
"How could anyone forget?" He replied smiling
"Connar forgot.." Those words just slipped out, and I regretted it right when I said it.
"Well he's stupid and doesn't-" I cut him off because I didn't want him talking about Connar like that.
"Well he's still my boyfriend"
"I know" he said frowning but covering it up with a fake smile.
•••••
About 2 hours later
The party was pretty much over and everyone had left except Niall.
Connar's P.O.V.
Tiffany hadn't texted me back so I decided to swing by her house. I noticed an unfamiliar car parked in her driveway. I walked up to her door and knocked and I couldn't believe who answered. I don't know his name, but I do know that he practically beat me up over Tiffany. So why is he at her house?
"You?" I asked trying to sound tough but failing.
"Me" he said smiling.
"Hey Niall, who's at the doo-" Tiffany asked as she walked in the living room, she stopped as she noticed who it was.
"Tiffany, what is he doing here?" I stated angrily.
"Well he threw me a party for my birthday.."
"When's your birthday?"
"Today"
I instantly felt bad when she said that, I had no idea that it was her birthday.
"Babe, I'm sorry I forgot"
"It's whatever"
"Do you wanna stay tonight? I promise I can make it up to you"
I wanted more than anything for her to say yes and she did. I felt like turning around and yelling to 'Niall' to leave and that she loves me, not you. But I knew Tiffany would get mad.
•••••
In the car
Tiffany's P.O.V.
We had been in the car for about 5 minutes and Connar finally broke the silence.
"Why was he over?"
"I already told you"
After that, it was silent again.
We pulled up into his driveway and I noticed that his parents cars weren't there, so they must not be home. We went inside and watched movies all night.
•••••
In the morning
"Are you like, not even mad that 'Niall' basically beat me up?" Connar asked
"Of course I was.."
"Was? So you're not mad anymore? Wait, never mind. Of course your not mad anymore or else you wouldn't have been hanging out with him at your house yesterday." His facial expression read 'that came out meaner than it was supposed to' but I didn't care, it made me mad.
So I just got up and left. I walked home while he was yelling for me to come back, but I refused. As I was walking home a way too familiar car started to slow down beside me. Yep, it's Niall.
"Need a ride?" Without saying a word I walked around and got into his car.
"Something happen with you and lover boy?" he asked smiling. That boy..
"Uhh, yeah kinda" I asked not even bothering to look at him.
"That's too bad" he stated, still smiling.
I never really noticed how blue his eyes are. I guess he noticed me looking at them, because the first thing he did was look at me and smile.
"Sorry.." I said awkwardly
"Don't be"
We drove right past my house and I don't know why.
"Where are we going?"
"My place"
The funny thing is, I didn't object. I was pissed and Connar and I know how much he hates Niall so I can go to his house if I want to. What's he gonna do, call me and yell at me? Pshh.