"He's telekinetic," she whispered.
"He's gorgeous," the other girl added.
"He's a criminal!"
"That's never stopped you before."
•••
The love interest could be Lydia, Kira, or Malia or you could change it and make a Scott, Derek or Stiles fanfic.
If you've seen X-men you'd remember that gambit was the card trick dude in wolverines origin movie, but you can change and mold the story line to whatever you'd like.