First of, this was hard.
Judging criteria:
Text (clarity, font, etc):5
Picture(the cover picture):5
Matches theme:10
Overall: 10
5th position:
WhereIsMyNargle !
Marking:
Text (clarity, font, etc):3
Picture(the cover picture):3
Matches theme:8
Overall:5
Total: 19
Look, the cover's text were tiny, I couldn't see it properly without my contacts on and my power is minimum. The picture just seemed a bunch of pics picked from google and made a collage, sorry. It matched the theme of the book, surely! It didn't give a good impression. It felt it was amateur and saying from experience, I wouldn't pick that book up. So, I'd say change it! Get a graphical artist, let them share their ideas with you and I'm sure it'll be amazing. I hope you aren't disheartened :), here take a chocolate : 🍫.
4th position:
leximiller08
Text (clarity, font, etc):3
Picture(the cover picture):3
Matches theme:9
Overall: 6
Total: 21
Look, the text seemed as if it was put with boredom. The picture seemed a straight up collage from google / Pinterest. It matches the theme of the book! The overall impression wasn't very nice, it felt as if the writer didn't put any effort for a cover, how will they put effort for writing? So, I'd say change it! Get a graphical artist, let them share their ideas with you and I'm sure it'll be amazing. I hope you aren't disheartened :), here take a chocolate : 🍫.
3rd position:
swachchatoya983
Text (clarity, font, etc):4
Picture(the cover picture):4
Matches theme:7
Overall: 8
Total: 23
Not gonna lie, the cover was very nice. It was aesthetic, the coffee made me drawn towards it, along with the iPhone. It didn't match the theme though. It wouldn't occur to a reader that it was a poetry book. It was really nice and I felt an argue to read the book but when I saw the description and I comprehended that it was poetry, I felt a bit.. let's say disheartened. But I'm sure if you put something related to poetry it'd be brilliant! I hope you aren't disheartened :), here take a chocolate : 🍫.
Runner ups: TIE!
We'll go alphabetical order !
Text (clarity, font, etc):4
Picture(the cover picture):3
Matches theme:10
Overall: 8
Total: 25
First of, it's amazing. Now, the text was nice, visible and everything! The picture, it lacked proper lighting. Even if it were a dark themed one, the faces were not visible nicely. It matched the theme, perfectly! And it gave an overall nice impression. Here, take a chocolate :🍫.
I'll PM you the sticker asap !
Text (clarity, font, etc):5
Picture(the cover picture):5
Matches theme:7
Overall: 8
Total: 25
Now, i would be lying if I said I didn't love the cover. It was brilliant! The text was amazing, the picture was fabulous, it showed something I value: EFFORT but the draw back, it didn't match the theme. I wasn't able to understand, just by seeing the picture whether it was literature related to not. It felt it was a story of a human or something similar. It gave a nice impression but not that it was a book full of amazing poems. I'd say you change that part, keep the layout! Here, take a chocolate : 🍫. I'll PM you the sticker asap!
WINNER:
_rehyaa
Text (clarity, font, etc):5
Picture(the cover picture):5
Matches theme:10
Overall: 8
Total: 28
First of, I LOVED IT! The text was clear, it was so so pretty! The picture made me awe, it was very beautiful! It matched the theme, it was romantic, it had an overall amazing look, I would've given full but hehe, I'm very mean. Here have a chocolate: 🍫.
I'll send you the sticker asap! LOVED ITTTTTTTT!