He's in love with you preference.
Scott:
"He knows he's lucky to meet someone like you." He knows your boyfriend is lucky to have you in his life. He just wish it was him that you loved.
Stiles:
"You can always change your mind, and you can't change mine." He wants you to get to know him, and maybe fall in love with him in the process, but even if you don't, he will love you no matter what.
Isaac:
"Maybe I'm a shot in the dark, and you're the morning light." Yes, he knows you usually don't go for guys like him. Yes, he knows you have your "dream boyfriend", but he feels like you should give him a chance. Even though if you do, your friends will think you're crazy.
Jackson:
"He never made it through a day of school. The only thing he studied was you." You had every class with him, so when he wasn't texting Danny about you, he was learning every curve of your body, what made you happy, sad, mad. Even though his grades were slipping, and was being closer to being benched a game, he could care less, because he knew one day he would make his move on you to make you his.
Derek:
"You could be the best for me, when I'm the worst of you." He makes you so mad and aggravated, and he knows it. He has a bad boy rep, and wont give it up. He wants you, no matter what he has to give up. He know he would be better of with you.
Aiden:
"Maybe this is sad, but true. Baby, maybe you've got nothing to lose." Just one try is all he's asking, and he knows he sounds desperate, but he needs you in his life.
Liam:
"Maybe I'm your Mr. Right. Baby, maybe I'm the one you like." He has this feeling in his gut that you two were made for each other, and he will not let it go unless proven wrong. He knows it could be everything either of you wanted.
After the next song preference, Theo will be added to the preference list.