the exception [pin hawthorne]...

By cathschapters

46.7K 1.5K 509

~ in which olivia collins fears pin drifting away from her when he joins holloway riding school also in which... More

~the exception
chapter one
chapter two
chapter three
chapter four
chapter five
chapter six
chapter seven
chapter eight
chapter nine
chapter eleven
chapter twelve
chapter thirteen
chapter fourteen
chapter fifteen
chapter sixteen
chapter seventeen
chapter eighteen
chapter nineteen
chapter twenty

chapter ten

1.9K 78 30
By cathschapters

a/n: hi yall, id like to start off by saying thank you so much to those of you still reading my fic and i am so so sorry for the irregular updates. i have to say i was planning on being done with this fic much sooner but i am officially done writing it now yaaay which means i will hopefully be able to finish updating this fic by the end of the year. love you guys so much and thank you for reading i really hope you're enjoying this story <3


"Are you sure this is a good idea?" Olivia asked, rubbing her arm. They were right in front of the tent Olivia had helped set up earlier, and she could hear the muffled music blasting from inside. They were definitely late, and Olivia hoped Zoe wouldn't mind too much.

"Of course! Everyone will think you look amazing, and Pin will realize he's been an absolute idiot," Emma replied.

"But it's Zoe's birthday, I feel like I shouldn't be making it about me," Olivia replied. From what she'd understood, turning sixteen was a big deal to Americans like Zoe.

"We're not making it about you Via, you're just showing up looking amazing and having a good time. The rest will happen on its own," Emma assured, linking her arm through Olivia's.

"All right," Olivia breathed out, more to herself than anything as the pair approached the tent. She brushed her curly hair from her shoulder, letting it bounce gently to her back. Emma held her free hand up, opening the tent flap letting the music stream out. Emma stepped in first, followed by Olivia. She hadn't been expecting so many people to be there, Zoe usually wasn't one for big parties. Olivia looked around, spotting Zoe towards the side, talking to Pin. Of all the people she could've been talking to, Olivia thought to herself. She knew she couldn't just walk in without greeting Zoe, so with a deep breath, she walked over to Zoe, her heeled boots clicking annoyingly with every step.

"Zoe! Happy birthday! Sorry for being late," Olivia said, decisively ignoring Pin as she hugged Zoe.

"Oh my god Olivia you look... Wow you look amazing!" Zoe exclaimed, taking in Olivia's uncharacteristic outfit. Olivia quickly glanced at Pin despite herself, granting him a small wave before she turned back to Zoe.

"Thank you so much, but you look even better!" Olivia said, returning the compliment. "Where do I drop off your gift?" she then asked, holding up the gift bag she'd been carrying in emphasis.

"Oh, you can just--" Zoe started, but was cut off by an angry looking Marcus.

"Is it true?" he asked Pin angrily. Pin looked back in confusion.

"Is what true?" he asked. Oliva's eyebrows knitted in confusion. What was Marcus mad about?

"You got into the academy and you turned it down?" Marcus said accusedly. Pin sighed deeply, and Olivia looked up at him in confusion.

"Yeah, it's true," Pin gulped.

"Wait, why didn't you go?" Zoe exclaimed. Olivia only stayed silent.

"I know why," Marcus said seethingly. "Because with me gone, you could have Zoe all to yourself."

"Seriously Marcus? This again?" Olivia said. Marcus spared her a glance before turning back to Pin.

"Wait, what do you mean again?" Zoe asked, turning towards Olivia. The latter stayed silent, looking down at her feet.

"Don't you know?" Pin said in mock amusement. "Marcus is the one who called Holloway. He told them we were there and that's why we were caught," Pin revealed. Marcus's eyes went wide.

"Marcus, is that true?" Zoe said in shock. "And you two knew? And you never told me?" she added, turning towards Pin and Olivia, who rubbed her arm in disappointment. She should've told Zoe, but she'd thought there'd be less trouble if she just kept it to herself. Well that backfired.

"Oh come on seriously Zoe?" scoffed Pin. "Olivia was just trying to do you a favour."

"Well she didn't," Zoe said dryly. "Next time, don't meddle in things that don't regard you," she told Olivia. Olivia looked up at her, her vision blurring slightly.

"Fine," she said, her voice wobbling. "Happy birthday anyways," she said, shoving the gift bag into Zoe's arms and storming back out of the tent.

"Oliva? What happened?" she heard Emma's voice behind her.

"I'm fine, I just need to be alone right now," Olivia sniffled.

"Alright, call me if you need anything," Emma said, hugging her quickly.

"Thank you," Olivia said earnestly before turning back around and heading for the beach. It was quiet outside, save for the rustle of the leaves in the cold wind, making her wish she'd brought a jacket. She considered turning around and simply heading back home, but she really wanted to be alone. Gradually, the sound of waves crashing grew louder and nearer, and before she knew it, Olivia was on the beach. She took off her boots, feeling the sand beneath her skin. She approached the water, letting the waves wash over her feet. She closed her eyes and breathed in deeply, feeling the cold air on her face. Gently, she brought her hand up to wipe her tears. Even with her eyes closed, she felt it when Pin arrived next to her. He stood there silently, and Olivia debated what to do. Should she leave? Should she just stay there and pretend she hadn't noticed him there? Maybe she should talk to him, but she wouldn't know what to say if she did.

"Are you cold?" she heard him say quietly.

"No," she simply replied calmly. They both kept quiet for a bit longer, before Olivia spoke up. "Why didn't you go to the academy?" she asked.

"Didn't want to," Pin replied after a moment.

"Why not?" inquired Olivia.

"Couldn't leave the island, I would miss it too much, the people here too," he said. Olivia nodded gently, humming absentmindedly. "I'm sorry for telling Zoe that Marcus gave us in. I was just so mad at him and... I'm sorry."

"It's okay. Not your fault I make bad decisions," Olivia said.

"You were just looking out for her," Pin said. "It's not your fault Zoe takes everything personally." Olivia only hummed in response. "Look, about yesterday, you were right, I had no place to get mad at you like that." Olivia's eyes finally fluttered open. "I just feel like I'm losing you."

"You could never lose me Pin," she simply said. Damned what Emma said, even if he didn't reciprocate her feelings, Pin was her closest friend, and she wouldn't leave him even if it meant living with that. She turned her head slightly towards him, finding him studying her intently. "Well, I have to get back to Bright Fields," she said after a moment.

"I'll walk you," offered Pin.

"Thanks," softly smiled Olivia. As they walked together in silence, Olivia's thoughts drifted off to the boy beside her. If you'd told her at the beginning of the summer that she'd become this close to Pin Hawthorne, she never would've believed it. She remembered barely being able to utter a sentence in his presence only a year ago, and now she was calling him her best friend. And they'd kissed once. She didn't really like recalling that memory. Not because it was a bad one, but because of the thoughts that followed. The thoughts that reminded her that Pin had regretted it.

"What are you thinking about?" asked Pin, striking Olivia with an eerie sense of deja vu. You, she wanted to say. And she did.

"You," she said shortly. She had practically confessed her love the other day. If he didn't know she liked him yet, he was truly oblivious.

"What about me?" his breath hitched almost imperceptibly.

"Just about how close we've grown this summer," she said nonchalantly. "We weren't very close friends before."

"Right," he said. He muttered something else Olivia didn't catch. They reached Bright Fields, and Olivia bid Pin goodbye before walking into the mostly empty stables. Almost everyone was at Zoe's birthday, which is why Olivia was surprised to bump into Mia.

"There you are!" she exclaimed. "I was going to tell you at Zoe's party but well, you left rather abruptly. Anyways, the girls and I talked this morning, and we decided to keep you on the team," Mia said.

"Oh, that's awesome, yeah, thanks, I appreciate it," Olivia said, smiling brightly.

"Right, well, tomorrow is friendlies, do you think you'll be ready then?" Mia asked.

"For sure, no problem," Olivia said.

"Alright, see you tomorrow," Mia said. Olivia took out her phone and called her aunt to tell her she would be getting home later than usual. She made her way to the tack room, taking out the spare riding clothes she always kept there and changing into them. She brought Nina out to the training paddock, practicing a new routine as the sun set behind her.

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

100K 2.8K 21
~in which the arrival of zoe philips turns olivia collins' world into a flurry of horse thieves and heartaches šš™šš’šš— šš‘ššŠšš šššš‘šš˜šš›šš—ššŽ šš” šš˜ššŒ šššš›...
16.4K 207 10
Zoe Phillips left her life at bright field stables behind after getting an offer from the American riding team. That includes her friends, her boyfri...
90.6K 2.1K 23
in which an old friend returns to town, secrets will come out, old relationships will unfold and most importantly, love makes it entrance. a maxine b...
20.6K 369 26
Whenever something huge changed in books, movies, and television shows, nobody ever expected it. In dystopian settings or natural disasters, nobody k...