*5 years later*
"Love, Did you remember Elijah's friend Riley's coming over?" I asked.
"Yeah. Hey, did you remember Katie and Brittany are going out to the park?" Nate asked.
"Yeah." I said.
I felt him behind me and I turned around.
"Hey. Can you imagine that this entire thing started cause I wanted to mess with Benji?" I asked.
"Well now this thing is your real boyfriend and 2 kids." He said laughing.
"And I wouldn't have it any other way" I said smiling.
At 4 PM Riley's dad Cian brought over Elijah and Brittany's mom Sally brought Katie.
"Mom when can I have a boyfriend?" Katie asked.
"Maybe when your 25." Nate said.
"But he'll be my fake one." She said.
"Then of course not. How do you think me and your father met?" I asked. "Look at you. Your 5, your brothers 3, I'm not married."
Just then. My brother, sister, and parents showed up.
"Hey. What are you guys here for?" I asked.
Chrissy's daughter, Lizzie pointed at Nate. He was down on one knee.
"What's this?" I asked.
"Madeline Elenora Minehart." He started. "Ever since we met I've loved you everyday. So will you make me the happiest man on earth. And be my wife?"
I was in shock to see him open a little box with a diamond ring in it.
"Yes." I said through my tears. "Yes, yes, yes!"
He got up and tried to put the ring on my finger and saw the ring he gave me 5 years ago.
"You still wear it?" He asked.
"Of course I do." I said.
He took off the ring and put on the new one.