Aries: The killer
Taurus: wonders off to explore the creepy house
Gemini: jumps at every sound
Cancer: tells everyone that this was a bad idea
Leo: The brave one
Virgo: tries to be a hero
Libra: Goes missing first
Scorpio: Is secretly helping the killer
Sagittarius: Screams a lot
Capricorn: Tries to call for help but loses cell phone
Aquarius: Calls out to the random noise they heard
Pisces: Tries to hide in non obvious hiding spots