Madelaine Petsch as Julia Evans
"They hate me. There's not much I can do with that."
Drew Starkey as Rafe Cameron
"You left. You left when I needed you the most. I begged you not to leave but you did. Now you're back as if nothing happened?"
Rudy Pankow as JJ Maybank
"You sleep with me and now you're back like nothing? The reason you slept with me was to get over him, wasn't it? Did it work?"
Madison Bailey as Kiara (Kie) Carrera
"You broke his heart when you left. You used him."
Austin North as Topper Thornton
"Juls, you're my best friend and you know that. But he's also my best friend and I can't continue seeing him like this."
Madelyn Cline as Sarah Cameron
"It's good to have you back. I've missed you. You're practically like my other half."
Jonathan Daviss as Pope Heyward
"I don't want to sound like an asshole right now but you're practically kook royalty. I don't think JJ needs any more drama than he already has going on right now."
Chase Stokes as John B Routledge
"He's my best friend, Julia. Don't break his heart. Please."
Sadie Sink as Jessica Evans
"You're the most annoying person ever, but I love you."
Jessica Chastain
↳ Naomi Evans
Jensen Ackles
↳ Andrew Evans
The rest of the Outer Banks cast as their representative selves.