No doubt in my mind that my favourite scene happened in Season 1 after Shay and Dawson had responded to a call where Shay's ex-girlfriend was at the house. Shay discovered that Clarice was now married to a man and expecting.
That however, was not my favourite scene. My favourite scene was later in that episode when Shay was talking to Kelly about Clarice. She then went on to say, "Turns out I may have over-estimated her lesbianism."
I found this downright hilarious and it is totally something Shay would say which is why it's my favourite scene. I found it so fantastic and after I watched this episode all I could say was that line. Looking back it maybe wasn't the best idea but it was just so good! I couldn't not repeat it!