Certainty | TSITP

By t0n1c0r3

22.9K 484 50

After Analise's summer in cousins, her best friend Jeremiah makes her return in hopes to find his brother, an... More

O N E .
T W O .
T H R E E .
F O U R .
F I V E .
S I X .
S E V E N .
E I G H T .
N I N E .
T E N .
E L E V E N .
T W E L V E .
T H I R T E E N .
F O U R T E E N .
A/N
S I X T E E N .
S E V E N T E E N .
E I G H T E E N .
N I N E T E E N .
T W E N T Y .
E P I L O G E .

F I F T E E N .

870 28 4
By t0n1c0r3

A/N: Woooowwww I am so sorry for the long break. It's been so busy recently. I'm gonna try, and hopefully, post (at least) one chapter a day from now on. I hope you enjoy. 🖤























After the teens woke up, and cleaned their mess they all made their way to the house again. Everyone was quiet and tired, and... sad.

Ana and Conrad walked up to the house side by side. He had a small smile on his face after their conversation the night before. He was relieved to get it off of his chest.

"Look who it is." Jere said as they stopped and looked to Julia and the real-estate agent.

The other woman walked past the teens muttering a small hi before getting in her car and driving away quickly.

Jere and Ana shared a quick Look before he grabbed Belly's hand, trying to make it obvious to Ana... which it was.

"Oh, I wish you boys had gone home when I asked you to." Julia huffed.

"You're not getting us to abandon our house, Julia." Conrad spoke, with a confident smile.

"It's not your house, Conrad. And uh... it won't be mine for long either. A buyer has made an offer on the house and I've officially accepted it. I have to go to Boston to finalize some details but... it's done. The house is sold." She replied, obviously a little upset.

Everyone was silent, Ana was so shocked. She didnt realize the woman would actually go through with selling her sisters favorite place. Her nephews favorite place..

"Please... they have an idea." Ana pleaded gently, a look of pain crossing her face.

This was her boys place... their home. Their literal heart. She felt so awful for them.

"It's done." She repeated.

Ana looked to Conrad as his face dropped and his eyes watered. She grabbed Conrads hand and looked to the ground.

"Well this can't just be over..." Jere tried.

"It is. I'm gonna need your keys, please." She cut in quickly.

"I'll bet you're really enjoying this." Conrad said, taking his key off of the keychain and handing it to the woman.

"Mom... don't do this."

"Skye, really?" The woman sighed, "I told you two I was selling the house. You just refused to believe it. And I'm not enjoying it, but I will admit that I'm relieved it's finally over."

"How could you even say that to them?" Ana scoffed, looking up to the woman, with teary eyes, "how- how heartless can you be?"

The woman looked at the young girl surprised by her words. The only time the girl talked to Julia was when she comforted her for a moment last night. But now...

The woman looked to the ground and pushed past all the teens without another word.

~

"Okay, so, I know things aren't going so great..." Jere started when Ana felt a buzz through her phone.

She looked down and saw a text from JJ.

'Im on my way :).'

Ana smiled widely and set her phone down, finally returning to the conversation after texting him a short message back.

"I'm sorry, I tried to get her to call off the deal." Skye said sadly, walking into the house.

"Don't be, at all. It's not your fault." Ana said.

"I know... but shes my mom, so I would get it if you guys were angry at me, too." They replied.

"Hey, no one's mad at you Skye." Jere sighed, giving them a side hug.

"So what... we're supposed to go home now?" Steven piped in.

"Yeah, it's over." Conrad snapped.

"Conrad..." "No." belly and ana spoke at the same time, sharing awkward glances with each other.

"Listen, our last memory here cant be... this." Belly said, "everyone miserable and defeated? I mean this place deserves a better goodbye than that."

"Like what?" The older fisher boy asked.

"Like! Like a party!" Ana said eagerly, "like a I don't give a fuck, do what you want, leave a mess for Julia party!"

Conrad and jere both looked at the girl, smiles growing slowly.

"I'm in."

"Me too."

"Me three!"

"I think it's exactly what my mom would've wanted." Conrad laughed.

"She'd love it." Jere smiled widely.

"Great! Okay, everybody, shower, Power Nap, and then I am putting you to work!" Belly laughed, as everyone dispersed.

"Hey... Ana?" Taylor started, pulling the girl aside.

"What's up?"

"I saw you smile at your phone... like really smile. Can I ask what that was about?" Taylor semi teased, lightly shoving the girls shoulder.

"Oh... uh." She cleared her throat awkwardly and smiled shyly, "I invited my friend, JJ."

"Is JJ actually only a 'friend'?" Taylor rolled her eyes, wanting to hear more.

The girl thought for a second, not knowing the answer. I mean, she was 'with' him, but she wasn't at the same time. They weren't really anything...

"I don't know..." she laughed.

"Okay, okay... anyway, I'm excited to meet him." Taylor giggled, walking away from the girl and upstairs.

Ana stayed in the kitchen for a moment longer, making herself a quick cup of coffee as Jere awkwardly walked in.

"Hey." She smiled.

"Hey..." Jere responded, Ana looked at him weirdly making him sigh lightly, "so... belly-"

The girls eyes widened when she realized what he was going to talk to her about. She knew they were together in a way... but she didnt understand why. After what they had at the beginning of this trip, why was he doing what Conrad did to her last summer? Why was he picking belly?

"Yeah, I've taken notice." She let out a breathy laugh, not even looking to him.

"... are you okay with it?"

"Why wouldn't I be? We aren't dating, we're best friends."

The boy felt like he had just gotten punched in the stomach, all of the air leaving his lungs as a lump formed in his throat. He thought that maybe he had been reading their friendship wrong, once again... and it pained him to know that he might not actually have a chance with her.

"Yeah, duh..." he started, looking away from her as well, "you and Conrad?" He asked, obviously upset.

Ana looked at him as if he was crazy, she scoffed loudly and stopped what she was doing to look at him.

"Me and Conrad what?"

"You two are back together?"

"No."

"Then what are you guys doing?"

"What are you talking about?"

"Jesus, Analise! You don't even realize?" He laughed bitterly, and watched as her eyes squinted in confusion.

Obviously she knew what he meant, but she was pissed that he would even be slightly upset at her for being close to Conrad again... when he had belly.

"You guys have been growing 'close' again. Did you forget that he left you last summer? Lied to you? Micro cheated on you, and then micro cheated on belly with you?"

"Jere." The teens heard and turned to see a visibly angry Conrad in the doorway.

"Hey, we were just talking..." Ana muttered quietly.

"Yep." Jere hummed, in agreement.

"Yeah, I heard you. Everyone can, really. Why are you talking about this like it's any of your business?" He snapped at his brother, walking further into the kitchen.

"It is my business-"

"No, it's not. It's mine, belly's, and Ana's." The boy took a deep breath before starting again, "and if you see that we're moving past it, or trying to why are you bringing it back up?"

"You left her! Alone! You put her in your back pocket and decided to focus on Belly!"

"Yeah, and what are you doing now?" Jere looked between his brother and Ana, wondering what he could've meant by that.

"What are you talking about?" He asked.

"You're literally doing the same thing to her now! You were all lovey dovey when you guys first got here, holding hands, constantly together, all over her at the boardwalk, but out of nowhere you are all over belly! Can't keep your hands off of her! Ana... can I talk to my brother alone?" Conrad ranted, in a semi whisper-yell type of thing.

"Yeah." The young girl sniffled and wiped her eyes a little before looking between the boys and walking upstairs without another word to either of them. She hated this.

She hated the fact that again she was the one that had caused a fight between the boys. When everything seemed to be getting better.

"What Conrad? What could you possibly want to say?"

"Ana told me that she thought you guys had something. That she was a little upset to see you and belly randomly start something... then you come in here and berate her for being... there for me?" Conrad shook his head, disappointed in his brother.

"She said that?"

"Yeah... she also talked about how belly thought that Ana was competition but it's the other way around... jere, I know I don't deserve Ana, and maybe you're just trying to make her see that so she doesn't get hurt again... I don't know. But I do know that if I don't deserve her, you don't either."

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

14K 308 32
"I want you, why can't you see that?" "You don't want me, Jeremiah" The last thing on Rowan Park's mind is a relationship. After her recent breakup...
52.4K 567 14
what happens to shelby, mostly known as "shels" who has trouble figuring her feelings for her childhood crush while she visits her mothers best frien...
198K 3.3K 44
I don't wanna hurt you but you live for the pain. Female OC x Jeremiah Fisher (1) The Summer I Turned Pretty TV series fanfic Started: 07/09/2022 Com...
18.3K 231 25
Summer has arrived, but already Kristin Fisher is feeling a change in the atmosphere. From her oldest brother's bad mood, to it feeling like the who...