Slenderman:
There was no doubt that you had a fear of heights, it was one of the reason you rarely let Slender pick you up seeing as how high off the ground you would be. Sitting in his office at the manor, he started to think it would be slight fun to use this fear of yours to scare you. He loves you dearly but he thought it would be a fun little idea, nothing that would cause any harm. You were sitting outside the Creepypasta manor, you sat on the porch steps watching as Ben, Sally, and Jeff played with Smile as they all soon ran to the back of the manor, leaving you alone. As you sat there fiddling with your fingers you didn't notice your boyfriend teleport behind you.
Suddenly something wrapped around your ankle and pulled you up into the air. You screamed, fear coursing through you as you looked down at the ground. Looking at the thing that had picked you up with wide frightful eyes, you soon narrowed them when you saw Slender's faceless face. "Put me down" you said, crossing your arms as you glared at him. Doing as he was told he quickly sat you down and bowed his head as you turned away from him.
"I'm sorry [Your Name], I love you" Slender mumbled as he wrapped his long arms around you. Biting your lip you tried to stay mad at him but couldn't help but turn and hug him.
"It's alright, just don't do it again or I swear to God I will break those long legs of yours" you threatening jokingly, causing him to laugh a little.
Jeff the Killer:
Jeff loved trying to scare you, but it never really worked in his favor at times. You either didn't noticed and when you did you didn't seem to react. Finally you were able to fall asleep and get the well needed rest you longed for without having to use your sleeping pills. While you were fast asleep on the couch, Jeff entered your home, like usual your parents where away, they never really did like staying home that much. Walking into the living room he spotted your sleeping form and his everlasting smile widens even more.
Slowly he walked over to you before leaning real close to your sleeping face and taking in a deep breath he released a loud scream, causing you to jolt awake and throw your fist up towards Jeff, landing a perfect hit on his almost invisible nose. Jeff stumbled backwards, crying out in pain as he held his face. "Oh God, Jeff I'm sorry I didn't know it was you!" you exclaimed as you sat up and tried to comfort him.
"Shit, [Your Name] that hurts! I expected you to get scared not punch me!" Jeff grunted in pain.
"I'm sorry, it's just a natural reflex; I love you so much I didn't mean it" you said hugging him tightly while burying your face into his chest. Jeff sighed and wrapped his arms around you, before blushing as you leaned up and kissed his nose which was beginning to bruise.
Laughing Jack:
Laughing Jack always found it amusing that you had a fear of spiders. Every time there was one in the room, big or small, you would run out of the room and beg him to kill it. Which he never did of course, he usually scoop them up and throw them outside. Today he wanted to scare you, just terrify you and what better way to do that then give you a pet spider as a present. Wrapping the box up in black and white wrapping paper and poking a few holes into it he carried the box which held a full grown tarantula in it.
He walked into your room to find you reading, something you usually do when bored, yet you never showed much interest in the books you read. You looked up at him with a raised eyebrow as you looked at the box in his hands with suspicion. "What's in the box?" you asked as you watched your boyfriend shake with suppressed laughter.
"Just a little gift for you" Jack said, holding the box out for you as you took it from him. Sitting it on your bed, you pulled the wrapping paper off and opened the box before screaming as you saw the tarantula crawling around the bottom of the box. It's legs raising and lowering as it walked. Jumping up you ran out of your room and into the hallway.
"Kill it!" you whined as you shivered at the thought of that disgusting creature giving birth in your room or even staying in it.
"Come on, [Your Name]. It's not going to hurt you" Jack cooed as he walked over to the box and picked up the spider.
"Kill it now!" you hissed at him, before watching in horror as he shrugged his shoulders and stuck the spider in his mouth. Biting down a disgusting 'crunch' was heard that made you shiver. "You are getting no kisses for an entire week!" you exclaimed.
"Oh come on baby, I know you love me too much to go that far without kissing" Jack said, smirking as he licked his lips.
"Oh watch me you deranged, handsome clown" you said before turning on your heels and walking down the hallway, leaving a laughing Jack to follow after you.
Eyeless Jack:
For some reason you had an unnatural fear of loud noises in the dark. Something Jack found out when you had flinched after he dropped a bowel that broke in your apartment one night while you were watching a horror movie. It fascinated him how you could handle horror movies but not a simple noise in the dark. This of course, gave him an idea on how to scare you. It was midnight, you were snuggled under your covers, not hearing your bedroom door creak open.
Jack had stayed over for the night, taking the couch as a place to sleep to give you your privacy. Slowly he tipped toe over to your bed side and held the air horn he had bought earlier that day. Waiting for a while he pressed down on the top and listened as the horn released a loud shriek that jolted you awake with a scream ripping past your throat. At first he started to laugh until he heard you whimpering, freaking out seeing as he didn't want to upset you he quickly pulled you into a hug and tried to comfort you. "I'm sorry, I love you" he said, repeating the same words over and over as he calmed you down.
Ticci Toby:
Toby didn't know you had a fear of snakes and because of that he didn't know the little garden snake he had found would scare you so much. You were waiting for him at the park; you two were going to spend a day together. Sitting on one of the park benches you hummed lowly while waiting for your boyfriend. You soon heard that familiar ticking sound that you had grown so fond of. Turning to greet your boyfriend you froze and stared at the small green garden snake that coiled around his arm.
It hissed lowly as its black beady eyes stared at you, causing you to shiver as you stood up and took a step back. "[Your Name], look at this snake I found" Toby said, smiling at you before frowning as he saw fear in your [Eye Color] eyes as you were shivering. "What's wrong?" he asked, taking a step forward only to have you take a step back.
"Toby, I love you but please get rid of that snake before I lose it" you said, your voice strained and laced with fear. Looking from the snake to you he nodded his head and threw the little guy towards some bushes close by and walked over to you.
"Sorry, I didn't know you had a fear of snakes" Toby whispered as he twitched before enveloping you into a hug.
Masky:
If there's one thing you didn't like it was when people sneak up behind you. You always like to know where people are in a room so you don't freak out if one of them walked up behind you. Masky of course didn't know this, so why you were busy heating up some leftover pizza from yesterday you didn't hear your masked boyfriend as he quietly walked into the kitchen and towards you. You swayed back and forth on your feet as you watched your food go round and round before releasing a high pitch scream as someone grabbed your sides. Turning quickly with wide eyes you locked eyes with Masky's wide blue ones as he stared at you.
"Masky!" you exclaimed, as he raised his hands in defense.
"I didn't mean to scare you, I just wanted to surprise you" he said quickly as you placed your hands on your hips. "Promise, I love you baby" he said, as he grabbed your hands and pressed his masked forehead against your own. Looking at him you nodded and smiled back.
"Alright, you're forgiven" you said, smiling at him.
Hoodie:
Hoodie knew you had a deep hatred for anything horror related, horror movies, horror games, even those stupid YouTube videos were something popped up at the end. So he decided to have a little fun as he sat you in front of your computer with a video pulled up on full screen, not letting you see the name. You pursed your lips as you looked at him before facing the monitor again, a little suspicious by all this. Soon Hoodie pressed play and the video started, there seemed to be nothing wrong with it as it was just a car driving down a road. "Hoodie what's the-" you started to ask before yelping and pushing the computer chair backwards away from the screen as a horrifying image popped up with a loud screech.
"Nope" you said over and over as you pushed yourself further and further away from the computer as Hoodie chuckled. "Not funny" you whined as your boyfriend walked over to you and wrapped his arms around you, laughing when you childishly buried your head into his chest.
"S-sorry [Your Name], b-but you k-know I l-love you" Hoodie said, you couldn't stay mad since that stuttered of his made him sound so adorable.
Dr. Smiley:
If there's one thing Smiley learned, it was that you hated needles, just completely hated them. He found this out when you had paled at the sight of one of the syringes he had left out in the open in his room. Currently you were reading one of his medical books while sitting on his bed, though you didn't really seem that interested in it that much. He smirked as he walked over to you and plopped down next to you, causing you to look up. "[Your Name]" he said.
"Hm?" you hummed in acknowledgment.
"You know flu season is coming up, right?" Smiley asked as you nodded your head. "And that means you need to get a flu shot" he said, holding his laughter back when you slammed the medical book shut, face pale and eyes wide with fear as you looked at him.
"What! No, I'm perfectly healthy I don't need a s-shot" you said, stuttering the last word as you shivered. Not able to hold back his laughter anymore, Smiley fell over, clutching his stomach as he laughed. Looking at him for a minute your face soon grew red with embarrassment and anger. "It's not flu season at all!" you exclaimed, grabbing his pillow and started to beat him with it.
"Hey, come on baby. I love you!" Smiley exclaimed through his laughter as he tried to block your attacks.
"I love you too but you still have to pay!" you exclaimed as you hit him square in the face with the pillow.
Ben Drowned:
Ben didn't know what you were afraid of, but that wasn't going to stop him from scaring you. Multiply times he had asked you what scared you the most and each time you never answered him, knowing what he was trying to do. One day why you were messing around on your phone outside, you furrowed your brows as it started glitching. "Come on, work you stupid thing" you mumbled as you tighten your grip on it, not wanting to accidentally throw it and break it. Soon it started to screech causing you to wince before screaming as Ben popped out through the screen.
"Oh, I didn't mean to scare you" Ben said, laughing as he stood in front of you while you clutched your heart and tried to calm your breathing.
"Jerk" you growled as Ben laughed harder before hugging you.
"Aw, I love you too babe" he cooed as you just growled at him causing him to smirk a little.
Bloody Painter:
If there's one thing you didn't expect, it was for Helen to try and scare you. Of course he didn't mean it; he just didn't expect you to freak out so much when he walked up behind you. He's done it so many times before and of course you jumped but never fully screamed. You had just finished a shower and was in the kitchen looking for something to eat as you dried your [Hair Length] [Hair Color] hair with a towel. Of course you forgot that he was here and was in your room drawing.
He had his mask on today since he had came over after killing one of his latest victims so when you turned around you didn't expect to see him standing there in his mask. You flinched and screamed as you dropped the glass bowl to the floor, shattering it. "God, Helen, you scared me" you said, clutching the kitchen counter with wide eyes.
"Sorry" he said as he walked over to you and lifted a mask to press his lips against your forehead. "Love you" he mumbled.
"Love you too, now help me clean up this mess" you said.
Dark Link:
If there's one thing Dark liked to do, it was scare you. He'd always come up with new ways to do it but his most favorite way to do it was to jump out at you. It always worked for some reason, especially when you weren't expecting it. Just like today, you were coming home from a friend's house; you expected the house to be empty since your parents were at a party, so when you entered the home. You couldn't help but tense up when you heard footsteps walking around upstairs.
Shutting the door and with caution walk up the stairs, all the lights were still off as you walked down the hallway. Before you could react your bedroom door was swung open and a loud scream ripped past your lips as you didn't expect Dark to jump out. "Fuck, you scared the shit out of me!" you exclaimed as he threw his head back and laughed.
"Oh man, your face that was priceless" he said through his laughter as you growled at him.
"Oh, shut up!" you snapped as you crossed your arms and pouted.
"Aw, baby, come on you know I love you" Dark said as you just turned away from him and started to walk down the stairs with Dark following close behind you, saying 'sorry' over and over through his laughter.