We were in Percy's cabin hanging out when a question popped into our 'Ask Us' website, making our monster-proof computer ding. We went to it and read the question. . .
Percy and Matilda Smith (me as I am also a daughter of Poseidon): A raw fish!? No way! A rotten egg obviously. If I choose raw fish, I could be eating Nemo! Everyone! Choose rotten egg or else...
Heather Miller: Raw fish!
Percy and Matilda glared at Heather. However, Heather did not notice and continued talking.
Heather: Because Salmon is a type of raw fish and I love Raw Salmon!
Matilda: Heather! Just because you are my best friend does not mean that I let you of the hook!
Heather backs away slowly from Matilda and accidentally bumped into Percy.
Percy and Matilda: Attack!
Heather winced from the shout as she was right in front of Percy, while Percy and Matilda pounced on Heather with pillows in our hands and started hitting it on her.
Piper *uses her charmspeak *: Matilda and Percy, stop hitting Heather and go back to where you were just now.
Percy and Matilda returned to where they used to be and groaned: PiPeR!!
Annabeth: A rotten egg because if I eat a raw fish, Lord Poseidon might be angry at me. Thus, not allowing me to date Percy anymore.
Hazel, Nico and Jason: Rotten egg as Uncle Poseidon/Neptune might drown us if we say raw fish.
Piper: I don't actually want to eat any because I am vegetarian, but if I am forced to choose one, I will choose raw fish as Heather's reasons are good and Salmon is something that is actually edible and you won't die.
Calypso: A rotten egg as I do not want to anger Lord Poseidon or else he might put me back on the island.
Leo: Raw fish. This is because I can use my firepower to make raw fish grilled fish, but I cannot make a rotten egg become a fresh egg using my firepower.
Frank: I . . . Am going with Piper but the other option. I won't want to eat any, but if I'm being forced to choose. I will choose rotten egg as I am scared of Lord Neptune.
Kassandra: I would choose the raw fish as I Like raw fish and I am scared that I will fall sick after eating the rotten egg.
Matilda and Percy: Yay! Rotten egg won!