Emily and Alison are in their mid 30's for this story. They live together and are married.
Emison kids:
Brandon DiLaurentis Fitz (Ezra is the biological father bec. Alison got drunk at a high school grad. party and slept with Ezra) - 15 Years old
Callie Fields DiLaurentis (Jason is the biological father bec. Emily got drunk at a high school grad. party and slept with Jason) - 15 years old
Isabella and Arabella - 10 year old twin girls (Adopted by Emily and Alison when they were babies)
Brandon's POV
My sister Callie and I have been trying to figure out who my dad and who her dad is for 3 years now. Callie and I are twins well not by genetics but in our hearts we are. Callie and I were both born on March 21. My moms name is Alison and her moms name is Emily. Alison and Emily are our moms.
We also have younger twin sisters named Isabella and Arabella. They are 10 years old and our moms adopted them when they were babies. It's a sad story and the twins don't exactly know the truth because they wouldn't understand. Hours before Isabella and Arabella where born their dad was driving their mom to the hospital because she was going into labor. At the time their birth dad was drunk. They got to the hospital but by ambulance because he had gotten into a crash. Isabella and Arabella's mom only survived long enough for the babies to be delivered. Isabella and Arabella's dad went to Jail and wouldn't be getting out for at least another 5 years.
Callie and I are in the spring semester of Freshman year at Rosewood high. I play basketball, baseball. I learned how to play the piano, the guitar, and I can sing as well. Callie is more into dramatic arts so she takes acting and singing more seriously then I do. Our mom's went to the same school. Callie and I even have some of the same teachers that they had. My favorite is our English teacher Mr. Fitz. He is also a family friend. My moms have him over every other Sunday for dinner. Tonight was one of those nights. Before dinner I overheard my mom Alison talking to Mr. Fitz.
"Now that Brandon is 15 I think it's time to tell him the truth." Ezra said
"What truth, I am his mother and Emily adopted him." Alison said
"I want Brandon to know. It's been 15 years now and I can't even do one father/son activity with him." Ezra said
"You have Malcolm and Katie. You don't need my son as well." Alison said
Katie Fitz is 15 like Callie and I. She is in English class with us and Callie is friends with her.
"Malcolm is 21 now and he only comes home from NYU a few times a year. Katie prefers to be with her friends over me." Ezra said
"In cause you don't know Katie is upstairs with Callie right now." Alison said
"That can't be true. Katie is supposed to be with her mom. Ever since Aria and I divorced 7 years ago she got Katie for the weekends." Ezra said
"It is true Ezra. If you don't believe me go see for yourself. Katie slept over her last night and the night before to. I think you need to talk to her and ask her why she's avoiding her mom." Alison said
"I can talk to Katie if you talk to Aria." Ezra said
I learned a lot from overhearing this conversation. I can't believe Mr. Fitz is my dad. One mystery solved and one more to go. Maybe I can figure it out for Callie. She already thinks I'm the best sibling ever.
Callie's POV
I was in my bedroom with my best friend Katie. Katie's mom is friends with my mom and Katie is only 2 months younger then me so we have been friends since childhood. My phone rang and it was Katie's mom. I hit decline because now wasn't a good time to talk.
"When's the last time you talked to your mom?" I asked
"A few weeks ago why?" Katie said
"Your mom just called me." I said
"If she calls again answer it and tell her I'm not here." Katie said
"Why are you avoiding your mom?" I asked
"It's not my mom that I'm avoiding. It's my step dad." Katie said
"I don't get why you hate him so much. That's my mom Alison's brother." I said
"Jason thinks that he has control over me but he doesn't. The other day he tried to tell me who I could and couldn't be friends with. The person he doesn't want me being friends with is you." Katie said
"Why is that?" I asked
"The last time I was there I heard my mom and him talking about how if you found out this secret it would change everything." Katie said
"You need to find out that secret Katie." I said
"Did you ever find out who your dad was?" Katie asked
"Nope, 3 years and I still have nothing." I said
"This may sound crazy but what if Jason is your dad?" Katie asked
"I never thought of that but he's Brandon's uncle so that would be kind of weird." I said
General POV
Ezra walked into Callie's room and found Katie.
"You are supposed to be at your mom's house right now Katie." Ezra said
"Dad, I promise I will go to mom's next weekend. Please just let me stay here or go home with you." Katie said
"I am driving you to your mom's right now. Aria already called me in a panic thinking you ran away." Ezra said
Katie and Callie said goodbye. Ezra returned 30 minutes later for dinner. At the dinner table Brandon was about to spill that he knew the truth.
"I know the truth about who my dad is." Brandon said
"You told him." Alison said looking at Ezra.
"No, he must have overheard our conversation earlier." Ezra said
"Mom, I overheard and I'm sorry but it's something I have been wanted to know for years." Brandon said
"Mom, is my dad Jason DiLaurentis?" Callie asked
"How did you guess?" Emily asked
"Katie said she heard her mom and step dad talking about a big secret." Callie said
"Yes, it's the truth. I was drunk at a high school graduation party and I slept with Jason. Alison and I were not dating at the time but we were close friends so we decided to live together and raise our kids." Emily said
"Brandon I guess it's time I tell you the truth. Ezra was dating my best friend Aria at the time. I got drunk at the same party and Ezra was there with Aria but she went home early. Ezra and I slept together that night." Alison said
"It was only a one time thing. I didn't tell Aria but she found out on her own 7 years ago and that's why we got a divorce." Ezra said
Isabella and Arabella didn't say anything because they didn't know how to react to the news. In the months and years after Brandon did some father/son bonding activities with Ezra and even got to know his half sister a little better. Callie has gotten to know Jason as her dad and she even calls him dad instead of uncle. Callie and Jason have father/daughter bonding weekends. Callie and Katie are still best friends and their friendship is stronger. Now that Katie's mom is Callie's step mom they act more and more like sisters.
What did you think about this one?
Votes and Comments mean everything to me plus they help me write faster. The more Votes and Comments I get, the faster my stories will be updated.
Please give me some more ideas for "PLL Story Book". You can give me your idea in the comments or by sending me a private message.
Next PLL Story Book chapter is called "Love, Pray. Heartbreak". It is a Spoby story. Spoby is married and they will be 25 years old with a 5 year old daughter. Spencer is stressed out with work, her marriage, and trying to raise her and Toby's daughter. Spencer turns to drugs. Will Toby be able to help her before it's to late? Will he lie to protect her when something dramatic happens to Spencer? If Toby's lies for Spence he would put his job at risk and may face legal trouble himself.